Recs if you like Choosing Theo...

this list is not to be confused with mastication

by burntsunflowers
🔞
🔦
💥
45
The Deal
By a Thread
For the Fans

The Monster Smash

by erintripsey
🐉
🌶️
🐺
18
The Dragon's Bride
Ensnared
Impromptu Match

finger licking good

by erintripsey
💦
👅
🫴
74
Shadows of You
The Love of My Next Life
City of Souls and Sinners

what is kiss?

by erintripsey
💋
🫦
❓️
33
Ice Planet Barbarians
Edin
Choosing Theo

Beamed Up, Boo’d Up

by really.bookish
👽
😍
💗
11
Space for Love
Space for More
Space for Growth

Monster & alien agencies for horny humans

by PowahWom
😈
🥵
🛸
25
Lessons with the Mothman (Monster Smash Agency)
Howl for the Gargoyle (Monster Smash Agency)
Games with the Orc

1.0 Human ❤️ Non-human romance

by Alice_World
🌶️
❤️
💦
5
My Roommate Is a Vampire
Ensnared
The Haar

Let's Go To Monster (Pound) Town!

by PowahWom
🏡
😈
❤️
27
Two for Tea: Welcome to Azathé
Sweet Berries
Morning Glory Milking Farm

The 'Dirty' Book Club 😘

by mariangello
💗
🥰
📚
2
Before I Let Go
Butterfly Swords
Faking Christmas (Christmas Escape)

someone you can look up to

by erintripsey
⬆️
👀
🆙
20
Book Lovers
The Love Hypothesis
The Witching Hour

two for one special

by maomi
🍆
🐝
🔞
23
Sweet Berries
Choosing Theo
Wed to the Alien Warlord

no head?

by maomi
🙅‍♀️
🤕
🔪
28
Again the Magic
Seducing My Guardian
Gifting Me To His Best Friend

Books Where Everyone Is Locked Up

by chelssicle
🔒
🗝️
⚔️
6
The Prison Healer
Caged Wolf
Choosing Theo

Romance where HE is inexperienced

by mikaelabooks
🔞
💋
🌶️
7
Ice Planet Barbarians
Choosing Theo
Falls Boys

Curvy, Mid & Plus Size Leads in Adult Romance (& Erotica)

by robinjomargaret
💋
❤️‍🔥
💯
0
Spoiler Alert
Reclaimed
A Man for Mrs. Claus

SciFi Romance (The weird and the wonderful)

by Erin_is_reading
🌌
👽
❤️
0
Winter's Orbit
Hunt the Stars
Ocean's Echo

Romance Palate cleanser (unhinged version)

by mariangello
🔞
🤪
💗
0
Heartstopper: Volume One
The Awakening
Dark Fae

Mars Needs Women

by electrikate
👽
🚀
💘
6
Ice Planet Barbarians
Lauren's Barbarian
Choosing Theo

Quality Monster Smut

by booksontuesday
👹
👽
🌶️
0
Ensnared
Enthralled
Bound

Thanks, it’s the✨Trauma ✨

by electrikate
😓
💔
💪
4
A Dowry of Blood
Daughter of No Worlds
Atonement of the Spine Cleaver