avatar

xoToughCookie

Hello! (She/Her)┃Basil The Cat🐈‍⬛🌿┃🖤= Genre Bending & Blending •🦇Horror • 🔍Mystery • Fantasy✨ • 💖Romance • SciFi💫┃📽️Letterboxd🍿 & 🎮InfiniteBacklog🕹️┃✉️Discord😊┃🌈✊🍉😷🏳️‍⚧️☂️┃🍅≠🍎 😭

5140 points

0% overlap
Horror Starter Pack Vol I
Dia de los Muertos 2025Top Contributor
My Taste
Bury Your Gays
I Was a Teenage Slasher
The Eyes Are the Best Part
We Have Always Lived in the Castle
Model Home
Reading...
The Silent Corner (Jane Hawk, #1)Strange PicturesYou Weren't Meant to Be HumanThe Blonde Dies FirstVampires of El NorteGods of Jade and ShadowMister MagicImmortal DarkBlood Over Bright Haven

xoToughCookie TBR'd a book

4h
Doll Parts

Doll Parts

Penny Zang

3
0
Reply

xoToughCookie commented on a post

4h
  • Chain-Gang All-Stars
    Thoughts from 11% (page 41)

    I’m really enjoying the bouncing between POVs mid chapter. Never let them know your next move 🤫

    6
    comments 1
    Reply
  • xoToughCookie commented on a post

    6h
  • Tender Is the Flesh
    Thoughts from 45%
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    9
    comments 4
    Reply
  • xoToughCookie made progress on...

    6h
    Blood Over Bright Haven

    Blood Over Bright Haven

    M.L. Wang

    3%
    11
    0
    Reply

    xoToughCookie commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    6h
  • Book Criticism

    I saw something today and I’m really curious what other readers think.

    Someone commented on an author’s personal Instagram post to say they weren’t a fan of the new book. The author replied with “if you don’t have anything nice to say, don’t say anything at all.” The person who posted the screenshot felt icky about the author’s response.

    Personally, I didn’t think the author was out of line. I don’t really see the point of going onto an author’s own page just to drop a negative comment. That isn’t a review, it’s just putting criticism directly in front of the author for no real reason. Review platforms exist for a reason.

    I also saw someone comment back to me about this ‘but sometimes authors don’t read reviews and won’t see it’ and I just always felt reviews are for other readers? I don’t know. And also how is ‘I didn’t like this book’ helpful in any way and why does it need to be seen?

    That’s just me. What do you all think? Is it fine to leave negative opinions on an author’s page, or should that stuff stay on review sites instead?

    Curious to hear everyone’s take.

    34
    comments 22
    Reply
  • xoToughCookie commented on xoToughCookie's update

    xoToughCookie earned a badge

    9h
    Level 7

    Level 7

    5000 points

    97
    37
    Reply

    xoToughCookie commented on True14216's review of Fan Service

    9h
  • Fan Service
    True14216
    Jul 07, 2025
    3.0
    Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:

    This book was a fun and steamy romance read. Alex reminded me of myself and my love for fantasy shows like Supernatural and Doctor Who (and the fandoms behind them). My biggest gripe with this was Devin because he really didn’t seem 42. Mind you I’m only 27 so the way he acted reminded me of other people my not someone middle aged. I think the characters could have still been an age gap just aged down a bit. Maybe Devin could have been 35 or 36 and Alex been 26 or 27, I think would have worked better.

    3
    comments 1
    Reply
  • xoToughCookie wrote a review...

    9h
  • Fan Service
    xoToughCookie
    Nov 15, 2025
    4.0
    Enjoyment: 5.0Quality: Characters: 4.5Plot: 5.0
    🐺
    🎬
    🖥️

    View spoiler

    4
    comments 0
    Reply
  • xoToughCookie earned a badge

    9h
    Level 7

    Level 7

    5000 points

    97
    37
    Reply

    xoToughCookie commented on xoToughCookie's update

    xoToughCookie made progress on...

    1d
    Fan Service

    Fan Service

    Rosie Danan

    100%
    8
    1
    Reply

    xoToughCookie made progress on...

    1d
    Fan Service

    Fan Service

    Rosie Danan

    100%
    8
    1
    Reply