Recs if you like The Broken Girls...

Book(s) of the Month(s) 📚

by kassidy
📚
📆
🏅
5
Station Eleven
The Almost Nearly Perfect People: Behind the Myth of the Scandinavian Utopia
The Unquiet Dead

Mysteries and Thrillers

by aleenolilo
🔪
🩸
🔎
1
My Husband's Wife
It's Not Her
This Story Might Save Your Life

Totally Normal Boarding Schools™

by curiousmoth
🏫
😱
🧑‍🎓
26
Wilder Girls
Don't Let the Forest In
The Spirit Bares Its Teeth

Atmospheric Autumn for Goths

by jovialdebris
🍁
🌒
🌉
3
A Study in Drowning
Ninth House
Rouge

Goodreads "Horror For Beginners"

by MindlessMoose
☠️
🖤
🌹
0
Never Whistle at Night: An Indigenous Dark Fiction Anthology
Midnight Rooms
Strange Beasts

Spooky Season Reads

by Stephlove.reads
👻
🎃
🔪
7
The Spellshop
Immortal Dark
The September House

Horror for Beginners 🩸

by mels_reads
🩸
🔪
👻
0
A Dowry of Blood
The Broken Girls
House of Hunger

Spooktober & Autumn Vibes

by BusyMomReadsItAll
👻
🎃
🍁
0
My Best Friend's Exorcism
The Ghostwriter
How to Survive a Horror Story

books that feel like you were watching a movie

by Gremmy
🎥
🏔️
🎬
3
Ariadne
The Woman in the Window
This Poison Heart

horror

by safeaslife
👻
🕸️
🫣
0
The Troop
The Twisted Ones
The Hollow Places

Simone St. James Reading List

by BookKenz
😮
👻
🫣
0
The Broken Girls
The Sun Down Motel
The Book of Cold Cases

BOTM 2018

by Annie_509
🌙
🔍
📖
0
The Broken Girls
The Woman in the Window
The Great Alone

IRL Book Club Picks

by amfrek
👥
📚️
💼
0
The Broken Girls
The Final Girl Support Group
Little Gods

february 2026

by safeaslife
📚️
💌
👓️
0
The Broken Girls
Spiral
The Defense