BallroomsOfMars commented on a post
I've just come across a simile that is interesting because it's not doing what the author thinks it is, though it's close enough that most readers would move right past it without realising. CW for description of an injury:
She forced herself to walk instead of run, her bones scraping against each other like a violin bow.
Violin bows do not, in and of themselves, scrape. They need a violin. And while "scrape" is a good word for the bones part, it's not something I'd associate with what a violin bow does. Violinists aren't up on stage scraping out music. We can intuit what is meant by the simile so most people wouldn't give it further thought, but on closer inspection it isn't successful. It's only half there, to begin with -- a solitary violin bow in want of a violin. It's also misaligned with the sensation it's trying to describe -- are musical instruments the strongest way to emphasise what is going on here? Maybe they are, if the musicality is harsh and discordant, but that isn't part of the simile as it stands.
The writing in Ninth House has been very solid, so this particular example is more a reminder that a fallible human wrote this. I've been coming across this kind of thing more and more often, though, so think it's worth drawing attention to in general. As readers it is not our job to compensate for the failings of an author's writing or an editor's inattention.
Post from the Ninth House (Alex Stern, #1) forum
I've just come across a simile that is interesting because it's not doing what the author thinks it is, though it's close enough that most readers would move right past it without realising. CW for description of an injury:
She forced herself to walk instead of run, her bones scraping against each other like a violin bow.
Violin bows do not, in and of themselves, scrape. They need a violin. And while "scrape" is a good word for the bones part, it's not something I'd associate with what a violin bow does. Violinists aren't up on stage scraping out music. We can intuit what is meant by the simile so most people wouldn't give it further thought, but on closer inspection it isn't successful. It's only half there, to begin with -- a solitary violin bow in want of a violin. It's also misaligned with the sensation it's trying to describe -- are musical instruments the strongest way to emphasise what is going on here? Maybe they are, if the musicality is harsh and discordant, but that isn't part of the simile as it stands.
The writing in Ninth House has been very solid, so this particular example is more a reminder that a fallible human wrote this. I've been coming across this kind of thing more and more often, though, so think it's worth drawing attention to in general. As readers it is not our job to compensate for the failings of an author's writing or an editor's inattention.
BallroomsOfMars commented on a post
Post from the Ninth House (Alex Stern, #1) forum
BallroomsOfMars joined a quest
Queer Horror 👻💀🏳️🌈
🏆 // 4997 joined
Not Joined



From psychedelic fever dreams to things that go bump in the night: all things queer and scary.
BallroomsOfMars joined a quest
Fever Dreams & Strange Realities 👁🗝😵
🏆 // 1958 joined
Not Joined



Reality is overrated! These surreal and absurd fiction books remove logic to reveal their truths. Here the impossible is inevitable, the strange is necessary, and Kafkaesque is only the beginning.
BallroomsOfMars made progress on...
BallroomsOfMars commented on a post
Please stop telling me Alex avoids looking directly at the Grays. I know. I paid attention the first time, and the second time, the third, the fourth…
BallroomsOfMars left a rating...
BallroomsOfMars left a rating...
Post from the Ninth House (Alex Stern, #1) forum
Please stop telling me Alex avoids looking directly at the Grays. I know. I paid attention the first time, and the second time, the third, the fourth…
BallroomsOfMars started reading...

Ninth House
Leigh Bardugo
BallroomsOfMars paused reading...

Middlegame (Alchemical Journeys, #1)
Seanan McGuire