themothgatherer commented on a post
Would this book win a Pulitzer Prize? No. Am I having fun? Definitely yes.
themothgatherer commented on a post
i resonate with libby so much. also she needs an adhd diagnosis
themothgatherer commented on CatherineJ's update
CatherineJ earned a badge

Top Contributor
An invite-only program for our most active users; see FAQ for more details.
Post from the Book Lovers forum
i resonate with libby so much. also she needs an adhd diagnosis
themothgatherer started reading...

Book Lovers
Emily Henry
themothgatherer commented on masen's review of Three Holidays and a Wedding
View spoiler
themothgatherer commented on the_rags's review of Three Holidays and a Wedding
probably the cheesiest thing i’ve read maybe ever, for the most part i’d say this novel executes fine on the heartwarming multi-cultural holiday comedy. i wouldn’t necessarily call it a romcom, as i thought the family and friend relationships shone the most. i wouldn’t say the romances were bad, just not that strong.
it was easy to root for the main characters to get their HEA and while the ending was a bit abrupt i liked where everything left off. definitely got me in the holiday spirit and it was very nice to have a novel with lighthearted and varied representation!
themothgatherer finished reading and wrote a review...
View spoiler
themothgatherer earned a badge

Winter 2026 Readalong
Read at least 1 book in the Winter 2026 Readalong.
themothgatherer finished reading and wrote a review...
i really tried to get through it but this one just isn’t for me. everyone’s entitled to their own opinions, so those who love this book are also valid, but i couldn’t get over the sum of unlikeable things in this book: the info dumping and over-explaining, the insanely unlikeable characters, the unnatural dialogue, the constant romanticization of how petite Anastasia is, all the misogynistic lines…all of it together really made me dislike this book fast.
i love skating and am on a quest for good skating books but i’d barely qualify this as a book about skating (and sex), as it’s marketed. it’s moreso about terrible people (and sex). i would love to hear recommendations if anyone has any!
themothgatherer DNF'd a book

Icebreaker (UCMH, #1)
Hannah Grace
themothgatherer commented on a post
I usually try not to be This Person but there's a line about Anna singing along to a Michael Bublé Christmas album in the year 2000 which didn't feel right to me so I spent four seconds googling his discography and sure enough, he didn't have any albums out until 2001 and no Christmas album until a decade later...
It's not that I care this much about Michael Bublé, it just doesn't bode well for how much the authors care about the specific 2000 setting other than the triple holiday coincidence - time will tell!
themothgatherer commented on a post
i wish this book was actually about skating and not about unlikeable people
Post from the Icebreaker (UCMH, #1) forum
i wish this book was actually about skating and not about unlikeable people
Post from the Icebreaker (UCMH, #1) forum