I was immediately drawn into this book, and its world. I can feel Mal's sadness, and anxiety as she questions where she belongs. And it is explained why she feels she doesn't belong in a way that leaves you wondering why and wanting answers to this mystery. At the same time, we begin learning bits and pieces about the world. I like the way it's done. It isn't too much at once to the point where it's overwhelming, but it isn't so little that I'm struggling to follow along. I feel like the pace at which we get the information is perfect. The world itself was really well done. I read so many fantasy books that they start to kind of bleed together a bit, but this one had different elements that made it stand out to me. It didn't feel like so many other fantasy stories out there. I liked the way Mal's family was introduced, and it was refreshing to see that it felt like they accepted her and had never treated her differently, despite her backstory and differences. ""No, Mal." He shook his head. "I will not allow you to marry the Fire Prick just because some silly whispers of witches are keeping our father awake at night." " This interaction between Mal and her brother made me laugh a little, but also I felt their connection and I really loved seeing that sibling relationship. I really liked the characters, especially Mal. I've read several books where I didn't like the main character, and it was so nice to read one where the main character stood out to me and I wanted to keep reading about her. "If it mean saving her people, if it meant forging peace, if it meant protecting her kingdom - she would sacrifice herself to the flames. Even if it meant she would never rise again." The writing style itself is beautifully done. It is easy to read and follow, but it still feels elegant at the same time. I really enjoyed this book, and I cannot wait for the next one.

The book A Kingdom of Shadow and Ash achieves a 3.5 rating because its traditional elements work well when combined with excellent character development and meticulous world-building. J.F. Johns demonstrates remarkable ability to merge romantic elements with fantasy adventure while crafting believable characters who transcend typical archetypes. The most significant accomplishment of the book is its character development which portrays Mal and Ash as multifaceted personalities instead of basic romantic figures. The world-building creates a strong basis for future series development but remains easy for new readers to understand. The story is clearly pulling inspiration from established Romantasy series yet creates enough original elements for it to feel like a refreshing work not just an imitation. The magic system operates organically while political intrigue keeps readers engaged and character relationships evolve naturally throughout the story. Although small pacing problems and some standard storylines keep the book from earning top scores, they don’t disrupt the general enjoyment of reading through the book. The author demonstrates mature storytelling through their balanced romantic development and commitment to character growth which bodes well for future volumes. Full in-depth review can be found on BroMantasy.com.

Holy crap, what an amazing fantasy romance novel! I started it this morning and finished it in 6 hours, and I loved every minute of it. This book is classified as New Adult, Fantasy, and Romance and it fulfills all of those labels perfectly. This book made my chest hurt and my heart pound. The writing style is absolutely lush, everything is described beautifully but it's not tedious. The magic and and lore? Stunning. Tropes: slow burn, arranged marriage, enemies to lovers, and chosen one. I need the next book in the series yesterday. I truly don't understand how this author hasn't been snapped up by a big 5 publisher yet? Believe every good review you see, read this book, you will not regret it! Thank you to the author J.F. Johns for providing a review copy of this book at no cost and with no obligation. I reviewed this book voluntarily, and all opinions are my own.