

Love mysteries/thrillers, historical fiction, and fantasy but I read a lot of different genres. She/her. (previously jslynschapterverse)
14348 points










4.23 average · 667 reviews
Click a segment to filter
3.75 ⭐
This was okay/pretty good. I could see why it doesn’t sit well with some readers, as it is basically a gritty, crime, action movie with unlikeable characters in book form, and that requires a specific audience.
While I love a revenge story, this didn’t hit the notes that I enjoy in a revenge plot as much. Longer thoughts on what stood out/what I thought below. (Not my typical review style, but I took points I nixed adding to the forum and just dumped them here)
So, this is my first Southern noir. S.A. Cosby and Karin Slaugher have been on my TBR for way too long, and I know they are both recognized as powerhouses in the genre. (S.A. Cosby is literally referred to/known as the modern King of Southern Noir.) But outside of knowing this is a subgenre of crime fiction, I didn’t know much.
And before I started reading, I wanted to get a better sense of the genre, and in addition to a brief stint at YouTube and Wikipedia University, I found the following interesting articles: Southern Noir; The Rise of Rural Noir; Y’all Means All.
What stood out to me was that the genre often focuses on themes of poverty, racism, and violence, is known for its hard-boiled cynicism, and centers on morally ambiguous characters. There aren’t heroes, and the characters live in the gray (at best). I know this book got a lot of flak for its main characters being so problematic, and yeah, cringe. But that’s the point, and not just for the sake of being problematic/unlikeable and not as a reflection of Cosby.
Through the characters and the setting and their background, racism, homophobia, prejudices against ex-cons, etc., are being critiqued. Ike and Buddy Lee aren't meant to be people you root for; they're not heroes. They are products of the environments and cultures that shaped them, and the ugliness they carry is the whole point. Southern Noir doesn't clean that up or ask you to look away. It puts it front and center because that is how you're invited to reckon with it.
The discomfort is the critique. If these characters were likable and easy to sit with, the commentary would have no teeth. The genre has always used deeply flawed, often morally reprehensible people to hold a mirror up to systemic and cultural failures, and Cosby is doing exactly that here.
And look, it is completely valid to not want to spend your reading time with characters this difficult. That is a personal preference, not a moral stance. But not wanting to read it is different from the book being problematic. Cosby is not his characters. A writer giving voice to racism and homophobia on the page is not the same as endorsing it, and the whole architecture of this book is built around interrogating those exact things.
Side note: In my YouTube University studies, I ran across Cosby’s interview/appearance at the 2023 National Book Festival. He’s discussing All the Sinners Bleed (which got added to the TBR after this interview), but I think it’s such a great discussion. They get into Southern Noir vs. Southern Gothic and genre stuff around the 13-minute mark. A peek at how Cosby explains Southern Noir: “I think it’s just this idea of crime fiction that takes place in a place where you can’t get away from the people you’ve hurt.” This part of the discussion isn’t long; this was just my favorite video of the ones I watched.
Moral ambiguity is the most prominent “hallmark”/genre staple. Not to belabor the point, but Ike and Buddy Lee are not heroes/moral pillars. They are doing something arguably righteous but through methods that are brutal and outside any legal or ethical framework. Survival and revenge are driving them far more than justice.
Based on what one article said that the hallmarks of the genre are, I jotted some more thoughts on how this book fits in the genre:
Like I said, I love a revenge story. The Glory, chef’s kiss! She Started It, loved watching you end it, though. They Never Learn, but you made sure they learned in the end, sis. However, this story made me realize I enjoy revenge stories where we know who hurt us/who wronged us, and we have a plan to take them down. This was a lot of us hunting down Tangerine and trying to piece together what happened and hurting anyone who got in the way of us finding the truth so we can get revenge. And I am not a huge action/fight scene reader.
Also, while Buddy Lee and Ike are on their journey to be less problematic, I do not know how effective/how much I valued the “lesson” portions of the book.
The writing wasn’t my favorite at times. I wouldn’t say it is purple prose, but there were metaphors and language that felt misplaced/awkward. I would be interested to hear a bit of the audio, since people mentioned lines that read weirdly seemed natural/flowed well.
A pro for how this is written: the chapters are short, and if you like to try to read to the end of a chapter before stopping, you, like me, will love that.
My siblings and I love yelling “Aveeengeee meee!” as a callback to my forever Spiderman, Toby Maguire, specifically Green Goblin yelling this at Harry, over like small inconveniences/as a joke.
One critique I’ve seen a lot about Razorblade Tears is that Buddy Lee and Ike say the revenge is for their sons, but really it’s for themselves. And no, Derek and Isiah aren’t yelling out like Green Goblin demanding to be avenged. But I don’t think it has to be either/or. Why can’t they be doing it mostly for themselves but also for their sons in a way?
I can’t help but think about Long Way Down by Jason Reynolds, which is a novel-in-verse that takes place entirely in an elevator in the 60 seconds it takes to get from his floor down to the lobby, as he is set to go and get revenge for his brother's murder. Will, the 15-year-old protag, talks about “the rules,” especially the idea that you avenge whoever you lose. That book is very explicitly critiquing that mindset and the cycle it creates, but it also understands how real and ingrained those rules are. They’re not easy to just…opt out of.
Buddy Lee and Ike feel like they’re operating under those same rules, just in a different context and with even more baggage. They’re ex-cons who have lived violent lives even outside of prison, and revenge is something they understand. It’s almost like the only way they know how to do grief. So when they say this is for their sons, I don’t think that’s a lie. I think that’s genuinely how they’re framing it to themselves.
But at the same time, they’re not oblivious. They know their sons were better than them (kinder, more open, more capable of love in ways they struggled with). There are moments where it’s clear they understand their sons might not have wanted any of this, that all this violence in their names is kind of…misplaced. But some rules/ingrained responses are hard to avoid.
So yeah, part of this is for them. It’s about guilt, anger, needing somewhere to put all of that. But it’s also about love, in the only language they really know. And like Long Way Down, it ends up circling back to that bigger question: what does it actually mean to follow the “rules/community codes”? And what does it cost to honor or break them?
I do plan to read more Cosby. All the Sinners Bleed sounds up my alley, and I think, even if they are similar, the dive into the religious critiques will be intriguing.
PS. If you actually read all of this wow. Thanks.


