I was first introduced to Tremblay's work through a copy of A Head Full of Ghosts, and I ended up loving the structure and storytelling in that novel. I loved the "let's-make-a-documentary-slash-movie-tv-special-oh-god-this-is-going-horribly-wrong" angle, I loved the relationship between the two sisters (which I am always a sucker for complicated-yet-endearing sisterly bonds) and I loved the ambiguity of the ending. So considering Horror Movie follows a very similar pattern, at least where that first point is concerned, I was expecting to really love it.
And at first I did! I loved reading the pieces of the script, which I found enthralling and scary, and a total contrast to the realistic chapters of a bunch of twenty-somethings making a movie and a middle-aged guy trying to make a living decades later. Maybe I'd be one of those movie goers who would be happy confronting my demons while waiting 5 minutes staring at the doorway waiting for Karson's death to arrive, idk.
I think my major hang up with the novel is I was just starting to really get in the groove and get to know these characters (and the characters they play - a real nesting doll of characters here) and then the ending happened. This is a layered hang up - first, we get through the revelation of what happened to Cleo on the last day of filming, have our sort of emotional release of "oh, that's what happened!", and then all of a sudden it's chapter 20 and the book is nearly done. Second, to be blunt, I didn't like the ending. I didn't like the sudden verge from "is the Thin Kid the monster or are humans the real monsters?" and ambiguity surrounding this topic into full on "oh... he's eating Thin Kid 2.0 and turning into him I guess?" It felt weird and out of place, and considering I finished this book at 3 am and I'm under the weather, it wouldn't surprise me if I hallucinated the whole thing, or it was described as happening in a weird dream and I missed the memo, because that genuinely is what it felt like. Huh, okay!
Overall though, the real highlight for me, as mentioned before, were the portions of script we got. I loved the descriptions of the Thin Kid's transformation, and the slow build of dread. Cleo (okay Tremblay as Cleo - nesting dolls, etc.) certainly did have talent, even if it verge into pretentious twenty-something territory sometimes (on purpose, I'm assuming).