avatar

handflex05

andy • she/her • 20-something 🕯️ your local pretentious english major 🦝 jane austen & weird lit fic lover! 🪐 opinion-haver and argument-maker

3934 points

0% overlap
Badges27
Level 6
British & Irish Classic Literature
Weird Girl Fiction
My Taste
Persuasion
Atonement
North Woods
Dubliners
All's Well
Reading...
Gypsies & the British Imagination, 1807-1930
0%
Ebony and Ivy: Race, Slavery, and the Troubled History of America's Universities
0%
The Mysteries of Udolpho
46%
Beautyland
45%
Emma
34%

3.36 average  ·  854 reviews

Click a segment to filter

  • May 20, 2026
    Rejection
    Rejection Tony Tulathimutte
    handflex05's Book Journey
    Enjoyment: 1.0Quality: 5.0Characters: Plot:
    ⚠️
    📱
    🤮

    it feels disingenuous to quantify this book on a 5-star scale. this book exists on a separate plane from that scale. in terms of enjoyment: i hated this book. i hated nearly every second of reading it, and the first four chapters in particular evoked visceral reactions from me. however, in terms of objective quality: this is about the best book i’ve ever read. when i could distance myself from the weeds of the character’s voices, the interconnectedness was perfectly rendered, the voices lovingly crafted to verisimilitude, and the increasingly meta setups placed to drive home the theme were overwhelmingly impressive.

    rejection is so committed to showing the extremes of the titular theme, and it makes it a genuinely hard read, but a nonetheless rewarding one. it is steadfastly grounded in the present moment (i sincerely hope if i reread this is 5 years the 2024-ness of it all will add an additional level of cringe on top of the already overwhelming levels of cringe), with constant immersion in the extremes of internet culture, be that memes and twitter bots or hardcore reddit porn and incel chat rooms. it’s darkly funny, if you can manage any other emotion for these characters than disgust or pity, and above all, a twisted love letter to human connection. the online spaces where rejection amplifies into a self-fulfilling prophecy carry with them the afterimage of how genuine connection found out in the real world can end that loop, if we’re just brave enough to put down the damn phone and really talk to people.

    rejection is a trip. it’s worth taking if you think you can stomach it. i stole my shoelaces from the president, and it’s time to log off.

    0


  • Canon

    Canon

    Paige Lewis

    Thoughts from 14% (page 69) (Even A Prophet Suffers Men’s Interruptions)
    6
    2

  • avatar

    handflex05 commented...

    i tend to think of quality & enjoyment as separate categories, so my ratings look something like this… ⭐️ - this book was both objectively poorly written and i didnt enjoy myself reading it. notable books in this category: twilight, robinson crusoe, most of the shatter me series, any non-fiction book that views corsets as a torture device ⭐️⭐️ - this book was poorly written, but i had a good time anyway (or: this book was well done, but really didn’t work for me) notable books in this category: new moon, slewfoot, the republic, most of the throne of glass series ⭐️⭐️⭐️ - this book was good! no glaringly bad writing, and i had fun, but 3 stars typically have something that kept me from loving the book. this is my default rating notable books in this category: a lot of terry pratchett books, the catcher in the rye, the safekeep, taming of the shrew (and lots of books i know are important but just didn’t like) ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ - now we’re talking! four stars are for books i really love. they’re well written, and i had fun reading. typically, these books have a little extra something that makes them stand out. notable books in this category: who’s afraid of virginia woolf, fruit fly, wide sargasso sea ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ - i would go to war for this book. i am fundamentally changed after reading this book. i am fairly sparing with my five star ratings, they’re only for things i consider true masterpieces! notable books in this category: the overstory, dubliners, persuasion, rosencrantz and guildenstern are dead, atonement

    i do use half stars when a book falls somewhere in between my ratings, but i think going any smaller than that takes away the intuitive nature of rating. at the end of the day, my ratings are for my reference; i wouldn’t not recommend a book to someone because i personally gave it a low rating.

  • Star ratings and their meanings ⭐

    Something I struggle with from time to time is the star rating system. Trust me, I know it's pretty much the system for rating just about any media, but as a person of the AuDHD variety, I sort of have a quiet hatred for star ratings because of how vague they can be. I have to admit, PB does do them in a way I really appreciate - i.e. breaking the star ratings down into separate contributing factors in addition to asking for the overall rating.

    Which leads me to my question: What do star ratings mean to you? How specific do you like to be (2 stars vs 1.85 stars, etc), and are there any factors different from PB's that determine a book's star rating for you? I'm so curious!

    I don't have a specific set of rules or factors myself, but sometimes I wish I did. I think it's something I'll set out to do someday soon!

    23
    31