Post from the Pagebound Club forum
so this is a not-so-subtle nod to my CR but also something i've been thinking about in general for a while, and noticing in some of the books i've been reading. i don't know why but i've noticed a certain trend in books i read in which the MC is meant to be an underdog and it's going to be a "started from the bottom" type story, and that is the fact that author's seem to be losing the entire point of an underdog story, which is that at some point the MC needs to actually start winning.
i understand that the point is that they start awful and eventually get better at whatever it is they're supposed to be doing, but there's a fine line between having them face adversity and just reading page after page of them being metaphorically (and sometimes literally) ground into the dirt. just bad thing after bad thing keeps happening to them (ergo - A Little Life effect) and not only do they not seem to be taking any wins, it has genuinely no effect on the story other than to add drama. it doesn't cause character development, it doesn't push the plot along, it doesn't even really tell us more about the world. most of the time this ends in the MC having an "i need to lock in" moment where they suddenly start improving.
honestly i just think this is lazy writing. we as the reader are supposed to connect with and root for the MC and if i'm reading chapter after chapter of them losing or being humiliated or falling behind the reading experience is no longer fun or interesting to me. it's boring and repetitive and frustrating because it feels like the story is making no progress. for instance, i am 52% of the way through my CR. i should not be HALFWAY through a >500 page book and the MC is still as scared and helpless as she was on page one.
i don't really have any sort of question here, though i would be interested to know if any of you have noticed the same thing (especially within fantasy books). really i just wanted to rant lol
seekerxr finished reading and wrote a review...
View spoiler
seekerxr started reading...
Glorious Poison (Battalion of the Dead, #3)
Kat Dunn
seekerxr commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
Hey all! So I’ve been wondering this for a while: are Sarah J. Maas books worth the read? I’ve seen a lot of people on here and on Booktube rave about her stuff, but with the controversy surrounding her and my pickiness with the fantasy genre, I’m not sure if I’ll actually like her books. Maybe I just have book FOMO idk 😭😭 What are yalls thoughts?
seekerxr commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
This might be a very niche question, but are there people out there who get attacked by fandoms of books they didn’t like? For me it’s always Fourth Wing, ACOTAR and The Deal :/
I just never really know what to do, because it sometimes feels like expressing my opinion (if not having like the book/author) gets me so much hate from people ij bookish online spaces. I feel comfortable talking about it here though, which is really cool!
seekerxr commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I’ve been wanting to slow down my consumption of books by creating a sort of self imposed book report for better reading comprehension.
Are there any questions I should ask myself before, during, or after reading a book/article/story?
Currently, I don’t think I ask myself anything beforehand, I have comments for in the middle of the book, and only really ask what I can read next after finishing a book.
seekerxr finished reading and wrote a review...
Ok we're upping the drama scale on this one to a bit of ridiculousness, but I'm still enjoying myself so I don't have too much to complain about. I will say I really enjoyed the moral dilemmas in this book; the author seems to be going for the trope of "how far will you go to do the right thing? is it even right at the end of the day?" and that's always fun when it's done well, which it seems to be working out for this series.
These characters are constantly questioning themselves and their loyalties and their friend's loyalties and it's very juicy if nothing else. Watching the whole scrappy teenager crew vibe of "how will they get out of this one?" continue to get more intense was definitely fun! Still giving Six of Crows vibes with secret plans and extra secret plans and extra extra secret backup plans popping up every couple of minutes. It IS verging on the line of unbelievable, but we're still on the side of the line where it doesn't hurt the experience too much, so I'm fine with it for now.
I enjoyed all the new characters were got to see in this book but it does feel like we kind of came to England for no real reason since the duc is still around and being a menace. I'm interested to see how it's all going to end!
seekerxr started reading...
Monstrous Design (Battalion of the Dead, #2)
Kat Dunn
seekerxr finished reading and wrote a review...
This book hooked me from the very beginning! I don't normally go for historical books but the premise for this was SO interesting. I will admit that the writing is definitely more modern than the author trying to match the writing style to the time period, but I prefer it in this case. This was definitely more of an action-focused novel and if it had been written in an older style it would've slowed it down and it would've been to the story's detriment.
This whole book was just fun. Definitely kind of unbelievable in the Six of Crows fashion where you're like "ok it can't REALLY be a group of teenagers who just keep managing to pull it off" but they do! And it's fun! So I don't mind!
I adored the cast here, and I appreciate that there are 3 confirmed queer characters all in the main cast. I also love how two of the main characters are women and the sexism of the time doesn't affect how amazing they are and how they constantly defy expectations. I love the dynamic between the team, and how it's clear they all care about one another even if they bicker sometimes.
I'm excited to see where the series goes! I'll be cracking into book 2 immediately!
seekerxr commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
Since Pagebound I've been reading more books at once (and just plain reading more) and I've developed some habits I want to share but I also need more tips and want to hear about yours!
I read a nonfiction audiobook, currently The Palestine Laboratory when I'm walking places (mainly to the thrift store and the used bookstore where there are cats for me to pet while listening) or if I'm playing a game I don't have to focus on.
I've been reading my literary fiction, currently A Girl Called Eel while I'm on break at work - it just developed like that I didn't plan it but when I'm at work I'm drawn to my lit fic. I typically like reading my lit fic during the day - it doesn't tend to be a genre I like opening up super early or late so afternoon fits it best.
