I’m going to find you. No, James Harris you won’t.
BEFORE YOU READ THIS, THIS IS A HATE REVIEW AND ITS WRITTEN LIKE A LETTER BECAUSE THIS WAS THE ONLY WAY I COULD COMPENSATE MY FEELINGS FOR THIS. Enjoy.
Dear The Southern Book Club’s Guide to Slaying Vampires, I hope this letter finds you well. I’m writing on behalf of my sanity.
I’m going to be straightforward: The way you present yourself is misleading. Southern? Yes. Book Club? No. Guide? Where? Vampires? Multiple? Definitely not.
I will try to explain why I’ve come to this conclusion in a bit, I just need to gather my notes because they contain around one very long Notion page and around seven minutes worth of audio material. My pulse is already spiking, and a headache is forming, just thinking about the possibility that I have to encounter you again. I’m also noting that I wrote a lot in German, because I was so angry at this book, so I’m trying to translate every German sentence that might appear here, later on, but just know that German is the perfect language to word your anger.
When I encountered you the first time, I was mislead by the first chapters. I thought the book club would be a central aspect of your personality. On top of that, repeatedly describing the mental load, mostly mothers, have to endure every single day, to create flat characters is not something I can agree on. It didn’t sit right with me, that you had to remind me every second chapter what Patricia had to do as a mother and as a housewife and how bad the patriarchy is, when you were created by a man. Writing flat characters is one thing, but repeatedly describing how hard life is as a mother and that the “book club” is one of the things that empowers Patricia but then destroying it a few hours later with men is another critical aspect. Why were you written by a man when your story is partially about empowering house wives with a “book club” because they have no no way out of their normal life? Grady Hendrix, if you are reading this, please put a stop to describe the detailed mental load a mother has to endure, if you haven’t experienced it first hand. Thanks! Also, Patricia was such a weird FMC and I could write a whole page about her but it wouldn’t make any sense in the end. She never ever, not even once, questioned James Harris suddenly spawning after someone crawled over her roof??? And then this situation never gets mentioned again? This actually happened to a lot of weird situations in this book, but at least this would’ve been an interesting idea for the grand reveal of him being the vampire. On top of that, she is part of a “book club”, reads about the most stereotypical murders, horror and vampire books and nothing clicks in her head that James Harris becoming a part of her life is maybe a weird thing happening.
Talking about repeating, you did that. A lot. I’m trying to sort my review so I don’t repeat myself, because I want to be a better role model, but all of the aspects are woven together so I’m not quite sure if I can manage that. You repeated words, scenarios, names, topics, everything to fill holes you created yourself. There was no need to repeat the “old-fashioned” life in the Southern States or rather how Patricia pieces stuff together to convince us that this is the perfect life, the son’s obsession with Nazis (which, why are you only acknowledging this and aren’t you talking to your kid if this obsession stretches OVER YEARS????, original quote from my notes app: WENN DEIN VERF**KTES KIND JAHRELANG ÜBER NAZIS LIEST, WÜRDE ICH MIR MAL SORGEN MACHEN), Ted Bundy and hospital bed. Especially the “southern life” was something that you kinda tried to sell to me, several times, just with another title. Safe and small neighbourhood? Letting your kids play outside till noon? Leaving the door open the entire time? I get what picture you were trying to paint, but I was so confused when suddenly two boys in a near town turned up dead and Francine went missing and NO ONE KNEW ABOUT THAT? HOW IS THIS POSSIBLE? You are contradicting yourself with this one, especially when you are praising that everyone knows everything in such a small town. Also, please take the following aspect not too serious, because I don’t remember it being 100% correct, but it was a feeling I had and I wanted to include it. You felt a tad too “positive christianity” for my taste. Also the repeated mentioning of the life in the Southern States felt like Grady Hendrix wanted to desperately include it in your story and forgot it halfway through, so he mentioned it again at one of the most random moments.
I have a lot to complain about the “book club”, but they all thematisieren different aspects so I’ll talk about them bit by bit.
Where is the book club? I remember that there was one at the beginning that was dissolved but then fused into a club, that talked about books but didn’t want to call itself a book club. After I got to know you a bit better, I was confused that the book club didn’t have the importance, I wish it had. It suddenly disappeared then reappeared again as a book club. And then BAM: MEN. I got more questions, than you probably have answers, but inviting James Harries and furthermore all the other husbands was a mistake. It didn’t help the story, it didn’t make any sense and it made me more angry than it probably should have. On top of that, the plot of you got finally lost when this happened. At around the seven hour mark, the husbands had the great idea to initiate a stand off, just like Disney bullies do, to reveal the big secret of the book club and to find out, where their wives got those stupid ideas about their wonderful and sudden business partner James Harris. THIS DOESN’T MAKE ANY SENSE, JUST LIKE THE REST OF YOU. This was one of the the scenes that made me so fucking mad, on top of me being angry already, because the husbands becoming “book club” members DOESN’T MAKE ANY SENSE. It was just exhausting listening to this and thinking about these incompetent husbands.
I think timeskips are a good idea, if they make sense. They do not make sense if THEY SKIP IMPORTANT SITUATIONS AND CONVERSATIONS AND DEVELOPMENTS, REGARDING THE MAIN SITUATION AND RELATIONSHIPS. WHAT DO YOU MEAN THREE YEARS LATER? THIS DOESN’T MAKE ANY SENSE IN THIS LONG ASS BORING STORY. THESE THREE YEARS WOULD HAVE BEEN SO FUCKING IMPORTANT FOR THE STORY. You cannot tell me that Patricia and James just went back to their normal lives afterwards and a conversation with her “book club” would have NOT been interesting for the story. This three year skip also circles back to the book club aspect again, because wdym this is a big event now and there are husbands involved? IMPORTANT CONTEXT IS MISSING and on the other side you were filled with so much unnecessary stuff about every weather vane and how the grass looks when it's wet, that a timeskip would’ve been a good choice.
