4.08 average · 90 reviews
Click a segment to filter
TL;DR: I understand now why there are sponsored quests to promote books because I have no idea how this would get reads otherwise.
This is a strong contender for the worst book I have ever read.
We could talk about how the book is way too long, has terrible pacing, needed several more drafts, and the smut was so excessive that it entirely ceased to be erotic and was instead just comically redundant. However those are probably the best things about this book!
The prologue starts out promising. There’s some gruesome body horror and a nice mystery and suspense. It gives you hope for the dark romance that this is marketed as. If only the authors could maintain even a tenth of that quality for the rest of the book.
The book very quickly devolves into My Immortal if it were a self insert x Weasley brothers fanfic written by someone whose most advanced reading experience was My Life With The Walter Boys on Wattpad. Now, I have a pretty high bullshit tolerance in books. I’m happy to read plenty of books that many would consider slop or trash and just enjoy it for what it is. But Summer? Now this bitch was testing my patience. She is Not Like Other Girls down to her different eye color and she and her edgelord girlboss bestie are sooooo rebellious and crazy xD getting wasted at parties on tequila that apparently the university sells on campus. Like what?
I have to assume that the university setting was written by someone who has never been to college and probably watched too much Euphoria. In addition to the university selling tequila to students, they also have a social media platform which functions as the supernatural creature school equivalent of Canvas or Blackboard… and also Instagram and Twitter????? And also the students are posting sexually explicit content on there. Bro, be so fucking for real, WHO in their right mind would post their thirst traps on Canvas? Especially when they are being hunted and stalked by a psycho who would kill to find them?
Not only that, but a character posting photos of a naked, restrained conquest on the platform as well as other threats that sounded an awful lot like sexual assault. And we’re supposed to be like omg girlboss she’s so quirky and cool. BRUH.
As for our female lead herself, Summer spends the entire book talking about how every male character she meets is so sexy and hot and ethereal meanwhile every female character is bitchy or fake. She also doesn’t know how to do anything except wallow in self pity and essentially has a meltdown when she can’t have sex for like a few weeks. Girl. Stand up. And then at some point it’s mentioned that she’s 27-28, and you start questioning your sanity, because what the fuck, these bitches are all in their late 20s and 30s and acting like this? Lowkey (highkey) I feel like this was added just to try to make the pretty obviously future romance between Summer and her smexy fossil of a Headmaster a smidge less weird. (Message to the authors: the age gap is not the part making this weird nor the part making this sexy.)
The thing is, the dark romance doesn’t even deliver. The main love interest is a golden retriever boyfriend who she kisses during class because that’s a thing people do. He’s not the toxic obsessive dark romantic interest, he just gets cucked by essentially the Gossip Girl version of the Phantom of the Opera. Girlie is lying in bed post sex with a literal angel and hopping out into the cold as soon as Daddy Long Dick sends her an Instagram DM.
And that’s not even accounting for the pathetic obsession of The Stranger, as they call him, because like, dude. You have a guy who is sooo powerful and omniscient yet he can’t figure out a murder mystery. And also this random chick who grew up entirely outside of magic is teaching him runes??? Bruhhh.
Also, I will not be overlooking the racist undertones of the book just because they made God a black woman.
…will I be reading the next book in the series? Well. Yes. I want the sparkly badge 💀
Only a fool would touch a hot stove again after being burned by it. What does that make me? You got it. A fool.
Sent to my friends at 25%: “to be fair, this book is better than the first one. it’s still bad, mind you. but it’s better than the first one.” Reader, it was all downhill from there.
In the wake of grief, our heroine Summer throws herself into sexual relations with her buff and emotionally unavailable frenemy. Probably any therapist would try to dissuade her from this, but unfortunately, it’s somehow one of the most rational things she’s done in this series.
I’m not going to criticize Summer’s grief, especially at the beginning, too much. There were points when I felt it was unearned, or out of character from the first book, but then again, that’s how grief is. I know it’s made me a completely different person. There’s no reason why Summer would be immune to changes after undergoing such a traumatic experience. Thankfully for me, the changes in her personality make her a marginally more compelling heroine and less of a child, so slay. Or maybe not slay, since that’s kind of the root of the issue.
