seema commented on leitmotif's update
leitmotif TBR'd a book

The Once and Future Witches
Alix E. Harrow
seema commented on astral.projection's update
astral.projection earned a badge

Spring 2026 Readalong
Read at least 1 book in the Spring 2026 Readalong.
seema commented on bugbird's update
seema commented on a post
seema commented on seema's update
seema started reading...

Project Hail Mary
Andy Weir
seema started reading...

Project Hail Mary
Andy Weir
seema commented on a post
seema commented on a post
seema commented on a post
seema commented on a post
seema commented on a post


I’ve just seen this quest and I was surprised to see such titles as Wolf Hall, The Other Boleyn Girl, and Hamnet, which are Tudor-era novels, not medieval. Perhaps this may be seen as pedantic but I just wanted to point out that they belong to completely different eras and these three in particular belong to the Early Modern Era, which marks the end of medievalism in England.
I don’t know if you can remove books from quests, as I don’t think you can, but I thought I’d say because they’re very much not from that era, if that’s what people are looking for. These would be for fiction belonging to the Tudors or Early Modern specifically.
seema commented on SarahQueen's review of Goddess of the River
View spoiler
seema commented on jordynreads's review of Goddess of the River
I firstly want to acknowledge the incredible amount of work that Patel devoted to the crafting Goddess of the River. Her author's note discusses the level of research and care put towards the creation of this novel, and I found it so valuable to understand this process which was no doubt at times of overwhelming and all encompassing. Condensing a two million word epic into a four hundred page novel is no small feet.
The love Patel has for this story emanates off the pages, and for that alone I felt it was a worthwhile read. Her writing is gorgeous, and while this is a retelling of the Mahabharata from the perspective of Ganga, the mythological eminence is still felt throughout the story, with ethical dilemmas and discussion on morality abound.
Part one was my favourite, I was immediately drawn to Ganga and very invested in her character. However, I was decidedly less interested as the novel wore on and the scale of the retelling swells to include a vast family tree of characters who repeatedly frustrated me to no end. I completely understand this is, in part, the point of the story however I simply grew tired of the continued bouts and didn't enjoy the musings over ethics which felt repetitive.
While the story lost me a little, I do still want to impress the quality of the novel at hand. The origins of this novel were very cool to read into, and I will be looking into more of Patel's work in the future.
seema commented on OhMyDio's review of Goddess of the River
This was pretty enjoyable as far as a listen-while-I-work goes. The men are awful, the writing beautiful, and the Goddess lovely. I agree with others that it does get a bit bogged down with some of the POV choices, and it was a little annoying to have a book titled after a goddess and to then spend so much time in the heads of men. Like, who cares about them?? surely not me.
But I did genuinely have a great time listening to this. I think the audio book is particularly lovely, and the quality of that definitely helped me wade through the middle slog. There's some meat to this book if you want to dig into it - a lot about morality and choices and autonomy. I am not familiar with the original tale this is a retelling of, but I'm glad it's somewhat on my radar now!
seema wrote a review...
I came into this retelling with no pre-existing knowledge of the Mahabharata, and I did enjoy dipping my toe into the waters of this world. With that in mind, it was admittedly quite challenging to orient myself at points, especially from part 2 where there was a significant expansion in characters that even the provided family tree couldn't quite help me with. I found it to be very philosophical text, with thought provoking themes of righteousness and humanity and divinity and power, all of which I did quite enjoy musing on, especially in the final part. That said, I also found it to be very frustrating, with characters I wasn't really rooting for and whose decisions I felt continuously irritated by. Having not read the source material it's hard for me to say whether these points of frustration are actually just being faithful to the original, but either way the truth of the matter is that for my particular circumstance it made it less enjoyable for me to read. I want to feel excited about the journey the main characters take, and here I just wasn't after the first quarter. In the last, I was actually finding myself most moved by a couple side characters given a bigger moment in the spotlight. I really appreciated the content warning and end note provided by the author that give a glimpse into their writing methodology and intentions, but ultimately it just didn't really work for or speak to me.
seema commented on FeralAcademic's update
seema commented on seema's update
seema earned a badge

Spring 2026 Readalong
Read at least 1 book in the Spring 2026 Readalong.
seema commented on seema's update
seema finished a book

Goddess of the River
Vaishnavi Patel
seema finished a book

Goddess of the River
Vaishnavi Patel