A Sitting in St. James

A Sitting in St. James

Rita Williams-Garcia

Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:

An unmissable tour de force from three-time National Book Award finalist and Coretta Scott King Award–winning author Rita Williams-Garcia, who memorably tells the stories of one white family and the enslaved people who work for them. Essential reading for teens and adults who are grappling with our country’s history of racism. This astonishing novel about the interwoven lives of those bound to a plantation in antebellum America is an epic masterwork—empathetic, brutal, and entirely human. 1860, Louisiana. After serving as mistress of Le Petit Cottage for more than six decades, Madame Sylvie Guilbert has decided, in spite of her family’s indifference, to sit for a portrait. But there are other important stories to be told on the Guilbert plantation. Stories that span generations, from the big house to out in the fields, of routine horrors, secrets buried as deep as the family fortune, and the tangled bonds of descendants and enslaved.


From the Forum

No posts yet

Kick off the convo with a theory, question, musing, or update

Recent Reviews

Your rating:

  • Apr 06, 2025
    Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:

    Typed a whole review and it disappeared on me….

    This was an intricate and interesting novel that explored and informed on a tremendous variety of topics, including race, slavery, French Creole, Louisiana plantations, romance, army, and antebellum Louisiana. There are overlapping character arcs, relationships, and family trees, blending and blurring the lines between the enslavers and the enslaved, though with the caveat that Madame Sylvia was committed to her French roots and “society.” 

    Lucien, Sylvia’s son, runs the plantation, which is quickly going into debt, and seeks out any opportunity to irritate his mother. He has two children who feature prominently in the story. His son, Byron, was probably my favorite character. A student at West Point who is home for leave to officially propose to his betrothed, Byron is actually gay and has brought his lover home from school with him, passing him off as a good friend. His half-sister, Rosalie, is the product of lust and power, a forced intercourse between Lucien and her mother, an enslaved woman. Rosalie is fair-skinned and beautiful, a blight on the family from her grandmother’s perspective and the crux of Lucien’s plan to restore the family name while making his mother crazy, seeking to arrange a marriage between Rosalie and a wealthy free black man in the town. 

    The overlapping storylines are well-crafted with occasional flashbacks in time. I certainly could have benefitted from a physical copy of a family tree to reference, but overall, I am incredibly satisfied with the narration of the audiobook and the character voices she used (with the exception of Jane, the family friend who sounded like a robot or a sociopath). 

    If you liked…
    Conjure Women - antebellum South, multiple perspectives and timelines, focused on women and atypical voices 
    The Great Believers - family saga, time jumps, diverse perspectives, homosexuality
    Commonwealth - intergenerational family saga with sibling drama and tension

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • View all reviews
    Community recs if you liked this book...