avatar

windycitysarah

388 points

0% overlap
Level 3
My Taste
The Little Liar
The Postcard
Homegoing
We Were the Lucky Ones
The Love Songs of W.E.B. Du Bois
Reading...
Sarah's Key

windycitysarah wrote a review...

8h
  • The Only One Left
    windycitysarah
    Jan 24, 2026
    0.5
    Enjoyment: 0.5Quality: 0.5Characters: 0.5Plot: 0.5
    🍅

    God this was so bad. This is the Ryan Murphy of books. All the twists, none of them land, and the real twist is obvious before you even hit page 100.

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • windycitysarah TBR'd a book

    8h
    The Great Alone

    The Great Alone

    Kristin Hannah

    0
    0
    Reply

    windycitysarah made progress on...

    8h
    Sarah's Key

    Sarah's Key

    Tatiana de Rosnay

    70%
    0
    0
    Reply

    Post from the Sarah's Key forum

    22h
  • Sarah's Key
    Thoughts from 43% (page 126)

    I generally love multi-timeline/POV but I wish the author wouldn’t switch between the two narrators every chapter. This chapter would’ve been the perfect time to start Sarah’s story - ie. Julia the first third, Sarah’s story the middle and converge the two stories at the end.

    1
    comments 0
    Reply
  • windycitysarah made progress on...

    1d
    Sarah's Key

    Sarah's Key

    Tatiana de Rosnay

    29%
    0
    0
    Reply

    windycitysarah DNF'd a book

    2d
    My Friends

    My Friends

    Fredrik Backman

    0
    0
    Reply

    windycitysarah commented on trishjgibson's review of My Friends

    3d
  • My Friends
    trishjgibson
    Nov 15, 2025
    1.5
    Enjoyment: 1.5Quality: 1.5Characters: 2.0Plot: 1.5

    I couldn’t get into the writing style or the author’s third person narration of the story. It felt overwritten and could have done with a bit less of everything. Nearly every line was a similie “he smiled, and it was like someone waving through fog” - “he popped back out of the bush like a stripper from a cake”. I eyerolled my way through this book for my book club but, sometimes you can just say exactly what you mean and that is, in fact, enough. 

    0
    comments 2
    Reply
  • windycitysarah commented on alienromancefreak's review of Vladimir

    3d
  • Vladimir
    alienromancefreak
    Jan 01, 2026
    1.0
    Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:

    If I am ever in danger of caring about men this much I'll adopt another cat lmao

    2
    comments 1
    Reply
  • windycitysarah wrote a review...

    3d
  • Vladimir
    windycitysarah
    Jan 21, 2026
    5.0
    Enjoyment: 5.0Quality: 5.0Characters: 5.0Plot: 5.0

    This book made me realize that I should probably give all books under 3.5 ⭐️ a chance. With the current booktok obsessions, I’m convinced that anything not written in YA style with nuance is automatically going to be higher rated. Loved the storytelling style, loved the narrator grappling with her life + feelings. It was all just amazing.

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • windycitysarah commented on a post

    3d
  • Half His Age
    Has anyone read My Dark Vanessa?

    I read it a few years ago, and the synopsis of Half his Age sounds eerily similar, so I was wondering if I should expect anything original.

    6
    comments 4
    Reply
  • Post from the My Friends forum

    3d
  • My Friends
    Thoughts from 3% (page 14)

    “Right before the out throwing in question, she painted the guard, which doesn’t mean that she paints a guard on a wall, but actually paints the guard himself. Unfortunately, of course, the guard does not give the impression that he is the sort of person who appreciates symbolism of that sort, he just rushes over, as angry as a wild boar that’s been given a habanero suppository, and grabs her so hard that she screams. Shortly after that, he screams too.”

    I fear this may be a DNF for me - so much description to the point of trailing off. It’s like listening to the one friend try to tell a story that ends up going in 90 different directions because they think every detail is important when it’s not. I’m all for rich storytelling and painting a picture but there comes a point where it’s rambling - why did the above need an entire paragraph when it could’ve ended at the first sentence? I know this must be plenty of people who enjoy this type of writing but nothing infuriates me more than an author who thinks the reader needs an entire scene literally spelled out for them. Not throwing in the towel yet but morale is low 😂

    1
    comments 1
    Reply
  • Post from the My Friends forum

    5d
  • My Friends
    Thoughts from 3% (page 14)

    Gosh I love it when authors of long novels have short chapters! I feel like it makes it so much easier to get through the book - I hate stopping in the middle of chapters + I usually read at night, so if I know I can’t make it through 20 pages, I just won’t even start.

    3
    comments 1
    Reply
  • windycitysarah started reading...

    5d
    My Friends

    My Friends

    Fredrik Backman

    0
    0
    Reply

    windycitysarah TBR'd a book

    5d
    Dark Sisters

    Dark Sisters

    Kristi DeMeester

    0
    0
    Reply