avatar

mishmash

656 points

0% overlap
Early User
Spring 2025 Readalong
Level 4
My Taste
Severance
Beach Read
Rachel's Holiday (Walsh Family, #2)
Blood Over Bright Haven

mishmash TBR'd a book

1d
The Spellshop

The Spellshop

Sarah Beth Durst

0
0
Reply

mishmash commented on InkDragon's review of Katabasis

4d
  • Katabasis
    InkDragon
    Sep 14, 2025
    5.0
    Enjoyment: 5.0Quality: 5.0Characters: 5.0Plot: 5.0

    I finished the book over a week ago, but since I immediately travelled to Naples, I couldn't commit on writing a review :D

    But here we are. It's not coming as a surprise that I loved the book. And I suppose, many of us have heard the heated discussions in various book spaces surrounding Katabasis. Some of these arguments are in my opinion ... eh, well. I won't talk about them now. BUT I think that some disappointment came from false expectations - which, like, it happens. That's fine.

    In my opinion, this book isn't so much of an adventure journey into hell, but more of a deep dive into one, and by some extent two, very difficult character. Yeah, it's a character study, and a story about mistakes and trying your best and healing. I would also say that I could relate a LOOOOT with Alice, because I am working my way through academia myself, and my end goal IS a PhD in research. I could imagine that if one never experienced academic reality, and the toxic structures beneath it, it could get quite hard to relate to the themes of the story. Like, I can completely understand why Alice would go to hell and risk dying to save her dissertation. Such a mood.

    Also, keep in mind that the book is set in 1985 (right?) - this HEAVILY influences the characters' morals. I saw some people being upset about some things Alice and Peter said and did, but in this case, you have to keep the morals of that time in mind.

    You don't necessarily have to like the characters, but I think you have to have some understanding for them or else you won't enjoy the book at all, because it's so character centric. The same goes for the themes of academic structures, philosophy and morality.

    But whoever said that you have to read 10 other books or you won't undertand the book ... That's not true. Would you benefit? Sure, but we all do from reading more. But the book gives you all the information you need to follow the characters' journey and the plot (and there is still a plot which I enjoyed a lot).

    And a benefit, before I stop annoying you with my long post: You can entertain an entire table with the paradoxes explained in the book! It's very fun seeing everyone argue about when to drink the wine. Try it, cause some riots!

    23
    comments 11
    Reply
  • The Road of Bones (The Ashen, #1)
    hrmm Jonas
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    3
    comments 0
    Reply
  • mishmash finished reading and wrote a review...

    4w
  • Deep End
    mishmash
    Nov 27, 2025
    3.5
    Enjoyment: 3.0Quality: 4.0Characters: 3.5Plot: 3.5

    View spoiler

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • Post from the One-Star Romance forum

    5w
  • One-Star Romance
    Thoughts from 68%

    I’m struggling a little because this book started at romantic, at the meet cute, but the dreariness of life , drifting friendships, and the prospect of great partners who “just don’t have that spark” is so depressing. I’m having trouble believing in Natalie and Rob because they’ve interacted for like a total of 5 hours over the course of 5 years!!!!

    1
    comments 0
    Reply