I'm not trapped here with you...
... You're trapped here with me! The format: A group of people (could be strangers, or long-lost friends) are gathered or trapped in an isolated place together. Maybe it's a remote island. Maybe a cozy cabin during a blizzard. Someone is killed. The killer is obviously among them, but who?! Submissions welcome because this is my favourite mystery sub-genre at the moment, and I can't wait to discover more!
created by Emmy58
last updated December, 2025
Comments
Daisy Darker is my recommendation!
Emmy58OP
Added, thanks!! I've not read but definitely seen this one before because I vividly remember thinking it looks exactly like the cover for The Guest List đ
I love this! If you like this genre you should check out Tritsyâs lists too Trapped with a Killer! and It Has To Be One of Them
if youâre taking recs: secluded cabin sleeps six, in a dark dark wood, and dead of winter all fit here!
also breathless by amy mcculloch!
Emmy58OP
Ooh so much winter content I love it! I considered Dark Dark Wood when assembling the list, but there was some reason I didn't feel like it quite fit... maybe I'll have to read it and decide after. But thank you, I've added the rest!!
This is one of my favorite tropes of all time for horror đ you're a gem for this list.
Emmy58OP
â€ïž So glad you like it!!