I've been reading my adult fantasy, currently Babel mostly in the mornings but sometimes staying up late to fit in a couple chapters. Adult fantasy is easier for me to get totally lost in and wanting to stay up for but the morning time calls to it for me and the vibe with my morning tea is perfect for it.
And I've been reading my cozy fantasy, currently Howl's Moving Castle as an in-between when I know I want to read but am emotionally overwhelmed from my other books!
So what's your method if you read multiple books at once? Do you break it up by genre? Time of day? All vibes no plan? I'm tempted to start even more books but I'm worried I'll get lost in the sauce.
seekerxr started reading...
Dangerous Remedy (Battalion of the Dead, #1)
Kat Dunn
seekerxr finished reading and wrote a review...
nothing egregious here, just lost interest. personal taste stuff.
seekerxr DNF'd a book
Shadow of the Fox (Shadow of the Fox, #1)
Julie Kagawa
Post from the Shadow of the Fox (Shadow of the Fox, #1) forum
this is such a stupid ick to have because i KNOW the author of this is japanese herself but the constant interjection of one or two japanese words in an english book is very strongly giving anime fanfiction and it's throwing me off so bad 😫
seekerxr started reading...
Shadow of the Fox (Shadow of the Fox, #1)
Julie Kagawa
seekerxr finished reading and wrote a review...
This was fun! I don't think it needed to be as long as it was but I don't think I remember every getting genuinely bored, so that's a point in it's favor. The 1920s atmosphere was rich and thankfully this author didn't rely heavily on the bigotry of the time to add to the plot, which is what I normally don't like about historical books.
This is one of those first books in a series that plant a lot of seeds that aren't going to go anywhere quite yet. The magic system isn't explained at all except "some people have magic." The villain's whole magic/ritual thing ALSO isn't explained, which is frustrating because he doesn't seem to be a Diviner so you're just kinda left wondering how he's doing all of this when he shouldn't be able to? Maybe?
I really like the way Evie's character was written. I like that the author didn't make her this perfectly likeable protagonist when a white teenager who grew up without having to struggle just wouldn't be a perfect person, especially in the 1920s. I also liked how the author tied in historical events and viewpoints at certain points in the story, whether to enhance the atmosphere or to add to the plot. The eugenics committee was almost a jumpscare even though that was the time period in which they were active and accepted.
I love biblical horror and I love that that's the flavor of villain we got in this book. There were some scenes that read likes scenes from a horror movie; they were almost cinematic, just inside my head. There were some smaller plotlines that threw me off just a little bit, but I don't think any of them negatively impacted the story.
This was a bit difficult to get through but I liked it overall! I have no clue where the author is taking this story next but I'll probably tune in.
seekerxr commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I'm a spinner (I have both a wheel and a couple spindles!) and a knitter. I just finished Paladin's Grace, and I was wondering if anyone knows of any other good books where people spin or knit?
seekerxr commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
This is a topic that would likely spark biiig controversy on any other social platform, but I feel Pagebound is a safe space soo here we go - and I am honestly excited for all your opinions and input!
So, the big question: How do y'all deal with authors who turn out to be problematic, if you've really loved their work before, and also thought they in general were a decent person??
To give an example, last year Neil Gaiman turned out to be a piece of shit and I had been obsessed with his work, comics, shows, everything for a solid 2 years. Crowley and Aziraphale from Good omens are literally my comfort characters and it was super hard to deal with. I know for a lot of people the same thing happened with JKR, and same, but it was somehow less bad in the sense that it happened after my big HP craze - so I found it easier to walk away.
What goes without saying is that you should try not to financially support these people anymore, but do you still read their work, if you've bought the books before? Do you still engage in the fandom? How do you handle it?
Getting more familiar w Terry Pratchett's work, I really felt like re-reading Good Omens, but I feel like now it has a bitter aftertaste. I've found fanfiction to be a kind of safe haven cause it's not directly related to NG whatsoever, but I miss the original stories sometimes.
Hoping for a good conversation! Am a bit afraid cause the whole conversation on tumblr about this topic last year got extremely out of hand haha :I But I'm like genuinely curious and I trust in the pagebound community!
EDIT Just wanna say thank you guys for all the engagement and for having such a great and respectful conversation!! Pagebound is rlly the best community! (Imagine a heart here, I have no clue how to use markdown lol)
seekerxr commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
Hi all! I've been seeing this "personal curriculum" trend all over my socials lately. Maybe I'm just getting old but, is it just like creating a college course...for yourself? Or is it like something you can do as a group?
I'm curious to hear all your thoughts on what you all think of the trend! It seems quite a bit of work - so if you have done it, was it worth it?
Let's discuss :)
seekerxr commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I've never owned an e-reader but I'm considering getting one. My main reason is for portability, I commute to uni so it would be nice to have something to do during my travels. (Also, my bookshelf has officially ran out of space so I'm having to put books into my clothes drawers TT).
Are there any distinctive pros and cons I should be aware of? Is there a wide range of books that you can access?
And, is there any particular e-readers you guys would recommend 🙂↕️? I don't have a massive budget so I'll be prioritising affordability over premium features for the most part.
I'm completely unfamiliar with how they work so any and all information is welcome 💛.