AndromedaGal is interested in reading...

Still Life
Sarah Winman
AndromedaGal TBR'd a book

The Once and Future Witches
Alix E. Harrow
AndromedaGal started reading...

The Sirens
Emilia Hart
AndromedaGal paused reading...

The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny
Kiran Desai
AndromedaGal is re-reading...

The Last Time I Lied
Riley Sager
AndromedaGal left a rating...
AndromedaGal finished a book

Dungeon Crawler Carl (Dungeon Crawler Carl, #1)
Matt Dinniman
AndromedaGal commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
So today I was talking with a bookclub I was going to join, but decided against it because unfortunately I was very very different from them and they just wouldn't have a good time since I don't fit in at all. (Womp womp for me. Maybe next time!!)
For a moment, we actually almost started an argument. They brought up the last book they read, and I meantioned that I also read it and unfortunately didn't like it... I know I shouldn't have said this, I was just nervous and blurted it out!! But the conversation basically turned into an argument that hate-reviews and/or overly negative reviews should not be public if they aren't constructive because the author spent a lot of time on their book and it won't change now that it's published, that if you aren't an editor or author yourself you don't have the credentials to offer such criticism, and that all reviews should offer some kind of constructive criticism to help the author grow for their next work...
And more, but... I didn't really feel like retelling how a group of people yelled at me... 😭
So. I write pretty negative things about a lot of books. Unfortunately I am very fussy and picky with books most of the time, and I have definitely written a hate-review(?) or two before. But I NEVER tag authors or insult them as a person. I always thought that if you buy a product, you are open to criticize and dislike it, because reviews aren't for the one that made the product... but for people looking to buy said product.
The whole thing made me feel some type of way, and I'm not sure if I'm just being sensitive because they called me out but I just wanted to know what other people think and how you guys write your reviews! Do you think authors belong in reader/review spaces? How do you go about writing your reviews? I'm very curious and I want to do better with my own reviews.. 🦭
AndromedaGal commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
The Shining by Stephen King My Brilliant Friend by Elena Ferrante Commonwealth by Ann Patchett The Story Sisters by Alice Hoffman
AndromedaGal started reading...

The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny
Kiran Desai
Post from the Dungeon Crawler Carl (Dungeon Crawler Carl, #1) forum
As a gamer I have found this really charming and enjoyable. At the same time, I am wondering if it's going to be kind of the same thing all the way through. I mean, I get what they're doing and now I'm thinking ok that was cute, do I need to read any more? Thoughts?
AndromedaGal commented on a post
how many times am I going to read the full name of Anna Pavlovna? this could be a drinking game my god 🥴
AndromedaGal commented on a post
All I picture is Danny Devito as Mordecai in a rat suit. For the love of God, if this becomes a movie, make it happen. That — and make Jim Henson in charge of the creatures.
AndromedaGal is interested in reading...

The Unhaunting
Micaiah Johnson
AndromedaGal wrote a review...
I quite like this author generally speaking, and his combination of absurd and humorous, but this was sad and somewhat distressing. I did not enjoy reading it. CW: psychological abuse.
AndromedaGal finished a book

The Family Fang
Kevin Wilson
AndromedaGal started reading...

Dungeon Crawler Carl (Dungeon Crawler Carl, #1)
Matt Dinniman
AndromedaGal commented on ranthesolarpunk's review of Suffer the Children
Eh. The concept of the book was interesting enough to hold my attention, but it lacked depth. All the kids in the world die and come back after 3 days, hungry. Okay. They want blood, okay.
The parents struggle with whether or not to give them blood, and then eventually they do.
Yes, I definitely believe that a parent would give their children blood just to see them again. 1000%. However the catch is, the cure doesn’t keep the kids alive long enough for any real life to be lived and it’s here where the book could have been deeper to me and even started to lose me.
As a parent and as a parent who has lost an infant the author displayed the grief the parents initially feel, realistically. He was on point with the rage, the unfairness, the everything. However, at one point, I stopped reading to see if the author bio would reveal if he had any children because at that point it didn’t read like it.
Yes many parents would do anything for their kids, but there comes a point that even with the desire to “provide” for their kids, parents would see reason and I think the book could have been deeper and even scarier examining what it would mean for the parents to realize that what kids are doing isn’t living. I’m Just one person, but I’ve been in forums with parents about grief and what we would do for more time and why we made decisions we made and I don’t think Dilouie actually talked to parents, which I think would have given the story more depth.
Because in short: I don’t know a parent who would put these kids through what these parents put their kids through, for only a few more hours.
The characters were flat. Often the women were all: “You don’t know what it means to be a mother” and the men were like “I’m a man. I must provide. Eat the rich. I’m getting blood for my kids. Roar”
And idk reading it felt like watching a crazy Lifetime movie. Like something that looked like it had promise but then you end up texting your friend like: “Girl let me tell you about this crazy ass movie.” And then you spend the rest of it crying-laughing because what in the hell??
I hope this made sense.
AndromedaGal joined a quest
Made for the Movies 🎥⭐😎
🏆 // 8474 joined
Not Joined



Books that made it on the big screen