Oak Flat: A Fight for Sacred Land in the American West

Oak Flat: A Fight for Sacred Land in the American West

Lauren Redniss

Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:
Write a review

1 ratings • 1 reviews

A powerful work of visual nonfiction about three generations of an Apache family struggling to protect sacred land from a multinational mining corporation, by MacArthur “Genius” and National Book Award finalist Lauren Redniss, the acclaimed author of Thunder & Lightning. Oak Flat is a serene high-elevation mesa that sits above the southeastern Arizona desert, fifteen miles to the west of the San Carlos Apache Indian Reservation. For the San Carlos tribe, Oak Flat is a holy place, an ancient burial ground and religious site where Apache girls celebrate the coming-of-age ritual known as the Sunrise Ceremony. In 1995, a massive untapped copper reserve was discovered nearby. A decade later, a law was passed transferring the area to a private company, whose planned copper mine will wipe Oak Flat off the map—sending its natural springs, petroglyph-covered rocks, and old-growth trees tumbling into a void.  Redniss’s deep reporting and haunting artwork anchor this mesmerizing human narrative. Oak Flat tells the story of a race-against-time struggle for a swath of American land, which pits one of the poorest communities in the United States against the federal government and two of the world’s largest mining conglomerates. The book follows the fortunes of two families with profound connections to the contested site: the Nosies, an Apache family whose teenage daughter is an activist and leader in the Oak Flat fight, and the Gorhams, a mining family whose patriarch was a sheriff in the lawless early days of Arizona statehood. The still-unresolved Oak Flat conflict is ripped from today’s headlines, but its story resonates with foundational American themes: the saga of westward expansion, the resistance and resilience of Native peoples, and the efforts of profiteers to control the land and unearth treasure beneath it while the lives of individuals hang in the balance.


From the Forum

No posts yet

Kick off the convo with a theory, question, musing, or update

Recent Reviews
  • Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:

    The illustrations made each page turn such a delight! The frank, unbiased set of perspectives told through the stories of different stakeholders was also gently laid out,/l and allowed readers to draw their own nuanced opinions (indigenous Apache folks who are fighting for their land not to be mined, people in the slightly abandoned town of Superior who are eager for an economic injection that a mining town would provide, etc.)

    The end was really sudden? I was expecting a little more of a conclusion, but instead I guess the author wants me to think about these diff perspectives and draw my own.

    My personal conclusion is that while these mining companies are making billions in revenue, the rest of people are left to fight for scraps. Why is the town of Superior s desperate for an economic injection, that their only option is another Mining excavation that will produce tons and tons of toxic sludge that has to be dammed up?

    Ok my last comment is that...i saw people said this was really well researched and...it seemed more like a deep dive into a few families and their generations? Not like a fullly well researched thing that I’m used to? That being said, hearing history and facts from the perspective of a continuous lineage of family members leant a smooth story telling that kept my attention, and made it easier to read

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • Community recs for similar books
    Buy Lucy & Jennifer a coffee ☕️