This book is another instance of a compelling concept losing me with its execution. The things in the synopsis that sounded fun and drew me in aren’t really present in the novel. Notably, the book club element is surprisingly scant. But worse is the complete failure to do any of the women in this story justice.
I think what it comes down to is: this book was written by a man and it shows. (I generally avoid considering an author’s demographics when forming my opinions on their book, but it’s unavoidable here.) Based on the author’s note I do think that Grady Hendrix meant well, but that didn’t translate to the page. This is a story about women, driven by women, in which women are the heroes — and yet their portrayals are stereotypical, lifeless, and generally feckless. They’re also casually racist, even though the biggest hero of this story is the one main Black character. You’d think this book was set in the 50s, but it’s not. If the intent was for this all to come across as satire, it didn’t.
Massive TW for SA. When an author includes SA in their book, they have a responsibility to treat the topic with care. But it just felt gratuitous here. There were multiple instances of SA, including child victims, some of which were pretty graphic. Something about the way he handled this did not sit right with me. (Spoiler: one of the characters literally dies after what is done to her.)
I should have DNFd this. Not only does it not live up to its title, cover, or synopsis…. not only does it lack nuance and care… but it’s also not even a particularly good horror or vampire novel.

The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires
Grady Hendrix


honeydijon commented...
32w
This makes so much sense
I don’t think Grady Hendrix has ever touched a woman in his life


honeydijon commented...
19w

The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires
Grady Hendrix


honeydijon commented...
14w
The SA in this book was sickening to me; I’m genuinely confused by how popular the book is!!
This book is another instance of a compelling concept losing me with its execution. The things in the synopsis that sounded fun and drew me in aren’t really present in the novel. Notably, the book club element is surprisingly scant. But worse is the complete failure to do any of the women in this story justice.
I think what it comes down to is: this book was written by a man and it shows. (I generally avoid considering an author’s demographics when forming my opinions on their book, but it’s unavoidable here.) Based on the author’s note I do think that Grady Hendrix meant well, but that didn’t translate to the page. This is a story about women, driven by women, in which women are the heroes — and yet their portrayals are stereotypical, lifeless, and generally feckless. They’re also casually racist, even though the biggest hero of this story is the one main Black character. You’d think this book was set in the 50s, but it’s not. If the intent was for this all to come across as satire, it didn’t.
Massive TW for SA. When an author includes SA in their book, they have a responsibility to treat the topic with care. But it just felt gratuitous here. There were multiple instances of SA, including child victims, some of which were pretty graphic. Something about the way he handled this did not sit right with me. (Spoiler: one of the characters literally dies after what is done to her.)
I should have DNFd this. Not only does it not live up to its title, cover, or synopsis…. not only does it lack nuance and care… but it’s also not even a particularly good horror or vampire novel.


honeydijon commented...
6w
I’m glad my review spoke to your experience with the book too! The SA was sickening in this one and I kept thinking the whole time “this was written by a man and it shows” 😭 and I hated that I felt that way. But yeah this book was an awful reading experience for me.
This book is another instance of a compelling concept losing me with its execution. The things in the synopsis that sounded fun and drew me in aren’t really present in the novel. Notably, the book club element is surprisingly scant. But worse is the complete failure to do any of the women in this story justice.
I think what it comes down to is: this book was written by a man and it shows. (I generally avoid considering an author’s demographics when forming my opinions on their book, but it’s unavoidable here.) Based on the author’s note I do think that Grady Hendrix meant well, but that didn’t translate to the page. This is a story about women, driven by women, in which women are the heroes — and yet their portrayals are stereotypical, lifeless, and generally feckless. They’re also casually racist, even though the biggest hero of this story is the one main Black character. You’d think this book was set in the 50s, but it’s not. If the intent was for this all to come across as satire, it didn’t.
Massive TW for SA. When an author includes SA in their book, they have a responsibility to treat the topic with care. But it just felt gratuitous here. There were multiple instances of SA, including child victims, some of which were pretty graphic. Something about the way he handled this did not sit right with me. (Spoiler: one of the characters literally dies after what is done to her.)
I should have DNFd this. Not only does it not live up to its title, cover, or synopsis…. not only does it lack nuance and care… but it’s also not even a particularly good horror or vampire novel.