The Pale Lady (Fantasy and Horror Classics)
Alexandre Dumas
Then a strange hallucination took possession of me; I thought I was the lost Lenore of Bürger's famous ballad, in the act of being carried off by the spectral horse and horseman, and presently when I felt we were slackening speed, it was with a feeling of sheer terror I opened my eyes, firmly convinced I should see surrounding me only shattered graveyard crosses and open tombs.
I didn't get this reference ("the lost Lenore of Bürger's famous ballad"), so I looked it up and found it interesting.
This is a reference to a 1773 Gothic ballad by Gottfried August Bürger. And, in short, the ballad's story is: Lenore's fiancé dies and doesn't return from war. She's so overcome with grief that she starts fighting with God/cursing Him/saying He's never done any good for her/etc. Then, one night, at midnight, a handsome stranger who looks just like her dead love knocks on her door, asking her to take a midnight ride with him. She hops on, of course, and the ride (a very neck-breaking, scary one) ends at sunrise in a cemetery, and the marriage bed is a grave. The rider was Death all along.
So, this is interesting to me because our FMC making this comparison could hint at her own impending fate. In comparing Lenore/FMC:
Hedwig making this connection is good, though, since it points to her recognizing the danger she's in. Hopefully she remains guarded and skeptical.
(NOTE: I'm basing this on a Wikipedia search: see the page. But in lurking around the web, I also found this cool art illustrating the ballad.)


