Tanya4244 commented on a post
“The 2 cops were a study in contrasts. One was a tall but wiry Asian man. He was all sharp angles and hard edges…”
We are starting really strong with a character description that sounds like it comes right out of fan fiction. The topic is so serious so why is some of the writing so corny right now 😭
Tanya4244 started reading...

Razorblade Tears
S.A. Cosby
Tanya4244 commented on a post
I have very strange feelings after reading this book. On the one hand, the sentiment behind the book is quite honourable. On the other, the delivery and the ending spoiled it for me and left me disappointed. As it grew from an essay, it should have been shorter. It's too speculative to be a stand alone book, there's no data to back up the statements the author makes, yet the conclusion the author arrives at is quite revolutionary. Its narrative is too emotional and naïve which hurts the idea, in my opinion, if the goal was to convince readers and inspire chance.
Post from the The Serviceberry: Abundance and Reciprocity in the Natural World forum
I have very strange feelings after reading this book. On the one hand, the sentiment behind the book is quite honourable. On the other, the delivery and the ending spoiled it for me and left me disappointed. As it grew from an essay, it should have been shorter. It's too speculative to be a stand alone book, there's no data to back up the statements the author makes, yet the conclusion the author arrives at is quite revolutionary. Its narrative is too emotional and naïve which hurts the idea, in my opinion, if the goal was to convince readers and inspire chance.
Tanya4244 earned a badge

Winter 2026 Readalong
Read at least 1 book in the Winter 2026 Readalong.
Tanya4244 finished a book

The Serviceberry: Abundance and Reciprocity in the Natural World
Robin Wall Kimmerer
Tanya4244 commented on seema's review of The Serviceberry: Abundance and Reciprocity in the Natural World
The concept of reciprocal gift economy is heartening and this book does a nice job in drawing the reader to really expand their view of the various relationships and associated undercurrents of energy surrounding us, and to consider how we can more consciously invest our time and energy into those paths instead of the capitalist model we exist in. I particularly liked the repeated emphasis on indirect gifting and reciprocity and action that nudged away from the direct/immediate/transactional status quo.
I ended up reading this twice - once on audiobook (really struggled retaining with this, which is absolutely a personal difficulty with audiobooks and not a reflection on the book or narration itself), and then again with an eye read. My biggest qualm is honestly that despite two reads I come away understanding the concept and remembering several anecdotes, but feeling like even as short as it is, it could have been significantly shorter still and deliver the same points. I couldn't really differentiate one chapter from another. I believe this originated as an essay, maybe for me personally and my prior familiarity with the central idea of this book that would have been more suitable.
Tanya4244 made progress on...
Tanya4244 joined a quest
Tiny but Mighty Nonfiction 💡🌎🤏
💎 // 1224 joined
Not Joined

Classics to modern nonfiction, all under 300 pages.
Tanya4244 started reading...

The Serviceberry: Abundance and Reciprocity in the Natural World
Robin Wall Kimmerer
Tanya4244 is interested in reading...

Cold Comfort Farm
Stella Gibbons
Tanya4244 is interested in reading...

Maurice
E.M. Forster
Tanya4244 is interested in reading...

The Well of Loneliness
Radclyffe Hall
Tanya4244 finished a book

Black Cake
Charmaine Wilkerson
Post from the Black Cake forum
Tanya4244 is interested in reading...

Jude the Obscure
Thomas Hardy
Tanya4244 is interested in reading...

House Made of Dawn
N. Scott Momaday