Capella commented on a post
Okay, I'm torn between "Thank god, it's over" and "Wow, what a fascinating story." I still think it would make a good telenovela. The story is way too complicated and has too many characters and side-stories to reasonably fit into a movie or even a mini-series. That would break it. It is a story that, to develop its full potential, needs to be told exactly as Radcliffe tells it: slowly adding layer after layer of mystique and mystery, building a many skinned onion of tension that then, only in the last volume, slowly gets peeled open, revealing what's behind it all.
It's a book that does not gel with modern tastes very well, where everything has to be efficient, on-point and immediately gratifying. This book takes patience and devotion. But then the reward is fantastic. I absolutely understand why this book was so loved at a time when reading was for many people, especially many women, their main way of escapism, when there was no tv, no social media, no quick way to entertain yourself. And I also understand why it has fallen out of favor since. It's not an instant dopamine rush. Instead it is a slowly rising tide that only gets you fully submerged towards the end.
Capella finished a book

Jane Austen's Bookshelf: A Rare Book Collector's Quest to Find the Women Writers Who Shaped a Legend
Rebecca Romney
Capella commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
Which book formats do you prefer to read in? Paperback, audiobook or ebook? Is there a reason as to why?
Capella finished reading and wrote a review...
Okay, I'm torn between "Thank god, it's over" and "Wow, what a fascinating story." It took me almost two weeks to read this book, which is long for me, especially for a book that contemporary readers considered an absolute page-turner. I had a hard time getting into it at first, partly because nothing much happened in the beginning, but also because I had to get used to Radcliffes style and her overly complicated way of shoving way to many subclauses into one sentence.
But I got more and more intrigued the further I read on. From the reputation of the book, I had expected more typical gothic horror and fewer crazy plot-twists. But this is not a simple ghost story or a vampire gore fest. This is first and foremost the story of unhappy people who made bad decisions that come back to haunt them. Oh, and there's dead bodies and robbers and pirates and sword and gunfights galore. But they serve more as a backdrop to the stories that really count.
I think the book would make a good telenovela. The story is way too complicated and has too many characters and side-stories to reasonably fit into a movie or even a mini-series. That would break it. It is a story that, to develop its full potential, needs to be told exactly as Radcliffe tells it: slowly adding layer after layer of mystique and mystery, building a many skinned onion of tension that then, only in the last volume, slowly gets peeled open, revealing what's behind it all.
It's a book that does not gel with modern tastes very well, where everything has to be efficient, on-point and immediately gratifying. This book takes patience and devotion. But then the reward is fantastic. I absolutely understand why this book was so loved at a time when reading was for many people, especially many women, their main way of escapism, when there was no tv, no social media, no quick way to entertain yourself. And I also understand why it has fallen out of favor since. It's not an instant dopamine rush. Instead it is a slowly rising tide that only gets you fully submerged towards the end.
Post from the The Mysteries of Udolpho forum
Okay, I'm torn between "Thank god, it's over" and "Wow, what a fascinating story." I still think it would make a good telenovela. The story is way too complicated and has too many characters and side-stories to reasonably fit into a movie or even a mini-series. That would break it. It is a story that, to develop its full potential, needs to be told exactly as Radcliffe tells it: slowly adding layer after layer of mystique and mystery, building a many skinned onion of tension that then, only in the last volume, slowly gets peeled open, revealing what's behind it all.
It's a book that does not gel with modern tastes very well, where everything has to be efficient, on-point and immediately gratifying. This book takes patience and devotion. But then the reward is fantastic. I absolutely understand why this book was so loved at a time when reading was for many people, especially many women, their main way of escapism, when there was no tv, no social media, no quick way to entertain yourself. And I also understand why it has fallen out of favor since. It's not an instant dopamine rush. Instead it is a slowly rising tide that only gets you fully submerged towards the end.
Post from the The Mysteries of Udolpho forum
Bandits! Robbers! A very narrow escape. Okay, I admit it. The book is really exciting and there is never a dull moment. Well, maybe a few dull moments in all the landscape descriptions and poems, but the author really knows how to weave a tale. I'm beginning to understand why this book has captivated its readers so much and propelled the genre of the gothic novel to unexpected heights. It's the "Twilight" or "Iron Wings" of its time.
Post from the Jane Austen's Bookshelf: A Rare Book Collector's Quest to Find the Women Writers Who Shaped a Legend forum
I'm doing the Jane Austen July and the book I had picked as non-fiction originally absolutely did not pull me in, so I DNFed that and decided to give Romney's book a try instead. I found it as audiobook on Spotify. So far I really like it. It is a good companion-read to "The Mysteries of Udolpho", since Ann Radcliffe is one of the authors featured by Romney. And also because I'm quite interested in "forgotten" female authors from Austen's time in general. I'm on a similar hunt for German female authors from the same period (because those also existed, but have been buried even deeper than the English ones).
Capella started reading...

Jane Austen's Bookshelf: A Rare Book Collector's Quest to Find the Women Writers Who Shaped a Legend
Rebecca Romney
Post from the The Mysteries of Udolpho forum
I am reading this book for the Jane Austen July readathon, so I am very eager to finish it this month. That made me struggle with Radcliff's long-winded style and the many side-stories a bit more than I otherwise would have. In parts the book reminds me of one of those long Turkish telenovelas that go on for more than 100 episodes and that spend many minutes in each episode on montages with melodramatic music and people staring longingly into the distance. That's what it feels like to read this book. Actually, it would make a good basis for a telenovela like that. Yet there are so many secrets and mysteries, so many questions that need answering, that the tension rises and rises and I find it hard to put the book down, even though it is still hard to read.
Oh, and by the way ... Valancourt ... more useless than ever. Seriously, run, girl! Find someone else. He's a disaster waiting to happen and about as sexy as a bag of oatmeal.
Capella joined a quest
LGBTQ+ Sci-Fi & Fantasy 🏳️🌈🪐🦄
🏆 // 4444 joined
Not Joined



Magical empires, far-flung galaxies, robotic dystopias, haunted academies—queerness belongs in every world.
Capella TBR'd a book

When the Tides Held the Moon
Venessa Vida Kelley
Post from the The Mysteries of Udolpho forum