seema commented on seema's update
seema wrote a review...
I have some very mixed feelings about this book. I did learn a lot and found parts of it to be incredibly interesting and compelling, especially on intersectionality, but I also spent most of the book feeling like I didn't understand why I was reading what I was reading (i.e., why the authors were presenting the particular stories they did and in the way they did). I understand that the book originated as a podcast, and while I haven't listened to it, in theory that format makes a lot of sense to me; I can absolutely see how each chapter lends itself perfectly to a single episode focused on one particular queer person and drawing a picture of the relevant world and queer history shifts in- and as a result of- their lifetime. Unfortunately, in book form I felt that the chapters were largely independent and sorely lacking in the necessary throughlines that the introduction and conclusion tried to establish. As I read it felt like the identity of the book was a bit muddled and it was part thesis, part biography, part history book, part opinion piece, and not fully committing to delivering on any. I think the book also could have benefited from a heavier edit in general, because all the time jumps and loops back around within each chapter were a bit hard to follow, and the audiobook had some reread lines left in. Ultimately I do think this could be an especially cool listen for someone with more pre-existing mainstream knowledge on the people and historical periods featured, though I have to recommend the podcast in the hopes that it fares better than the book.
seema finished a book

Bad Gays: A Homosexual History
Huw Lemmey
seema commented on a post
The conclusion of this book is by far the best part, in my opinion. This is not to make a joke, "oh thank you, it's finally over." Sincerely, the author's discussion around the actual intentions surrounding the decision to write this book in this way, and who was discussed. The direct acknowledgment and naming of figures who lent their efforts and at times their lives to the movement of progress in gaining visibility, rights, and respect for the LGBTQ+ community. Most notably, Marsha P Johnson and Sylvia Rivera, two trans women of color who were at the forefront of the Stonewall Riots. Their actions were major catalysts in the Pride movement becoming a protest, standing up against injustices done onto the community proliferated by those in power, the police, in prisons, the healthcare system, and by those whose actions left LGBTQ+ individuals homeless. Their direct actions in the creation of STAR to protect young queer and trans individuals as well as drag performers and survival sex workers, is the spirit this month is all about.
I definitely want to check out the podcast that the book is based on. Not only have I been really getting into podcasts as of late, I'm also curious to check out what other figures they've covered.
seema commented on a post
Post from the Bad Gays: A Homosexual History forum
seema commented on a post
The version I’m listening to on Spotify has loads of pauses and multiple takes of certain lines. Has anyone else found this? Like they didn’t edit it properly?
seema commented on a post
seema commented on a post
seema commented on a post


For those in the US, the giveaway for a paperback copy of Hell Bent is open for the next 2 weeks! Good luck to those entering!
seema commented on seema's review of When We Lost Our Heads
What an ode to girlhood, unpalatability, selfishness, freedom, indecency, and taking up all the space in a room. The girls and women in these pages were by and large deeply unlikeable, hugely flawed, and certainly impressive in their sheer audacity. But damn if I didn't fall in love with them all and find them complex and compelling and even sympathetic. The relationships between them were also absolutely delicious with everyone locked in a twisted mirrored dance, I could honestly spend days talking about them (and sure took pages of notes about them) but for the sake of the review I'll just leave character commentary at this: I'm obsessed.
As far as the more technical aspects, the structure of the book was so fun with quick chapters (with titles!) and snappy simple cadence that just made it extraordinarily readable. Also so much rich imagery, metaphors, and even a dip or two into something approaching magical realism that I adored. The narrative voice I also thought struck such a good balance of scathing critique and deadpan sarcastic comedy. There's a ton of social commentary through this book hitting at class and gender with absolutely zero attempt at subtlety, and that really worked for me. I think in general my most appreciated aspect of this book was how well it layered satire and sincerity, where there was so much terribly and laughably wrong and yet so much keenly right, and all of it on the nose. Several featured characters obviously took inspiration from historical figures, but unfortunately I'm not very well versed in them so I'm sure a lot went over my head, and I do wish there was an authors note or something to get to dig into that more.
Finally, the plot itself was really solid too, for each thing I saw coming there were probably 3 others that had my jaw physically dropping. Especially the last 50 or so pages were exhilarating with tension that had me on the edge of my seat and twists and reveals that were both shocking and yet made complete sense once they happened, and which offered a totally new lens to the story. We end in a very different place we start, but I think I'm okay with that. In general everything was always looping back onto itself - reflections were a huge theme - so I feel like if I reread the book I'd get to find so many more parallels and passages in conversation with each other than I did on this first pass.
Just a really rich and ambitious book; I thoroughly enjoyed it and will almost certainly be returning for another read. "I support women's rights and wrongs" may have feasibly been the mantra and guiding light for this book, and I'd very much recommend it to all others who appreciate that sentiment.
seema commented on seema's update
Post from the A Spindle Splintered (Fractured Fables, #1) forum
Post from the A Spindle Splintered (Fractured Fables, #1) forum
seema commented on seema's update
seema TBR'd a book

The Ex Hex (The Ex Hex, #1)
Erin Sterling