avatar

IshaanS

1098 points

0% overlap
Badges14
Blood Suckers
Through the Eyes of Animals
LGBTQ+ Sci-Fi & Fantasy
My Taste
What We Fed to the Manticore
Gideon the Ninth
Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge and the Teachings of Plants
Speaking Bones
All This Could Be Different
Reading...
An Accident of Dragons
0%
Once Upon the Permafrost: Knowing Culture and Climate Change in Siberia (Critical Green Engagements: Investigating the Green Economy and its Alternatives)
0%
The Passing of the Dragon
0%

4.61 average  ·  553 reviews

Click a segment to filter

  • Nov 05, 2026
    Frankenstein
    FrankensteinMary Wollstonecraft Shelley
    IshaanS's Book Journey
    5.0
    Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:
    🧟‍♂️
    🏔️
    🛥️

    I am obsessed with Frankenstein now. I had never read this book before, though it has been recommended to me by a lot of people since I am also a huge fan of the novel Dracula. With some classics, I feel like the style of language is too difficult or removed for me to follow, but I was really easily swept up into this story, and it is absolutely a classic for a reason.

    I could talk about so much in Frankenstein. My favorite part by far was the depiction of monstrosity and what it feels like to have your humanity denied by other humans. It is so heartbreaking for a creature who is human in every aspect that counts to be shunned for one aspect outside of his control. This is the very essence of what I love in horror. There are so many parallels to real life with people who are othered because of queerness, race, or disability. The nesting of the narration allows us to see the creature from the judgemental eyes of others and from his own perspective, and it is so cathartic and devastating.

    I also had an amazing reading experience with this book. I picked it up to read around Halloween, and because I was traveling in Switzerland. This book is an amazing travel companion. I guess film adaptations change the location to unnamed towns in Germany or Britain, but the actual book takes place mostly in specific locations, mainly Geneva, Switzerland. While traveling, I was able to visit the villa in Geneva where Mary Shelley wrote the novel, which was such an amazing experience. I also stayed in Lucerne, Lausanne, and Evian-les-Bains, which are all mentioned by name in the book. And, the place where the creature confronts Frankenstein is in Chamonix, in the French Alps, where I recently moved to start a new job. I was shocked, and so happy to hear all the beautiful descriptions of the mountains here.

    I believe that it is significant that Chamonix is the location where the two meet. Compared to the towns, pastures, and small villages of Switzerland, the creature is much more able to find a sense of peace in the bleak and remote distant Alps. The other place where the two meet is the Orkney Islands in Scotland, which I haven’t been to (yet?) but also seems to be barren and isolated, especially in the 1700s. Being here in Chamonix has added a whole other level to my reading experience. There are so many references to local things like the chamois or the montenvers trail which made me so happy. I truly picked this up at the perfect time, because before moving here, these specificities would have gone right over my head.

    It is so clear to me after reading Frankenstein just how foundational this book is. It wears its influences from Paradise Lost and Prometheus very clearly on its sleeve. But there are so many storylines that continue to appear in sci-fi that were done perfectly here. One part of the story is the creature as an outsider who can point out hypocrisy in societal norms. There is a passage where the creature comes to realize that at the end of the day, what matters most in European society is wealth and bloodline, and how arbitrary it is to someone raised essentially in the wild. I also think that in sci-fi, we often see stories about robots or clones who struggle to be seen as human after being created in a lab setting. That is exactly the kind of existentialism that we get here, though Frankenstein definitely takes a horror and undead leaning. I was also so interested by the ways that this idea of “creating life” sounds very impressive until you realize we already have childbirth? It reveals the hubris of men obsessed with tech who want to sidestep the hard way and are not prepared to actually care for living beings.

    I found the start of the book a little boring. I enjoyed the part with the sailor in the Arctic, but when Victor Frankenstein is recounting his very boring and happy childhood, it was a little dull. He’s very dramatic though and loved to lament how bad things were going to get. I also wish that Elizabeth could have had any kind of character or agency, but most of the characters are admittedly here to represent ideas. My absolute favorite parts were the creature telling his story. I love this book.

    0



  • avatar

    IshaanS commented...

  • What We Fed to the Manticore

    What We Fed to the Manticore

    Talia Lakshmi Kolluri

    Thoughts from 24% - end of what we fed the manticore
    16
    9