Hotspur91 TBR'd a book

Borealis
Aisha Sabatini Sloan
Hotspur91 TBR'd a book

Forest Euphoria: The Abounding Queerness of Nature
Patricia Ononiwu Kaishian
Hotspur91 TBR'd a book

Winter Hours: Prose, Prose Poems, and Poems
Mary Oliver
Hotspur91 TBR'd a book

The Book of (More) Delights: Essays
Ross Gay
Hotspur91 TBR'd a book

Owls and Other Fantasies: Poems and Essays
Mary Oliver
Hotspur91 wrote a review...
It can be difficult to review a classic from a time with such different attitudes towards marginalized people as we have today. However, I think it is fair to give Steinbeck the credit of accurately reflecting the views of his time, not outright endorsing them. The marginalized characters in this novella are sometimes described stereotypically but are nevertheless treated with compassion by the narration. It's complicated, basically. I think the sole female character comes off the least charitably.
The strange thing is that I could have sworn I never read this book in school, but I had some vague idea of the plot—and I don't think it was just Steinbeck's foreshadowing at work. Perhaps we watched a film adaptation in one of my classes, or maybe it's just cultural osmosis. Either way, it's not difficult to guess what is going to happen, but the inevitability is intrinsic to the tragedy.
In the spirit once again of wanting to give Steinbeck the benefit of the doubt, my understanding of his message is that it's close to impossible to care for someone who can't properly care for themself when you are already in precarious circumstances yourself. That doesn't make what George does at the ending right, but that's literature. You can't make a good decision when the options given to you are all bad; you just have to make the decision you can justify to yourself and live with.
It's a grim read, no getting around it. So while I admired the carefully paced plot and the stark descriptions of "bindle" life in the 30s, I can't see myself wanting to return to this book for a reread as I do with many other classics. I do, however, want to continue reading more from Steinbeck; I couldn't get into The Pearl, but I would like to read East of Eden ahead of the new adaptation. I've only read Grapes of Wrath otherwise.
Hotspur91 finished a book

Of Mice and Men
John Steinbeck
Hotspur91 is re-reading...

Blue Lily, Lily Blue
Maggie Stiefvater
Hotspur91 finished a book

The Dream Thieves
Maggie Stiefvater