karigan commented on a post


Hello everyone!
I am making a new suggestion post because the original is a bit buried and I want to ensure it's easy to find the criteria for what does and does not qualify.
If you have a suggestion for books to add to this quest, please comment them here. Make sure to double check that it has not already been requested on this post. If your suggestion is already here, please upvote the existing comment as I will use the upvotes to gauge interest!
What qualifies a book for this quest? The books in this quest are structured around a game or trial rather than just including games/trials somewhere in the book. The entire narrative is about preparing for the games, the games themselves, and the aftermath of the games.
Examples of books that would not fit despite including a game/trial plot point:
While the games/trials in these books are important to the story, the books are not about the games/trials.
10/28/25 note: I am currently focusing on adding diverse voices, especially BIPOC authors, to balance the quest a bit more.
12/15/25 note: All suggestions from the old post and one-off posts have been added as individual comments here. If yours was missed please create a separate comment on this post.
4/1/26 note: I will be reviewing options between now and June to add a few more to this quest!
7/3/26 note: 6 new books have been added to the quest! I will be looking to add more books towards the end of the year (October-December). This post is getting quite long so I may make a new one with all the existing suggestions but for now, keep adding new suggestions to this post :)
karigan commented on marissa's review of Sweetbitter Song
A love letter to the women who survive, endure, and dare to love anyway. I think there's now a permanent ache in my heart.
karigan commented on karigan's review of A River Enchanted
A River Enchanted feels like coming home to a homemade meal after a long day of running errands. The story is refreshing with a beautiful magic system and immersive world building. Something I enjoyed quite a bit was how practical the romance was while thankfully not being all consuming. I won't be running to the second book right away, but only because I love the way this first book ended.
karigan commented on karigan's update
karigan wrote a review...
A River Enchanted feels like coming home to a homemade meal after a long day of running errands. The story is refreshing with a beautiful magic system and immersive world building. Something I enjoyed quite a bit was how practical the romance was while thankfully not being all consuming. I won't be running to the second book right away, but only because I love the way this first book ended.
karigan commented on karigan's update
karigan finished a book

A River Enchanted
Rebecca Ross
karigan commented on a post
karigan commented on a post
Look how stylish!! (expand post for a pic)

It’s obvi a quick Google search away, but I thought it didn’t hurt to add this to the beginning of the forum because I had never seen or heard this word before (for a hot sec I even thought it was a fictional creature lmao).
I have never seen this bird either, so my mental images were not imaging for the first couple of pages.
Since I have only read the first few pages, I haven’t really gotten a grasp of the hoopoe character, so i’m curious!! Based on the look of this bird, what kind of vibes do u guys think she is radiating?
It’d be fun to see how aligned the character is with how the actual bird is perceived!
I can’t quuuuite put my finger on it, but to me, I think it’s the combo of the eyes and the proud-looking mohawk that’s just giving a slightly defiant "I know better than u" attitude🙂↕️
karigan finished a book

A River Enchanted
Rebecca Ross
Post from the A River Enchanted (Elements of Cadence, #1) forum
karigan commented on karigan's update
karigan commented on Fantasy's update
Fantasy started reading...

She Waits Where Shadows Gather: A Novel
Michelle Tang
karigan commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
Okay friends, this question is inspired by @mimilovesreading’s club 🔗 post about quest forums.
What do you think is the most underrated Pagebound feature and why should we appreciate/use it more?
karigan commented on karigan's review of Ninth House
Never really knew where this was going and still not quite sure I kept up with all the plot points. I don’t think I’d continue with the series if it weren’t for the quest.
karigan commented on karigan's update
karigan is interested in reading...

Incidents Around the House
Josh Malerman
karigan is interested in reading...

Incidents Around the House
Josh Malerman
karigan commented on marissa's update
marissa paused reading...

Palimpsest
Catherynne M. Valente