hollagraph wrote a review...
“Time happens all at once for Helm, more or less, relative to longevity.”
I believe this opening line is meant to set the tone for an elaborate chorus of voices through the ages that collectively tell the stories of Helm, a named wind in north central England. The concept is strong, writing is gorgeous, the first and last chapters are brilliant. I especially loved the Bronze Age story.
What kept this from being a runaway success for me was the chopped up editing of each story. I think the novel would have worked better with the stories told coherently, sequentially, and with clear titles to orient the reader to some anchor of time or name. Unfortunately, I also think most of these unconnected stories lacked compelling stakes and cut away right at any point of action in favor of introspective inner dialogue (which Helm admits to “Helmself” is not totally clear). So while I see the rational from an artistic standpoint, the structure interrupted the reading flow without adding any deeper surprise or meaning for me.
hollagraph finished a book

Helm
Sarah Hall
hollagraph earned a badge

Classic Literature from the United States
Gold: Finished 15 Main Quest books.
Post from the Helm forum
hollagraph is interested in reading...

The Unmapping
Denise S. Robbins
hollagraph is interested in reading...

Arboreality
Rebecca Campbell
hollagraph is interested in reading...

The Tusks of Extinction
Ray Nayler