I’m curious to see if anyone has had a similar experience with a superstition (or coincidence?) when reading.

I bought a bookmark in Nepal in 2024, and every book I’ve put it in, no matter how good it has been, has put me into a slump. Every time I lay a finger on it, it’s like my motivation to read just withers immediately 😭

‼️NETTLES MENTIONED🚨 it really is happening to everybody #ethelcain

also tell me this picture isn't giving margot, go on i dare you

I’m growing a little tired of my kindle (throw your tomatoes I understand) and I’m curious to see if there are any better alternatives. My main drawbacks with the kindle is that you have to exclusively buy from Amazon and the fact that they’re going back and changing older books to be more “modern” with their references.

I’ve been looking at a Kobo - so far I love the idea of having a stylus and being able to write on books, and being able to buy it’s own page turner powered by Bluetooth rather than a whole seperate setup as you would need for a kindle. I also like the fact that it has buttons to turn the page.

As for cons, the main one has to be the price 😭 I think I got my kindle (2022 standard edition) for like £50 on prime day, and she hasn’t faulted me further than being owned by Amazon 🥲 I know I won’t be able to find another at this price, so I guess what I’m really asking is would a kobo/any better e-readers be actually worth the money?

My only requirements is a backlit screen and no access to any sort of games/social media as I’m easily distracted 😅

There's nothing like the 'cringe' of a dated 2006 reference to pull you out of a story - but is 'fixing' it even worse? Kindle is officially "modernizing" older titles, and the result is a bizarre time-warp where 2006 characters are obsessed with TikTok and Billie Eilish.

I came across this article detailing how the Pretty Little Liars (PLL) series (originally published in 2006) is being "modernized" both on Kindle (and apparently in the recent printings), but it's something I have been ruminating about since the story broke. I believe the initial person to raise these concerns was @coastalsoftgirl on X, who spotted the changes within the first few pages of the book.

I thought about posting this on the PLL forum since this specific case is about PLL , but the implications are global and I wanted more people's perspectives on this. I'm sure this is happening in other books, they just haven't been caught yet.

The Changes are.... a Choice Some of the examples of the "modernization" changes include

1. Instead of inviting the girls over to watch Fear Factor reruns, the text how says they're coming over to watch a "TikTok Challenge"
2. Gwen Stefani references have been swapped with Adele.
3. Green Day's American Idiot has been replaced with Billie Eilish's Bad Guy
4. Characters who originally used Sidekicks (RIP) are now using iPhones.

Paradox of Immersion On one hand, I get the logic. I often get pulled out of a story when a reference hasn't aged well or feels otherwise jarring. It reminds me of how Kesha recently change her TiK ToK lyrics from "feeling like P. Diddy" because that reference carries a very different, darker weight now than it did in 2009. Sometimes, an update feels like a necessary "fix" for the vibe. But on the other hand, books are historical capsule. Swapping Fear Factor for Tiktok feels almost like an "uncanny valley" experience because the characters are technically in 2006 but using 2020's tech. If we start "live-patching" literature like it's a video, do we lose the context of when it was written?

So, I bring my questions to you, Boundlings!

1. Does a dated reference ruin your immersion, or do you prefer the "time capsule" feeling, or land somewhere in between?
2. Do you think "modernizing" is helpful for new generations/the authors and publishers, or is it a more a form of digital revisionism?
3. Most importantly: If we buy a digital book, should the publisher have the right to change the "art" inside our device years later without us opting in?