avatar

lilymunster666

I love a good fantasy, litfic, dystopia, or historical fiction. I love some good worldbuilding and I have elite taste.

1421 points

0% overlap
Level 4
Fall 2025 Readalong
My Taste
Legendborn (The Legendborn Cycle, #1)
Hell Followed With Us
Between Two Fires
A Wizard of Earthsea (Earthsea Cycle, #1)
Babel
Reading...
The JungleSpinning SilverNightbitchThere Was a CountryCapital: A Critique of Political Economy Volume 1The Farthest Shore (Earthsea Cycle, #3)The Prison Healer (The Prison Healer, #1)Wuthering HeightsQuicksilver (Fae & Alchemy, #1)

lilymunster666 finished reading and wrote a review...

2d
  • Heartwood
    lilymunster666
    Oct 03, 2025
    2.0
    Enjoyment: 1.0Quality: 3.0Characters: 2.0Plot: 2.0
    😐
    😴
    😑

    It wasn't terrible, but it sure felt meaningless. I didn't feel any big emotions because of how heavy handed the theme felt. I truly didn't feel anything. Lena as a character doesn't have any purpose til the big reveal. And it was cheapened because we already knew what happened to Valerie due to her having her own POV. Which was a stupid ass choice. It should have been only Lt. Bev who had a POV. It would have been a better book. Because then there would at least be some mystery on Valerie. But no, you just get told how she's doing every single chapter. Santo's interviews were literally pointless and only exist to have a black guy as comedy relief. This was clunky and boring.

    1
    comments 0
    Reply
  • lilymunster666 commented on a post

    4d
  • Nightbitch
    Thoughts from 22%

    This makes me not want to be a mom or a wife to a man even more. Because yikes. I'm an artist. Not doing art anymore because of some snot-nosed kid would make me scream. Also having that annoying incompetent idiot for a husband would make me homicidal. Straight married ladies with kids almost make me sad when I look at them, as a lesbian. Poor souls. I would have already murdered that man by then.

    8
    comments 4
    Reply
  • Post from the Nightbitch forum

    4d
  • Nightbitch
    Thoughts from 22%

    This makes me not want to be a mom or a wife to a man even more. Because yikes. I'm an artist. Not doing art anymore because of some snot-nosed kid would make me scream. Also having that annoying incompetent idiot for a husband would make me homicidal. Straight married ladies with kids almost make me sad when I look at them, as a lesbian. Poor souls. I would have already murdered that man by then.

    8
    comments 4
    Reply
  • lilymunster666 commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    4d
  • The most annoying thing a person can say

    You didn't like the book because you didn't get it. PISSES ME OFF EVERY TIME. ESPECIALLY WHEN THE BOOK IS SO INCREDIBLY SIMPLE ANYONE COULD HAVE GOTTEN IT. You are making the book out to be more intelligent and high level than it actually is. Cough cough Secret History fans who pretend that people who gave it bad reviews just aren't smart. This happens every time someone gives any author with some "intellectual" acclaim (aka anyone outside of the Romantasy-J. Maas-Dark Romance-Cont. Romance-smut side of Booktok) a bad review. If you didn't like Poppy War, "you didn't get it". If you didn't like Six of Crows, "you didn't get it". If you didn't like My Year Of Rest and Relaxation, "you didn't get it". For the love of God! Sure, some people genuinely did not get the point of the book and hate it for anti-intellectual reasons. But people who hate the way The Secret History was written due to having many parts where literally nothing happens for pages on end, are not stupid because of that. You didn't even actually care to listen to them. You just scream "you didn't get it" or "that's the point" until you feel satisfied by being soooooo much smarter. They have the same mindset as people who refuse to listen to critiques on Sarah J Maas, who makes even worse books. Because in their eyes, it's not the same because it's obvious that those suck.

    29
    comments 30
    Reply
  • Post from the Spinning Silver forum

    6d
  • Spinning Silver
    Thoughts from 8%

    Naomi Novik, I am sorry to have doubted your writing. Don't read A Deadly Education first. Read this. Then get disappointed by A Deadly Education. This is masterful fantasy work and by far one of the most unique retellings ever.

