avatar

GothicDreamer

Trying to pick reading back up after my maths degree had me years without touching a non-academic text. She/her. 24. 🏳️‍🌈.

557 points

0% overlap
Gothic Literature
Level 4
Horror Starter Pack Vol I
My Taste
Les Misérables
Wuthering Heights
Dracula
Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe
No.6, Volume 1
Reading...
The King in Yellow
20%
Mexican Gothic
23%
Complete Sonnets
6%
The Secret History
10%
El infinito en un junco: La invención de los libros en el mundo antiguo
0%

GothicDreamer commented on a post

1d
  • The Starving Saints
    Thoughts from 60%
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    14
    comments 6
    Reply
  • GothicDreamer commented on a post

    8w
  • Mexican Gothic
    Thoughts from 13%
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    16
    comments 2
    Reply
  • GothicDreamer made progress on...

    11w
    The King in Yellow

    The King in Yellow

    Robert W. Chambers

    20%
    1
    0
    Reply

    GothicDreamer made progress on...

    11w
    The King in Yellow

    The King in Yellow

    Robert W. Chambers

    10%
    0
    0
    Reply

    GothicDreamer started reading...

    11w
    The King in Yellow

    The King in Yellow

    Robert W. Chambers

    0
    0
    Reply

    GothicDreamer wrote a review...

    11w
  • His Black Tongue
    GothicDreamer
    Jun 07, 2026
    His Black Tongue
    1.5
    Enjoyment: 1.5Quality: 1.5Characters: 1.0Plot: 2.0

    Since this was an anthology, I will do a review for each story.

    His Black Tongue: 1/5

    The titular story, and the worst one. I was hooked with the summary, the concept was incredible, and then it delivered absolutely nothing.

    Everything is told, not shown. Our main characters come from outside Enfaire, but except from some detached descriptions of the plague outside, the show no reacting from what in their eyes should be a bordeline apocalypthic situation, the are so apathetic about everything. Everything they see is "horrors" and "gates of hell" and whatever but it feels so flat.

    Rami, our saintess, in so annoying. Her process of becoming a saintess reads like a shopping list, and she doesn't feel too virtuos in general. She started spitting accusations with barely any proof and believed herself to be Sherlock Homes for how sure she was of her findings. (And talking about anoachronisms, the characters use the word "resurrectionists", which is a term for body snatchers coined in the 18th century, not the middle ages.)

    Pierre is as interesting as a cardboard. That's it.

    This story is religious horror in the same way the Ao no Exorcist/Blue Exorcist manga is religious fiction, which is "not really but I guess kinda yes". They throw around the words Inquisition, saint, prioress, hell and devil, but at no point is faith, dogma or sin a real part of the plot. You could say they chose a christian aesthetic for an otherwise empty story. And no, no matter what the summary says, their faith is never "tested". Not even the smallest interrogation symbol, let alone a test.

    The dialogues of our villain seemed taken out of some corny kids show, they would be funny if they weren't so cringe. And the fight scene was so boring it felt eternal.

    If you liked the summary, just stay there and do not read the book, that summary did a better job of what the story was trying to do than the actual story.

    The Bone Fields: 2/5

    Interesting concept, better writing than the previous story, but the author's writing is so monotonous that even when there was stuff happening, it was boring to read. The ending was cool, but the rest was average.

    The Knights of the Non-Euclidean Table : 1.5/5

    Before talking about the story, let's talk about the title. "Non-Euclidean" is actually a fairly simple geometric term that horror authors love to throw around because they think it sounds like something beyond human comprehension. It's not.

    Take a basket ball. That surface is a sphere. Can you comprehend that? Yes? Congrats, your human mind was able to understand a non-euclidean surface.

    When authors do this, they tell me they just use words they think sound cool without having any idea of what they mean. That's lazy, and it makes the whole thing look stupid. Like what were you even trying to say?

    Maybe they were trying to make the story actually lovecraftian, because turns out just adding a monster with tentacles does not do the job. The story was still boring. A lot of build up that did nothing for the tension, for a whatever resolution.

    Necropolis: 3/5

    I know, I was as surprised as anyone reading this review that I actually liked this story. Simple, an actually eery world building, the characters were very likeable in the short time we had with them, and the story didn't over extend beyond what it had to offer. I feel bad having this at the end of maybe one of the most pissed off reviews I have done.

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • GothicDreamer earned a badge

    11w
    Level 4

    Level 4

    500 points

    0
    0
    Reply

    GothicDreamer commented on a post

    11w
  • Beautiful Creatures
    Thoughts from 0% (page 2)

    reading this bc the movie was one of my guilty pleasures

    8
    comments 2
    Reply
  • GothicDreamer commented on a post

    11w
  • Fahrenheit 451
    Thoughts from 92%

    What book would you choose to store in your mind forever?

    I think it would be the Hobbit for me, even though it doesn’t feel as important as the works mentioned by Granger.

    20
    comments 5
    Reply
  • GothicDreamer commented on a post

    11w
  • His Black Tongue
    Thoughts from 29%- Begin of "The Bone Fields"

    I am now finding out that this is in fact not a novel, but two novellas and two short stories, which actually makes a lot of sense with how the big plotwist of the titular story was revealed at 21%.

    That was totally my fault, I am not sure if the "About" was updated since I added this book, or if I somehow completely missed that last part.

    3
    comments 3
    Reply
  • Post from the His Black Tongue forum

    11w
  • His Black Tongue
    Thoughts from 29%- Begin of "The Bone Fields"

    I am now finding out that this is in fact not a novel, but two novellas and two short stories, which actually makes a lot of sense with how the big plotwist of the titular story was revealed at 21%.

    That was totally my fault, I am not sure if the "About" was updated since I added this book, or if I somehow completely missed that last part.

    3
    comments 3
    Reply
  • Post from the His Black Tongue forum

    11w
  • His Black Tongue
    Thoughts from 21%
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    3
    comments 0
    Reply
  • GothicDreamer made progress on...

    11w
    His Black Tongue

    His Black Tongue

    Mitchell Lüthi

    100%
    0
    0
    Reply

    Post from the His Black Tongue forum

    12w
  • His Black Tongue
    Thoughts from 15%
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    1
    comments 0
    Reply
  • GothicDreamer made progress on...

    12w
    His Black Tongue

    His Black Tongue

    Mitchell Lüthi

    10%
    0
    0
    Reply

    GothicDreamer TBR'd a book

    12w
    The King in Yellow

    The King in Yellow

    Robert W. Chambers

    0
    0
    Reply