seema commented on seema's update
Post from the Girls Like Girls forum
Post from the Girls Like Girls forum
Post from the Girls Like Girls forum
seema commented on a post
View spoiler
seema commented on seema's update
Post from the Girls Like Girls forum
Okay so the start was a bit bumpy, definitely took a second. I forgot it was going to be YA and had the audacity to be confused when that's exactly what I got, but that bit is a personal problem lol.
The main bumpiness is coming from the fact that the POV/voice is definitely a bit peculiar, and I'm only finally settling into it now. My apologies because I don't have the technical terms to identify it. Best I can describe it is as a stream of consciousness from a highly melodramatic teenage girl. Or like we are reading her diary, maybe, because she's kind of talking to the reader? For example, from the first chapter:
"And one day you learn: it's not that you're not like other girls. It's just that you've never met a girl like you."
Like it's very much giving main character which is a bit cringey, and the issue at hand was that for the first few pages I couldn't really tell if the "feels like it was written by a teenage girl" effect was good intentional writing or if it was unfortunately simply the quality of the writing, unintentionally. Jury is still a bit out as it's still early days, but my mind is adjusting to the flow of it and I'm settling in which makes me sincerely hope it's the former.
Also, now that the plot is going and giving me the first taste of a sapphic crushing I am absolutely kicking my feet and feel my inner teenage babygay girl totally reactivated and every bit as dramatic as Coley becauseeeee
"Her dark eyes—bottomless, endless, fearless eyes—meet mine, and it’s like almost getting hit all over. A cataclysm to the senses. I can’t zoom out. I can’t get perspective. She is the only thing I can see."
Like SORRY that is kind of iconically immediately down bad and I get it and I'm on board LMAO. It's just all so 2000s movie too like I feel nostalgic
seema commented on a post
seema commented on a post


For some reason, when I heard "cozy" I heard "no conflict," even though I think getting over a hurdle is usually an important ingredient in the creation of a book, What would be a better understanding of "Cozy", without big emotions?–by that im picturing no angst, or negativity steeped in pain–or is it a slower pace? or a secret third thing?
And am I right in my thought of no book going without conflict or is there a read escaping my mind?
seema commented on a post


Could we add “An Arcane Study of Stars” by Sydney Shields to this quest?
seema commented on seema's update
seema commented on a post


hi!! i’m currently reading ‘field guide for the formerly villanous’ and it totally fits this quest!! it’d be super cool if it could be added ☺️
seema commented on a post


I'd love to see "A Witch's Guide to Magical Innkeeping" being added to the list, it got me hooked on the whole genre right now ♥