honeydijon commented...
6w
noooo I’m so sorry 😭
This book is another instance of a compelling concept losing me with its execution. The things in the synopsis that sounded fun and drew me in aren’t really present in the novel. Notably, the book club element is surprisingly scant. But worse is the complete failure to do any of the women in this story justice.
I think what it comes down to is: this book was written by a man and it shows. (I generally avoid considering an author’s demographics when forming my opinions on their book, but it’s unavoidable here.) Based on the author’s note I do think that Grady Hendrix meant well, but that didn’t translate to the page. This is a story about women, driven by women, in which women are the heroes — and yet their portrayals are stereotypical, lifeless, and generally feckless. They’re also casually racist, even though the biggest hero of this story is the one main Black character. You’d think this book was set in the 50s, but it’s not. If the intent was for this all to come across as satire, it didn’t.
Massive TW for SA. When an author includes SA in their book, they have a responsibility to treat the topic with care. But it just felt gratuitous here. There were multiple instances of SA, including child victims, some of which were pretty graphic. Something about the way he handled this did not sit right with me. (Spoiler: one of the characters literally dies after what is done to her.)
I should have DNFd this. Not only does it not live up to its title, cover, or synopsis…. not only does it lack nuance and care… but it’s also not even a particularly good horror or vampire novel.


honeydijon commented...
6w
I’m truly so glad to have helped!! I read it so you don’t have to 🫡🫡
This book is another instance of a compelling concept losing me with its execution. The things in the synopsis that sounded fun and drew me in aren’t really present in the novel. Notably, the book club element is surprisingly scant. But worse is the complete failure to do any of the women in this story justice.
I think what it comes down to is: this book was written by a man and it shows. (I generally avoid considering an author’s demographics when forming my opinions on their book, but it’s unavoidable here.) Based on the author’s note I do think that Grady Hendrix meant well, but that didn’t translate to the page. This is a story about women, driven by women, in which women are the heroes — and yet their portrayals are stereotypical, lifeless, and generally feckless. They’re also casually racist, even though the biggest hero of this story is the one main Black character. You’d think this book was set in the 50s, but it’s not. If the intent was for this all to come across as satire, it didn’t.
Massive TW for SA. When an author includes SA in their book, they have a responsibility to treat the topic with care. But it just felt gratuitous here. There were multiple instances of SA, including child victims, some of which were pretty graphic. Something about the way he handled this did not sit right with me. (Spoiler: one of the characters literally dies after what is done to her.)
I should have DNFd this. Not only does it not live up to its title, cover, or synopsis…. not only does it lack nuance and care… but it’s also not even a particularly good horror or vampire novel.


honeydijon commented...
5w
💀💀 you know what… I don’t know that I had even clocked that before but yeah… he really does write so many stories about women and girls. (I thought Riley Sager was a woman too.)
I don’t think that’s a hot take at all; I think anytime an author includes SA it should be handled with care and not be gratuitous. That can look different in each circumstance, of course, and like I think it can theoretically make sense for a character to die or be very sick after SA, but it has to be handled correctly and it felt so so gross to me here. And the scenes with underage girls were sickening. Just something in the way it was written.
This book is another instance of a compelling concept losing me with its execution. The things in the synopsis that sounded fun and drew me in aren’t really present in the novel. Notably, the book club element is surprisingly scant. But worse is the complete failure to do any of the women in this story justice.
I think what it comes down to is: this book was written by a man and it shows. (I generally avoid considering an author’s demographics when forming my opinions on their book, but it’s unavoidable here.) Based on the author’s note I do think that Grady Hendrix meant well, but that didn’t translate to the page. This is a story about women, driven by women, in which women are the heroes — and yet their portrayals are stereotypical, lifeless, and generally feckless. They’re also casually racist, even though the biggest hero of this story is the one main Black character. You’d think this book was set in the 50s, but it’s not. If the intent was for this all to come across as satire, it didn’t.
Massive TW for SA. When an author includes SA in their book, they have a responsibility to treat the topic with care. But it just felt gratuitous here. There were multiple instances of SA, including child victims, some of which were pretty graphic. Something about the way he handled this did not sit right with me. (Spoiler: one of the characters literally dies after what is done to her.)
I should have DNFd this. Not only does it not live up to its title, cover, or synopsis…. not only does it lack nuance and care… but it’s also not even a particularly good horror or vampire novel.


