Recs if you like Under Loch and Key...

no third act breakup!

by helloitsjo
β€οΈβ€πŸ©Ή
🫢
🫑
8
Powerless
Wild Love
Reckless

The Monster Smash

by erintripsey
πŸ‰
🌢️
🐺
18
The Dragon's Bride
Ensnared
Impromptu Match

silly reader, eggs aren’t just for breakfast!

by maomi
πŸ₯š
πŸ†
πŸ”ž
53
Found by the Lake Monster
Contagion
Serpents of Sky and Flame

Aardvark Book Club master list

by naomi.reads.world
πŸ“š
πŸ“ͺ
πŸ€“
0
Ithaca
The Night Ship
The House in the Orchard

cozy fantasy🧸

by read.with.melanie
🧸
☺️
πŸ’›
0
A River Enchanted
A Daughter of the Trolls (A Numina Parable, #1)
Assistant to the Villain

Knots, Ruts, & (Weird) Shifter Butts πŸ₯΅

by PowahWom
🌢️
😈
🦝
9
Smash & Grab
Feathers So Vicious
Love is Trash in Hallow's Cove

The 'Dirty' Book Club 😘

by mariangello
πŸ’—
πŸ₯°
πŸ“š
2
Before I Let Go
Butterfly Swords
Faking Christmas (Christmas Escape)

Paranormal Boo-ty Call

by mariangello
πŸ§›
🐺
πŸ‘»
4
Do Your Worst
The Fake Mate
A Witch's Guide to Fake Dating a Demon

Paranormal Romance

by Persephoness
🐺
πŸ‘Ή
πŸ§™β€β™€οΈ
0
Phantasma
Fairydale
Vesselless

men that sound like the song 'delicate'

by ausra
πŸ’–
πŸŒ™
✨
0
People We Meet on Vacation
Don't You Forget About Me
The Everlasting

Monster Smash

by DJWinterJamz
πŸ‰
πŸ™
πŸ§œβ€β™‚οΈ
0
The Dragon's Bride
Ice Planet Barbarians
Stalked by the Kraken

5.0 Human ❀️ Non-Human Romance

by Alice_World
🌢️
❀️
πŸ’¦
0
A Hunger Like No Other
Minotaur Sugar Daddies: A Monster Romance
My Minotaur Daddy (Tales of the Arcane)

Monster Smut: Cryptid Edition

by PowahWom
πŸ’•
πŸ‘»
πŸ”ž
9
Sweet Berries
Gotten by the Gator
Kissed by the Krampus

Flirting with monsters

by Coffeefiend
πŸ§œβ€β™‚οΈ
πŸ§›
🌢️
1
A Witch's Guide to Fake Dating a Demon
Bride
A Rivalry of Hearts

sea salt kisses

by kinga
πŸ–οΈ
β˜€οΈ
πŸ’‹
3
Happy Place
Good Girl Complex
Just for the Summer

Cryptids & Crushes

by Daci_FinalGirl
😍
πŸ‘½
πŸ‘»
4
Do Your Worst
Love and Other Conspiracies
Fan Service

Books with puns in the title

by cute.bloody.reads
πŸƒ
🫢
πŸ‘¨β€πŸΌ
3
Wolf Gone Wild
Always Practice Safe Hex
Witches Get Stitches

MC's who are mid twenties and older

by Coffeefiend
πŸ‘©β€πŸ¦³
🌟
πŸ₯³
0
The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue
My Roommate Is a Vampire
Oh No! There's an Incubus in My Hot Spring

Scottish Romantasy

by Madelise
🏴󠁧󠁒󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
🌢️
✨
0
Outlander
The Wolf King
Under Loch and Key

Cryptids and Mystery Creatures

by thebusta
🫈
πŸ‘½οΈ
❓️
0
Patricia Wants to Cuddle
Devolution: A Firsthand Account of the Rainier Sasquatch Massacre
Near the Bone