Recs if you like Once More with Feeling...

This list features books with covers designed by New York-based, Houston-born designer Cassie Vu. She is a Senior Designer for Penguin Random House's art department. Her covers boast loud, bold lettering and striking colour gradients. Her website features a "cover graveyard", showcasing different iterations of covers that were ultimately chosen, which I highly recommend perusing.

Needs to be own voices and feature a Jewish main character

romance that, in some way, has a theatrical element

For when you’re In the mood to feel nostalgic about your Jewish upbringing!