honeydijon commented...
5w


honeydijon commented...
5w
So many revelations 🤯
This book is another instance of a compelling concept losing me with its execution. The things in the synopsis that sounded fun and drew me in aren’t really present in the novel. Notably, the book club element is surprisingly scant. But worse is the complete failure to do any of the women in this story justice.
I think what it comes down to is: this book was written by a man and it shows. (I generally avoid considering an author’s demographics when forming my opinions on their book, but it’s unavoidable here.) Based on the author’s note I do think that Grady Hendrix meant well, but that didn’t translate to the page. This is a story about women, driven by women, in which women are the heroes — and yet their portrayals are stereotypical, lifeless, and generally feckless. They’re also casually racist, even though the biggest hero of this story is the one main Black character. You’d think this book was set in the 50s, but it’s not. If the intent was for this all to come across as satire, it didn’t.
Massive TW for SA. When an author includes SA in their book, they have a responsibility to treat the topic with care. But it just felt gratuitous here. There were multiple instances of SA, including child victims, some of which were pretty graphic. Something about the way he handled this did not sit right with me. (Spoiler: one of the characters literally dies after what is done to her.)
I should have DNFd this. Not only does it not live up to its title, cover, or synopsis…. not only does it lack nuance and care… but it’s also not even a particularly good horror or vampire novel.


honeydijon commented...
4w


honeydijon commented...
1w


honeydijon commented...
1w


honeydijon commented...
4d
Frustrating and disappointing, indeed. Sorry to hear the book failed for you too, but I’m glad my review resonated with you!!
This book is another instance of a compelling concept losing me with its execution. The things in the synopsis that sounded fun and drew me in aren’t really present in the novel. Notably, the book club element is surprisingly scant. But worse is the complete failure to do any of the women in this story justice.
I think what it comes down to is: this book was written by a man and it shows. (I generally avoid considering an author’s demographics when forming my opinions on their book, but it’s unavoidable here.) Based on the author’s note I do think that Grady Hendrix meant well, but that didn’t translate to the page. This is a story about women, driven by women, in which women are the heroes — and yet their portrayals are stereotypical, lifeless, and generally feckless. They’re also casually racist, even though the biggest hero of this story is the one main Black character. You’d think this book was set in the 50s, but it’s not. If the intent was for this all to come across as satire, it didn’t.
Massive TW for SA. When an author includes SA in their book, they have a responsibility to treat the topic with care. But it just felt gratuitous here. There were multiple instances of SA, including child victims, some of which were pretty graphic. Something about the way he handled this did not sit right with me. (Spoiler: one of the characters literally dies after what is done to her.)
I should have DNFd this. Not only does it not live up to its title, cover, or synopsis…. not only does it lack nuance and care… but it’s also not even a particularly good horror or vampire novel.


honeydijon commented...
15h
honeydijon commented...
32w
It has been a little while since I read this book, so my memory is a bit fuzzy. I first off want to say that your connection of every time Patricia’s tingles have happened is so astute!!
I don’t specifically recall the tingles being a supernatural element; they very well could be but generally I remember there being relatively low supernatural content in this book. But I will say if you’re already getting the ick and doubting the author, especially regarding women and consent, I felt the same way about this book and wish I hadn’t finished it personally.