“sometimes it’s inevitable for the past to be forgotten, especially if the present is no less horrific… she’s a nobody and will forever remain a nobody whose voice nobody will hear.”
such a heavy, meaningful read. the stories in part one and two are so thoughtfully mirrored, and it encourages a critical reflection of how we bare witness to historical traumas and the ways in which we honor and carry these stories with us.
while reading this, the lack of names (and the lack of dialogue) really stuck with me. it really emphasizes both the dehumanization of palestinians and lack of individuation in settler colonialism. there is no personal accountability, responsibility, or morality when you are just one of thousands of settlers/soldiers. and there is no humanity or empathy when all palestinians are viewed as “other,” reduced to numbers and/or objects to exploit.
i also wonder if the lack of names is also implying/honoring the fact that this story is one of many. there isn’t just one story to tell, nor is there a singular perpetrator involved. if anything, nearly every palestinian living under israeli occupation has had such experiences. and nearly every israeli settler has contributed to violence against palestinians, in varying degrees.
this is why individual stories are often easily lost to history. especially nowadays when we witness so many unspeakable horrors and want so desperately to give name and voice to these people. yet they are ultimately drowned out by the overwhelm of seeing the same atrocities again and again across history— all without change or consequence. we see this first hand with both the girl in part one and the speaker in part two, because despite taking place several decades apart, they both suffer under the same occupation.