avatar

IndubidablyAli

30 she/Her Lover of fantasy, sci fi, crime and romance, and any combination of the four. The consumption of books is so important, no matter the form

2648 points

0% overlap
Fall 2025 Readalong
Winter 2026 Readalong
Level 5
My Taste
Naked in Death (In Death, #1)
The Princess Bride
Reforged
Service Model
Don't Let the Forest In
Reading...
Otto and the Flying Twins
68%
Book Lovers
39%

IndubidablyAli commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

15h
  • Nostalgia reads - how do you rate them?

    I’m currently working on reading more children’s/YA books because I have nieces and nephews that I want to be able to safely recommend books to (I have learned I have a big pet peeve about people asking if books are suitable for their kids - just read the book yourself to see if it’s suitable? It’s your child damn it) and obviously I want to give ratings to encourage others to read them too, but there’s obviously a vast difference between the complexity of the books aimed at young adults/mature audiences and children’s books that means while I might not be as wowed by the writing of the book, it’s still a great story etc, or for those nostalgic reads it’s got a warm place in my heart but wouldn’t fit in my current rating scale.

    So I’m curious now, how do other people rate the books they read that they know a younger audience or a different audience would love? Do you base it on your own experience or do you rate it for the perspective of the intent - ie. recommending the book to its intended audience

    13
    comments 13
    Reply
  • IndubidablyAli made progress on...

    15h
    Book Lovers

    Book Lovers

    Emily Henry

    39%
    1
    0
    Reply

    Post from the Pagebound Club forum

    1d
  • Nostalgia reads - how do you rate them?

    I’m currently working on reading more children’s/YA books because I have nieces and nephews that I want to be able to safely recommend books to (I have learned I have a big pet peeve about people asking if books are suitable for their kids - just read the book yourself to see if it’s suitable? It’s your child damn it) and obviously I want to give ratings to encourage others to read them too, but there’s obviously a vast difference between the complexity of the books aimed at young adults/mature audiences and children’s books that means while I might not be as wowed by the writing of the book, it’s still a great story etc, or for those nostalgic reads it’s got a warm place in my heart but wouldn’t fit in my current rating scale.

    So I’m curious now, how do other people rate the books they read that they know a younger audience or a different audience would love? Do you base it on your own experience or do you rate it for the perspective of the intent - ie. recommending the book to its intended audience

    13
    comments 13
    Reply
  • Post from the Otto and the Flying Twins forum

    1d
  • Otto and the Flying Twins
    Thoughts from 69% (page 208)

    I love revisiting old books from my childhood and this world is holding up so far! Definitely going to be recommending this to my nephew for some whimsical adventures.

    1
    comments 0
    Reply
  • IndubidablyAli made progress on...

    1d
    Otto and the Flying Twins

    Otto and the Flying Twins

    Charlotte Haptie

    68%
    1
    0
    Reply

    IndubidablyAli made progress on...

    1d
    Book Lovers

    Book Lovers

    Emily Henry

    36%
    1
    0
    Reply

    IndubidablyAli commented on a post

    2d
  • Book Lovers
    Thoughts from 2% (page 6)
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    32
    comments 2
    Reply
  • IndubidablyAli made progress on...

    3d
    Book Lovers

    Book Lovers

    Emily Henry

    11%
    2
    0
    Reply

    IndubidablyAli made progress on...

    3d
    Otto and the Flying Twins

    Otto and the Flying Twins

    Charlotte Haptie

    39%
    1
    0
    Reply

    IndubidablyAli commented on a post

    4d
  • Project Hail Mary
    Thoughts from 4% (page 28)
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    5
    comments 4
    Reply
  • IndubidablyAli wrote a review...

    4d
  • The Spear Cuts Through Water
    IndubidablyAli
    May 31, 2026
    5.0
    Enjoyment: 5.0Quality: 5.0Characters: 5.0Plot: 5.0
    🏳️‍🌈
    🐢
    🌕

    I can honestly say I’ve never read a book quite like this one. Reading this book was such an experience, and one I will highly recommend to anyone who is tired of the same formula for fantasy. Observing the narrative as a performance on the stage, experiencing the innermost thoughts of characters as they present their monologues to the audience… honestly breathtaking. It takes time to understand what the author is portraying but I honestly believe the payoff is worth it. This would be a great book for a tandem read! I really enjoyed the audiobook narration, even if it took me longer to grasp the perspective shifts than if I’d been reading it myself. The characters are interesting, flawed and with reasonable motivation. The book captures the essence of myth and legend, weaving this throughout the tale where you, the reader and audience member, are gathering more understanding through both the events of the performance and your grandparents’ tellings.

    I highly recommend this book for anyone who is a fan of folklore and mythology. Not only is the structure of this book unique, the narrative is deeply compelling, complicated and visceral in so many ways. (We are not going to discuss Luubu okay? Okay.)

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • IndubidablyAli commented on a post

    5d
  • The Spear Cuts Through Water
    Thoughts from 89%
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    3
    comments 2
    Reply
  • Post from the The Spear Cuts Through Water forum

    5d
  • The Spear Cuts Through Water
    Thoughts from 89%
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    3
    comments 2
    Reply
  • IndubidablyAli made progress on...

    6d
    The Spear Cuts Through Water

    The Spear Cuts Through Water

    Simon Jimenez

    77%
    2
    0
    Reply

    IndubidablyAli made progress on...

    1w
    The Spear Cuts Through Water

    The Spear Cuts Through Water

    Simon Jimenez

    73%
    2
    0
    Reply

    IndubidablyAli commented on a post

    1w
  • The Spear Cuts Through Water
    Thoughts from 65%
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    4
    comments 4
    Reply
  • IndubidablyAli made progress on...

    1w
    The Spear Cuts Through Water

    The Spear Cuts Through Water

    Simon Jimenez

    66%
    2
    0
    Reply

    Post from the The Spear Cuts Through Water forum

    1w
  • The Spear Cuts Through Water
    Thoughts from 65%
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    4
    comments 4
    Reply