Recs if you like The Witch of Blackbird Pond...

the darker side of new england. crumbling colonial-era brick, run down coastal towns, abandoned factories, dilapidated mills, foggy orchards, cold dark waters, whispers of witchcraft, venerated institutions, secret societies, and uneasy echoes of the past.

Books of the millennial reader's childhood (not just scholastic book fair). Sticking with chapter books, and not picture books :) All books pre-2005 Taking recs!

For Stephen King and co. Horrors, thrillers, and spooky vibes

Bring on those Gen Y memories! A list of books likely to give people born between 1981 and 1996 a lot of feelings.

This list is for those of us who grew up eagerly awaiting the Scholastic Book Fair, watching Reading Rainbow (or Wishbone!), and dreaming of a free personal pan pizza from Pizza Hut.

Note: these are not books published in 1981-1996, but books that had a hold on the millennial generation.

Also check out the Dear America series, American Girl series & Royal Diaries series.

YA fiction about teens struggling to fit into (or leave!) their religions or faith communities.

A collection of slightly dark, spooky, or existential books for children whose imaginary friend just might have been a ghost, who fantasized about being an orphan, or who would have appreciated the Well for Sensitive Boys to gaze into. A mix of titles from my millennial childhood with some newer additions.

From the light-hearted, to the silly, to the thought-provoking. Genres ranging from contemporary, to historical fiction, to fantasy.

The books your teacher made you read between the ages of 11-14. They changed the way you saw the world, they made you realize books were more than just goofy or sentimental stories you gobbled up before bedtime, and they stuck with you, all these years later.

Suggestions welcome, especially from non-American readers!!

Note: this list was made by a Millennial, so I'd love to hear from some different generations! What did your teachers assign you?

According to the ALA, "The Newbery Medal was named for eighteenth-century British bookseller John Newbery. It is awarded annually by the Association for Library Service to Children, a division of the American Library Association, to the author of the most distinguished contribution to American literature for children."

Standalone books worth a read or repeat!

Complete as of August 2026.

Witch lit. Maybe with a tinge of romance. Always open to more recs that fit this theme!

alternative titles: girlhood in colonial america, young girls in young america, little house alternatives

goal: to curate a list of little house alternatives, with big appreciation for the diverse peoples and cultures.

including books appropriate for middle school and YA readers

Witches, heretics and powerful women. Who's the heretic now?

Other items used: "Americana Instructor's Handbook", "Americana Student Workbook Part 1", "Americana Student Workbook Part 2", "Science D Instructor's Guide", "Language Arts D", "History/Bible/Literature D Instructor's Guide", "Sheet of Book Labels D", "American History I Lap Book", "Electives D" (includes "A Child's Introduction to the Orchestra" and "Building Thinking Skills Level 2"), "50 States Unit Study", "US Elections Lap Book", "Extra Language Arts D Student Activity Sheets", "Extra Science D Student Activity Sheets", "Discover & Do: Level D Experiments Paper Packet", "Discover & Do: Science Supplies Kit D", "The Timeline Book", "Timeline Figures D", "Sing the Word: Great in Counsel and Mighty in Deed", "Erasable Colored Pencils", "Discover & Do: Level D Science Experiment Videos", "MathTacular 3", "MUS4 Delta Online Instruction with Video", "Math-U-See Integer Block Kit", "Markable Map", "Markers" and "3" Binder with Tabs".

I never read these books as a kid. I don’t want to miss out on anything

Winners of the award for "the most distinguished contributions to American literature for children."

Please make this a good, safe, and healthy environment. Do your best to not give away spoilers unless you make sure the spoilers will be announced at the beginning of your comment before the spoilers are listed! No bullying, harassment, or anything mean! Jesus loves you!✝️🫶🏼