Post from the The Things We've Seen forum
matmcdonut commented on crybabybea's review of How to Sell a Genocide: The Media's Complicity in the Destruction of Gaza
Damning, relevant, and likely to be relevant for years to come. How to Sell a Genocide has a very specific focus and it refuses to be distracted from it.
It's not about Israel's actions, it's not about conservatives gleefully supporting a genocide, it's about liberal media's complicity, cowardice, and hypocrisy. As the United States and Israel continue to commit genocide against people in West Asia and especially Palestine, and liberal pundits finally decide to admit that genocide is morally wrong, this book is going to be increasingly relevant as an incriminating historical archive of the post-October 7th media landscape in the US.
I especially loved this book's focus on language as a form of propaganda and how journalists are complicit in the way they tell stories. Passive vs. active language is something that interests me a lot, and there are a plethora of examples of that here as Johnson catalogs the ways that liberal media has used language to cover up the United States' and Israel's actions.
As much as it's imperative to talk about the physical violence used by the United States and Israel, the bombs and guns and military force, it's just as important to talk about the weaponization of language and propaganda. How to Sell a Genocide provides such an important companion to ongoing research into Israel's genocide, shining a spotlight on the way media has been captured and weaponized to manufacture consent for increasingly horrific atrocities against the Palestinian people.
The research in this book is immaculate and scathing. Every media outlet, every institution, every publication is complicit. The insight into the behind-the-scenes financial aspects of foundations like AIPAC and how they directly influenced the media landscape is eye-opening but not shocking, showcasing how those who should be the most dedicated to the objective truth have been the most swayed by capitalist interests.
Maybe one of the most important books about the genocide of Palestine to be released in our era.
Post from the The Things We've Seen forum
Post from the The Things We've Seen forum
At this point it’s really hard to pinpoint my thoughts until I see how the other books relate to the overall themes of Book 1. I know there’s 3 in total but I have no clue if the other ones are interconnected to this one directly, or if they’re more abstract but relating to “The Things We’ve Seen” in a literal sense.
That being said I feel like Book 1 was really enjoyable, intriguing, and downright weird. Which was the vibe I was hoping to get after reading the synopsis originally. I found another description from someone who said this feels like channel surfing. That feels very apt to my experience so far having unintentionally taken a month away from actively reading this and not missing a beat. Maybe because there was no beat to hang onto in the first place!
matmcdonut made progress on...
matmcdonut commented on matmcdonut's update
matmcdonut made progress on...
matmcdonut made progress on...
matmcdonut made progress on...
matmcdonut made progress on...
matmcdonut commented on matmcdonut's update
matmcdonut finished a book

Three Worlds: Memoir of an Arab-Jew
Avi Shlaim
matmcdonut wrote a review...
"... One thing is certain: without reviving or reimagining the kind of religious tolerance and civilised dialogue between Jews and Arabs that prevailed in Iraq before the emergence of the State of Israel, we will not be able to move beyond today's impasse."
Three Worlds is a memoir by Avi Shlaim, who is noted as one of Israel's "New Historians". They're a group of Israeli scholars who are critical of the history of Zionism and Israel. The title comes from his lived experience of being an Iraqi Jew, then emigrating to Israel during Operation Ezra and Nehemiah, and then heading to London to continue his education into adulthood.
Out of the gate I'll just mention: this is a memoir first and foremost. It has a very academic slant, particularly in the back half. As someone who wasn't aware of the details on the 'external' founding of Israel, I.E. the push of Jews in Iraq and surrounding areas to emigrate and the forces of Zionism being front and center, it was very intriguing. Shlaim also provides insights on his experience living in Israel with his family as a child. Going from relative wealth and upper-middle-class living in Iraq, to being considered second-rate citizens as Arab Jews in Israel.
Given his current Anti-Zionist beliefs, he does a great job centering the Palestinian experience throughout. Even in such a personal story, I never felt as if they were an afterthought. However, the majority of these thoughts, opinions, and history are bookended in the beginning and end of the story.
I enjoyed my time with this, but I'm personally not a huge fan of memoirs which is why this isn't a 5 star read for me. I would still recommend it, especially if you're someone more well-versed in the history of Palestine looking for additional historical context. Outside of that though, his personal story is also very interesting and compelling!
matmcdonut finished a book

Three Worlds: Memoir of an Arab-Jew
Avi Shlaim
matmcdonut commented on matmcdonut's update
matmcdonut commented on matmcdonut's update
matmcdonut is interested in reading...

Irregular Army: How the US Military Recruited Neo-Nazis, Gang Members, and Criminals to Fight the War on Terror
Matt Kennard