    11
    comments 2
    Reply
  • Post from the Heartwood forum

    6d
  • Heartwood
    Thoughts from 40%

    Idk how to feel. One one hand, I think it's ok. But it's not great. There are definitely parts that lowkey made me feel a bit alienated as a black reader such as the haha funny moment taking a jab at defund the police liberals which wasn't uber conservative, but definitely threw me off. Because the book is set during 2020 so people definitely did have strong opinions on it, and I still think they need less money (I mean seriously a billion dollars?). The handling of the singular person of color feels a bit like the black guy who is there for comedy. Like even the uneasiness that we feel in white spaces is played for a joke...for a white guy to laugh at. A white cop. Which, I would say is a masterful move because the white lady who has gone missing was seen with him repeatedly so yeah I can see him doing that for survival. But idk if that was the point. I can't tell if Amity Gage has that level of racial awareness. Because I can't tell at all from the overly white centered POV we are writing from. Santo is a mystery. Anyway, this book isn't hitting very hard in the feels so far. I feel pretty meh. The twist of who HIM was felt lackluster so maybe there is another twist? If not, probably going to be 3 stars.

    2
    comments 0
    Reply
  • lilymunster666 paused reading...

    6d
    Blood at the Root

    Blood at the Root

    LaDarrion Williams

    1
    0
    Reply

    lilymunster666 started reading...

    6d
    Heartwood

    Heartwood

    Amity Gaige

    1
    0
    Reply

    lilymunster666 commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    6d
  • The most annoying thing a person can say

    You didn't like the book because you didn't get it. PISSES ME OFF EVERY TIME. ESPECIALLY WHEN THE BOOK IS SO INCREDIBLY SIMPLE ANYONE COULD HAVE GOTTEN IT. You are making the book out to be more intelligent and high level than it actually is. Cough cough Secret History fans who pretend that people who gave it bad reviews just aren't smart. This happens every time someone gives any author with some "intellectual" acclaim (aka anyone outside of the Romantasy-J. Maas-Dark Romance-Cont. Romance-smut side of Booktok) a bad review. If you didn't like Poppy War, "you didn't get it". If you didn't like Six of Crows, "you didn't get it". If you didn't like My Year Of Rest and Relaxation, "you didn't get it". For the love of God! Sure, some people genuinely did not get the point of the book and hate it for anti-intellectual reasons. But people who hate the way The Secret History was written due to having many parts where literally nothing happens for pages on end, are not stupid because of that. You didn't even actually care to listen to them. You just scream "you didn't get it" or "that's the point" until you feel satisfied by being soooooo much smarter. They have the same mindset as people who refuse to listen to critiques on Sarah J Maas, who makes even worse books. Because in their eyes, it's not the same because it's obvious that those suck.

    29
    comments 30
    Reply
  • Post from the Pagebound Club forum

    6d
  • The most annoying thing a person can say

    You didn't like the book because you didn't get it. PISSES ME OFF EVERY TIME. ESPECIALLY WHEN THE BOOK IS SO INCREDIBLY SIMPLE ANYONE COULD HAVE GOTTEN IT. You are making the book out to be more intelligent and high level than it actually is. Cough cough Secret History fans who pretend that people who gave it bad reviews just aren't smart. This happens every time someone gives any author with some "intellectual" acclaim (aka anyone outside of the Romantasy-J. Maas-Dark Romance-Cont. Romance-smut side of Booktok) a bad review. If you didn't like Poppy War, "you didn't get it". If you didn't like Six of Crows, "you didn't get it". If you didn't like My Year Of Rest and Relaxation, "you didn't get it". For the love of God! Sure, some people genuinely did not get the point of the book and hate it for anti-intellectual reasons. But people who hate the way The Secret History was written due to having many parts where literally nothing happens for pages on end, are not stupid because of that. You didn't even actually care to listen to them. You just scream "you didn't get it" or "that's the point" until you feel satisfied by being soooooo much smarter. They have the same mindset as people who refuse to listen to critiques on Sarah J Maas, who makes even worse books. Because in their eyes, it's not the same because it's obvious that those suck.

    29
    comments 30
    Reply
  • lilymunster666 commented on a post

    6d
  • The Secret History
    ignore the reviews

    this is a very GOOD book lol people on here are annoying and it's almost as overwhelmingly negative and pedantic as goodreads. god bless

    20
    comments 14
    Reply
  • lilymunster666 wrote a review...

    1w
  • The Picture of Dorian Gray
    lilymunster666
    Sep 24, 2025
    5.0
    Enjoyment: 5.0Quality: 5.0Characters: 5.0Plot: 5.0
    🤬
    🫢
    🥳

    Ooh. Let's just say that was a satisfying ending. Overall, the themes in this were great. Character conversations revealed so much and made me hate Lord Henry more than anything. Sin was a recurring theme. Dorian Gray has got to be one of the greatest characters ever made. So interesting to go from liking him to downright despising him by the end. I was wishing for his death by the last pages.

    1
    comments 0
    Reply