
He/they | queer | mid-30s | Great Lakes region of the US | I read a lot of fantasy, sci-fi, and queer romantasy, and historical romance. I'm also an avid gamer, knitter, and comics enjoyer.
3964 points


4.24 average · 105 reviews
Click a segment to filter
Kit is the son of an impoverished noble family living in nineteenth century London. While his family believes he should be spending his time looking for a wealthy heiress to marry, he would rather spend his time studying and searching for magic in the hidden corners of the city. One night, he stumbles through a rift in reality and discovers an entire village of people locked in time by the Fairy Queen since 1066. Among them is the beautiful and charismatic Wil. Centuries ago, he dared to challenge the Fairy Queen and he has spent almost every second of the intervening centuries attempting to make up for that mistake to the family that is trapped with him. Driven by his growing attachment to Wil and the intoxicating magic of traversing worlds, Kit embarks on a quest to bring Wil and his family back to the modern world, even if he has to face the Fairy Queen head-on to do so.
What follows is a heady, if occasionally murky, fairy tale of star-crossed lovers, divided loyalties, and wizard hubris. A World Apart is a promising debut novel with compelling characters and beautiful prose. While the characters were interesting and multifaceted to start, their overall arcs through the book were fairly shallow and a lot of the development that was there happened between scenes instead of on the page.
Nesmith unfortunately struggles with a common new author problem of telling when you should be showing. This is very evident in the development of Kit and Wil’s relationship. They have immediate chemistry and attraction to one another, but despite much of the middle of the book being dedicated to their clandestine meetings, we get very little of actual development of their relationship. The blooming of their feelings for one another happens between time skips instead of on the page, which left me wondering exactly what pushed the two of them from lust at first sight to a love that could break the laws of space and time.
I also found myself especially frustrated by Wil’s lack of development in the second half of the book. In the first half, Kit and Wil have fairly equal influence over the events of the book, but in the second half Wil is relegated to more of a damsel in distress role. He is more of a goal to achieve than a character in his own right. I found this particularly frustrating because I quite like Wil as a character and I think his fraught relationship with the Fairy Queen was one of the better parts of the book.
The world-building was also a bit sparse, especially in the magic system. The mechanics are not explained very well and the reader isn’t given a foundation of knowledge so that they can follow the growth of Kit’s power (and his descent into obsession.) Black magic and its consequences aren’t really discussed until those consequences are happening. It’s a shame because I quite like some of the mechanics we’re working with here, especially magic’s tendency to multiply itself upon regular use.
“But Orion,” I hear you saying, “Didn’t you just say this is more a fairy tale than a high fantasy novel? Shouldn’t the magic rely more on vibes and dream logic if that’s the flavor we’re going for?” And my answer to that is, Nesmith could have possibly gotten away with that, if she wasn’t setting up a larger series with this book that is primarily focused on Kit’s addictive relationship to magic and how it feeds his own obsessive tendencies and intellectual hubris. Those themes require a bit more mechanical scaffolding to properly execute.
The obvious comparison to make here is Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell by Susanna Clarke. Of course comparing this mostly charming fantasy romance to one of the most important, paradigm-shifting fantasy masterpieces of the century so far is not exactly fair… However the striking similarity in the setting and magic systems invites the comparison. Where Clarke spends hundreds of pages dedicated to the precise workings of magic while still retaining a sense of wonder and mystery, Nesmith keeps the mechanics of the world conveniently vague until she needs the magic to do something specific for the plot. Instead of leaving me aghast in wonder, the magic workings of this book usually left me feeling like, “Yeah, sure of course it would work like that because that’s how we get to the next important plot beat.”
I find myself once again doing that thing while reviewing a book I liked but didn’t love where I spend the bulk of my review griping about what didn’t work and forget to tell you about what I actually enjoyed about the book. So please don’t misunderstand me, I enjoyed A World Apart and I think Nesmith is definitely a new writer worth watching! Her prose is pretty and evocative without veering into purple. She’s quite good at sensory description, evoking a place and time through smells, textures, and ambient sounds. You can feel the close, claustrophobic smog of London pressing against the windows of Kit’s home. You can smell the clammy, bone chilling air wafting off of an eleventh-century Thames in late Autumn. She’s very good at evoking a scene without getting too lost in the details.
And while the characters lack a bit in development over the course of the book, they are still vibrant and multifaceted. Even beyond Kit and Wil, the supporting cast all have their own personalities and motivations. Kit’s sister, Teddy, as well as his potential fiance, Agatha are particularly compelling both in personality and in their own stories that are related to but not entirely dependent on Kit’s. Wil’s village is also full of fascinating little character studies including a boy cursed to live as a child for hundreds of years and an elderly midwife who was forced to hover at death’s door for just as long.
If for no other reason, I hold a certain amount of affection for this book because it gave me a romance between two bisexual men. That is surprisingly rare in the media landscape overall, let alone in fantasy romance. More often than not, writers will default to pairing a bi man and a gay man together, or two gay men. And when there is a bi man the book is often about his coming to terms with his sexuality. In this book, both Kit and Wil are firm in their attraction to multiple genders before even meeting one another. They are secure in their sexuality and while Kit is obviously in the closet due to the social circumstances he lives in, he doesn’t spend page time wringing his hands over his attraction to men, or question his attachment to Wil as he starts to realize his attraction to Agatha. As a bi man married to another bi man, it feels refreshing to see a relationship that bears any similarity to my own.
Despite its flaws, I did have a good time with A World Apart. Sometimes reading a book that fails to meet expectations is a more interesting experience than a true five star read. When you can see the seams, it’s easier to pick at them. As you pry the pieces apart, it helps you develop your taste and discernment as a reader, which only leads to a better appreciation of true masterpieces when they come across your desk. Nesmith is clearly a talented writer with a lot of potential. She definitely got me hooked enough that I will be returning for her next book to see what fate has in store for Kit and Wil.
Thanks to NetGalley and Macmillan for the eARC!