Days of Light
Megan Hunter
I’m still really enjoying this one. Such a good exploration of grief and the passage of time (I know it’s only been a short period; still, 4 more decades to explore for me), and the way Ivy sees the world is so interesting. Hunter loves a colon and a long description, but I am loving the prose.
Before reading on to Day Three and entering a new decade, I wanted to reflect on/share my thoughts on Day Two, April 1938:
Disjointed Beginning The opening scene (the funeral and the burial scenes) felt so disjointed; the transitions were abrupt, and the scenes/Ivy’s memories flowed in and out of one another, and I feel like the muddiness of it all so perfectly reflects/mimics how Ivy is feeling and is coping with the loss.
The Bear Situation. Sigggghhhhhhh. I am sad and disgusted and mad, not at Ivy.
He reached for her hand, then, like a doctor in this one action that could give such medicine, such relief. She had been prescribed a pill, by a real doctor, the night Joseph disappeared, but it only stopped her, made her die, for a few hours. This — Bear’s hand on hers was something else: a sheet lifted above her on a summer day, floating back to her body.
The weight of grief permeates this section, and Ivy is looking for any kind of relief (no matter how artificial or misplaced and no matter the shape of salvation takes). Ivy isn’t responding to Bear so much as she’s responding to the feeling of not drowning for a moment.
The last part of the quote really stands out to me:
Bear’s hand on hers was something else: a sheet lifted above her on a summer day, floating back to her body.
A sheet lifted on a summer day is a gentle image and something that offers temporary relief. It creates a brief pocket of coolness, a soft barrier between your body and the oppressive heat.
That’s what Bear is offering her: not healing, not even true comfort, but a momentary suspension of feeling. A pause. A cover from the heat/pain/sorrow. And in her state of grief, that illusion is enough.
And what’s even more unsettling is how passive Ivy is within that image. The sheet is lifted over her. It floats back to her body. She isn’t doing anything; she’s being acted upon, covered, uncovered, briefly relieved, then returned to the same weight. That passivity mirrors exactly where she is emotionally, as she isn’t choosing Bear so much as she’s allowing herself to be wrapped in whatever dulls the intensity of her grief.
And Bear takes that grief and positions himself as the answer to it, inserting himself into the space Joseph’s absence has carved out rather than respecting it. He becomes the thing that hovers just long enough to feel like rescue. But unlike the sheet, he has intention. He chooses to step into that space.
Which makes the whole thing feel less like comfort and more like quiet encroachment. Because Ivy isn’t reaching for him; she’s sinking, and he’s placing himself where she might grab onto something.
I was so happy when she left Bear alone and ran toward the river (until I understood her intent to dive in the river). Her mom telling her that Bear was at her birth and mentioned marrying her then is gross/chilling, and it made his pursuit of her now even creepier. She is here, drowning in loss; her brother, a protector and someone against the relationship, is dead. Her parents are navigating the loss of a child, and her mother fought through grief to warn her off, but doesn’t have it in her to do much more to deter the relationship. And Bear (while also possibly grieving) is seizing an opportunity to sneak in and prey on Ivy when she nor anyone in her life has the strength or clarity of mind to oppose.
And I don’t just dislike him because he seems to be taking advantage and not just because of the age gap; it’s how he sees (doesn’t see) Ivy.
Of Joseph, Bear says: “He had such a fresh mind, didn’t he?”, calls him a clever one (he also calls him a boy, and he was older than Ivy, but I digress), and says “he was always striving — like I am constantly.”
Not even but a few breaths later, he says this about Ivy (to her!):
That’s what’s so wonderful about you, Ivy, why I wanted— There isn’t all that striving for you, is there? You’re just existing. You’re simply yourself. So wonderfully yourself.
And Ivy takes this to mean he believes she is drifting through life. He paints her as purposeless and the opposite of sharp. And Ivy is clearly still figuring out who she is and what she wants from life (and this process is interrupted by the loss of her brother), but she’s 19! And she is interesting; but he can’t see that.
She was so moved, she would say later. She was so touched by Bear’s love, by his need to protect her. But the truth was, she realized it no longer mattered what she did. She could be with Bear or not be with Bear: it was all the same.
She doesn’t care anymore. Bear has proposed while she’s in a hospital bed after nearly dying, and she’s alive because you saved her (so there’s indebtedness going on), and she’s decided to not care. Or maybe more accurately, she can’t afford to care because caring would mean re-entering the full weight of her grief, and she’s already barely surviving it. Indifference becomes its own kind of shield. And it’s so heartbreaking.
What It Means to Be Alive All throughout Day One, Joseph haunted the page with his life and how he lived, and was the most alive of the family.
It was only Joseph, it seemed that day, who knew how to live.
And drifting isn’t living. It’s a kind of quiet surrender/giving up on life.
Ivy clearly loves Joseph and admired the way he was so alive; that could be tied to romanticizing who he is in life. The other part could be that the Ivy (the one looking back and sharing these memories) may envy how he lived and that she did the opposite.
She chose to drift, not live. Yet she had the gall to be made that Frances can’t seem to live:
But Frances was neither free, nor alive. Ivy found herself feeling angered by this: how dare she appear to die, when her brother was truly dead, and nothing could save him. She remembered Frances the night she came back from the river, alone: she had been a dream figure, a form barely contained, a rush of colour and movement.
And I know gall is strong. This is just her grief manifesting as anger and her processing the unfairness of it all: Joseph, the one who knew how to live, is gone, while everyone left behind is either trapped, stalled, or disappearing in their own ways. She lashes out at Frances because she reflects a version of life that feels just as suffocating as her own.


Cousin Archibald continues to stonewall me, my three years’ pay is still a nebulous promise, and no allowance is forthcoming. Knowing Archibald Flat as I do, I had little expectation that he would greet me with my owed salary, my allowance, and a paternal kiss on the cheek (thank goodness). However, one hopes the fiduciary allotment is forthcoming.
I hope he hasn't lost a lot of the family money or something. Because I can't think of a reason outside of greed/triflingness that has Archibald sulking around and avoiding paying her.
Emma needs to be waiting in his study with her own version of B— Better Have My Money playing softly in the background:





