Now I’m going to talk about two of your characters. Carter and James Harris. I don’t have to mention that all of the men, that were mentioned in your chapters, were assholes, misogynistic and were only married because it fitted the patriarchy. Carter made me aggressive. It was so obvious that he is a cheating piece of shit and I have two problems with that. First, the obvious part. Him being away all the time, having no connections whatsoever to his wife and his children and only thinking with a business “brain” made me aware that he is cheating. So the listener knew that Carter cheats, but Patricia doesn’t, so I was annoyed at her for not noticing and being so positive with her thoughts. Second, the cheating aspect. I’m so over it. I don’t like it and I don’t think it was necessary for the story because IT LEAD TO NOTHING. Carter is a manipulative, gaslighting piece of shit and he acted like the world revolved around him. I hate him so much, just like you, and I had way too many questions about his being and why it felt like he planned on drowning his whole families minds in pills. On top of that, he and Patricia didn’t seem like a couple and he didn’t seem like a dad. James Harris. One vampire, not multiple ones, a reference to your misleading title again. (TW: mentioning of the SA scenes in the following sentences) Why did he sexual assault Slick and had Sex with Patricias daughter several times? This didn’t help your story and was very disturbing and unexpected which I see very problematic, because there was no trigger warning whatsoever. Suddenly being confronted with the assault scenes felt like listening to a grandma randomly sharing her most traumatic experiences with you and never talking about it again. Slick dies from the consequences of this assault and I can’t comprehend why this story string was even necessary in the first place. She made one tiny correct decision in her life and suddenly she is the “hero” of Patricias story so she has to die? I’m sure this could’ve handled differently and without an assault mentioning. Furthermore, I don’t like the idea of Patricia’s daughter “offering” her body to James in some weird, twisted way. She is a teenager for fucks sake and it doesn’t even get explained why this was necessary in the end 😭. Additionally, I don’t need the words “moaning” and “whimpering” in the same sentence with the description of the state of a little girls body, LG.
Regarding James Harris and the women. I have two situations which I want to talk about because initially I wanted to do a forums posts, but I really don’t have the energy to do that, so I’ll thematize them here. My review is really durchwachsen (mixed) because I really tried to sort all the aspects but it didn’t work 🥲. The first one is the “book club” ending James Harrisses life. Nothing could’ve prepared me for this underwhelming and annoying ending for your annoying and never ending story. It was worse listening to this, but it was a lot worse listening to James Harris trying to be a commentator at the Olympics aka his own death. The second one is Patricia casually trying to drag a suitcase with a cut up and dead body over a creaky attic. I’m not trying to question her strength as a hardworking mother but please, adrenaline has confines. And one of them is definitely seeing a dead body, deciding to drag it over the attic with no further plan, dragging the body over the attic, hiding under random shit (if the attic is so dusty and everything, I’m sure James Harris would’ve noticed her traces, for example the ones from her shoes, without a vampiric sense) and then enduring James Harris trying to be the next Justin Bieber. I had to laugh so hard on the train while James Harris thought his voice was sultry and the next winner of Voice of (insert country).
I have a lot more aspects, but I think we should put this to rest now (partly because I don’t know how to properly phrase my other aspects in English). I want to make clear, that I advise you from contacting me again. I don’t want to hear from you, or your siblings (other Grady Hendrix’s books) because you were unfortunately enough to make my blood boil and make me contemplain if I shall ever enjoy a vampire novel again. To end this letter, I will share some of my German rants with you, so you realise what you did to me [I don’t think I will translate them (sorry guys) but the rage is better if you just see the German].
With a high pulse and a twitchy eye, I will say bye forever.
Grüße, Flo
P.S.: “Why did […] need more pages than the bible to tell a story?” JA DAS FRAGE ICH MICH AUCH BEI DIESES BUCH; James will einfach eine Domina sein; es ist so langweilig, junge ich checks nicht, es fuckt mich ab, es ist so nervig, nichts geiles passiert, es ergibt null sinn, dinge gehen über mehrere Kapitel, aber da ist kein roter Faden, I don’t check und ich will auch nicht checken.; “This is not me trying to control you, this is me trying to help you” OMG CARTER HALT EINFACH MAL DEINE VERF**KTE FRESSE; Ich finde das Buch einfach scheiße, und dafür dass das so viele Kapitel hat, verstehe ich auch nicht, wie da nichts passieren kann, außer weirde Dinge die auch nicht in den Verlauf passen.
⊹ ࣪ ﹏﹏𓂁﹏⊹ ࣪ ˖
nenlindale commented...
@TomeFoolery asked me the same thing today and I'm so happy to answer the question 🤭. After finishing The Silmarillion I wanted to change something about my profile, because I fell in love with Tolkien's world all over again (and Legolas, even though he wasn't even mentioned 🥲 so more with the elves) and because some of my friends changed something about their profile too. Every time I see one of his works, I'm starstruck that he invented the whole elvish language, so I wanted a username that had something to do with that. I started by writing down German and English words that I connected with me, for example water, music or books and then tried to assemble them so they sounded like one word. At the end I chose nen for water and lindale for music and it sounds so beautiful in my opinion (one translator, translated it to waterfall). Unfortunately, Pagebound didn't allow me to use special characters, so I couldn't use an accent like nèn. Initially, I wanted to use the translation for book, but it means parma and that reminded me of Prosciutto di Parma 😭.