BookishlyErica joined a quest
Forgive Us Our Trespasses: Religious Horror đâ ď¸đš
đ // 2072 joined
Not Joined



This Quest was inspired by the List "forgive us our trespasses: religious horror," winner of Q2 2026 community voting.
BookishlyErica commented on a post
[...] there were no tidings of Carmilla. Of the scene that had occurred in the ruined chapel, no explanation was offered to me, and it was clear that it was a secret which my father for the present determined to keep from me.
Okay, here comes one of my main issues with this book: Laura is utterly stupid.
I made some jokes about it, but in all seriousness, I find it astonishing that (apparently) the idea of a woman displaying the tiniest bit of logicality and rationality was absolutely inconceivable for the author/the victorian society - even tho at that time women pioneered a lot of social, technological, medical innovations.
At times, we might argue that Laura doesn't understand the situation because her father keeps her in the dark (cf. the consultation with the doctor) and due to lack of informations that she couldn't obtain herself (in the case of the chosen example: a medical opinion) she is unable to reach the correct conclusions.
But, most of the time Laura doesn't even TRY to reach any conclusion/make any deduction. She just let herself be carried around by men and never tries to exercise her free will and completely lacks agency, even when her survival is at stakes.
Even if she's young, sheltered, naive, or whatever, I think she should be able to understand this situation (cf. quote up above) thanks to the extensive amount of informations the General shared.
I find the characterization of Laura a bit strange, given that Le Fanu associated with a good number of artists and activists of his time*, and some of same were * gasp * women.
*I just made a quick online search so I don't really have names, I'd need to look a bit deeper into that.
BookishlyErica TBR'd a book

Idle Grounds
Krystelle Bamford
BookishlyErica TBR'd a book

So Thirsty
Rachel Harrison
BookishlyErica TBR'd a book

Thrall
Rebecca Mahoney
BookishlyErica TBR'd a book

I Heard Her Call My Name: A Memoir of Transition
Lucy Sante
BookishlyErica TBR'd a book

Hot Girl Murder Club: A Novel
Ashley Winstead
BookishlyErica TBR'd a book

If Books Could Kill
Kate Eberle
BookishlyErica TBR'd a book

The Ending Writes Itself
Evelyn Clarke
BookishlyErica wrote a review...
This was a very mid book and currently my least favorite read from 831. This is a modern retelling of When Harry met Sally if Harry and Sally were just horny for each other. Donât get me wrong I like a little spice in my books but this book makes spice the whole plot somehow. This made it a bit repetitive/boring. I found I kept expecting the characters to dive deeper and give us more but they never did beyond the obvious things. Didnât hate it but didnât love it. Ok for a quick read!
BookishlyErica started reading...

Victorian Psycho
Virginia Feito
BookishlyErica finished a book

Exit Lane
Erika Veurink
BookishlyErica TBR'd a book

The Butcher
Jennifer Hillier