ilowe finished a book

Educated
Tara Westover
ilowe made progress on...
ilowe started reading...

Educated
Tara Westover
ilowe started reading...

The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet (Wayfarers, #1)
Becky Chambers
ilowe finished reading and left a rating...
Post from the Utopia for Realists: How We Can Build the Ideal World forum
Toward the end of the book, he gives a short history of the rise of neoliberalism as the current prevalent world system and also uses an anecdote of doomsday cults. With every belief system, there will come a moment of crisis. The moment that the predicted end of the world doesn't happen, or the moment that the system everybody believes in fails them. There are two responses to this: dig your heels in further, or change your belief system. People will usually only change their belief system if there is another better one for them to look toward. There has to exist an alternative for them to not dig their heels in. So let's assume it's true that a crisis is needed for a majority of people to change their minds enough for the world to change (and he cites a lot of evidence that this is the case, meaning just pure intellectual debate and "the free market of ideas" isn't enough on its own). This very much fits with the traditional Marxist narrative. That capitalism will destroy itself, and all Marxists can do is continue to point out the contradictions in capitalism. Marx and Engels pretty well argued that utopian socialism was silly, refusing to imagine a future or even offer ideas on how a revolution might be achieved, instead insisting that the contradictions and conflict inherent in capitalism would inevitably lead to its downfall and replacement with a socialist system all on its own. So Marxists nowadays mostly also refuse to engage in visions of Utopia. They just complain about capitalism, point out how everything is capitalism's fault, and that's it. To me, it seems obvious that this approach just inevitably leads to the "dig your heels in" result when the crisis comes, because there is no other competing ideology promising anything of value for people to grab onto. In fact, that's what keeps happening. Neoliberalism keeps collapsing on us, but people keep going back to it anyway, insisting there's no other better system. Or even worse, people are starting to slide even farther right, because unfortunately yeah, Trump and others like him are the only people offering to upset a status quo that is obviously failing, even if it's toward more fascism. Fascists are the only people proposing an alternative system. My point is that by not offering an ideology that promises anything, by not offering a utopia or an ideal to work toward, Marxists are contributing to helping people see the problems with neoliberalism now but leaving the door wide open for fascists to fill that power vacuum. So I really appreciate what this book is trying to do. Even if the ideas aren't all perfect. That's so much better than having no ideas at all.
ilowe made progress on...
ilowe created a list
Imagining utopia that isn't just secretly dystopia
"It is easier to imagine the end of the world than to imagine the end of capitalism"
But these books try anyway
Also see: Star Trek (TNG and DS9) but those aren't books
0






ilowe commented on a post
this book is the best thing ive read in my life. if i could live in this book i could. i have no clue how im going to keep living as if i haven't been entirely bamboozled by this book but alas i must try.
ilowe commented on a post
So if I take from the plant I magically can open a chain of positivity, but if I buy the berries at a store suddenly I can't give it to people and do good? Are we for real?
ilowe made progress on...
ilowe TBR'd a book

The Will of the Many (Hierarchy, #1)
James Islington
ilowe TBR'd a book

To Be Taught, If Fortunate
Becky Chambers
ilowe TBR'd a book

Jesus and John Wayne: How White Evangelicals Corrupted a Faith and Fractured a Nation
Kristin Kobes Du Mez