But that’s the thing: personally, I want deaths in my fiction to carry weight, and while we are feeling that for the first few chapters, she quickly gets a magic bracelet so she can talk to her boyfie and he can continue to get cucked from the other side. I mean, sure, I guess that’s a sort of dark romance. Anyway, I’m not a great fan of being able to interact with lost loved ones in order to move on, I’d rather them learn that from the people and life around them, but whatever, that one’s just a personal preference.
I do think the highlight of this one was when she was taking care of Rafe; there is truth to the idea that taking care of others forces you to take better care of yourself as well. I generally appreciated that the Morningstar family stayed so present in the story.
And then we get to her love interest, and that’s where my actual issues with the book lie. I mean, I have other issues with the setting and writing in general, but I don’t feel like rehashing all of it from my review of the first book. Even if we had any hope that Summer is maturing, the oh-so-mysterious Stranger is back and acting more like an emo teenager than the Daddy Long Dick promised in the first book. Actually, no, he was kind of pathetic in that one too, so I guess this tracks. And don’t get me wrong, I love a pathetic man in my romance, but when it makes sense, not when he’s a 500+ year genius. (Note: I am working on this review while reading the book under the assumption from the first that Headmaster = Stranger, so if it’s not, feel free to clown me afterward.) As Headmaster, he is essentially all-powerful and knowledgable, I don’t exactly buy that he is being totally professional here lmao for pretty obvious reasons, but then as the Stranger he’s a lil freak who never quite follows through on his freakiness as much as you might hope. And then you get his POV which frankly ruins it, because it makes him seem clueless and pathetic rather than a strategic mastermind who is withholding information from Summer. And maybe that’s not his character! Sure! But I think it would be a lot more compeling of a story if it were. I think this about a lot of romance novels, but it would probably be more enjoyable without the ML’s POV as he waxes poetic and simps over the FL. It doesn’t help that she acts like a child around him with her complete lack of introspection and what I’m assuming is supposed to be sexy banter is just a broken record of them both acting like emotionally constipated horny teenagers. Her denial is like, insane. It’s past the point of endearing or funny or sexy. Girl is straight up delulu and making it everyone else’s problem.
Max, for his part, was probably the most likable character in this book to me, but he also is really not doing that much except railing her. Poor guy, the second to get cucked by the Phantom Schlong.
I do think that Summer being essentially torn between 3 men this time around has potential with her ‘inner darkness’ (AKA bratting and manslaughter) but it’s kind of too little too late; the sexually charged push-and-pull chase of her and the Stranger is the kind of tension they should have established in the first book, because at this point it just feels excessively drawn out. It’s like being edged for so long that you give up on the O and start wondering if you should just put on the kettle and watch TV instead. Much like the first book, this book could probably be a lot better if it were half as long and had like 30% of the sex.
And mind you, virtually all of my other issues from the first book remained: their bizarre school website/Instagram/dark web all-in-one, pretty racist undertones in the way they describe the different species, the way the author is so intent on describing characters as “the male” and “the female”, truly excessive smut (look, I enjoy smut as much as the next gal, but Summer is such a horndog that my eyes just glaze over as soon as she says “this is the last time” because I’m so sick of this.
I still can’t shake the feeling that this feels a little too unoriginal. If the first book was giving x Weasley brothers fanfic, this one is giving darklina Hogwarts AU with a dash of “still mad Percy ended up with Annabeth instead of Rachel”.
One more gripe: YOU CAN’T BEHEAD SOMEONE WITH A SAI!!!!! You can stab or bludgeon them. Did the authors even research this? Or did they just think “oooh, cool ~exotic~ weapon for our oh so badass FL to have”. I’d joke and say my culture is not your costume, except in this case, I’m kind of serious about it, actually.
On the upside, this did deliver more on the dark romance, even if it’s ridiculous and completely unhinged. But it sure got a reaction from me! Overall, though, really, rather than a dark romance, I suggest to label this as an “accidental comedy”.
Will I read the next book? Only if they give me a badge for it.
Just the one jar. Not so difficult to imagine. She had always been a small girl. Nothing comes from nothing, and nothing passes away. Matter and energy can never be created nor destroyed, only transfigured and rearranged within closed systems. That's the rule.
No obscure knowledge, just grade-school science textbook stuff. So elementary I still remember all the figures it has led to: When we die, our bodies become the grass, and the antelope eat the grass.
I've spent most of my life loving poetry, and I have a few collections in my bookcase, but Object Permanence is by far the most precious to me.
I've had the privilege of being friends with Nica for several years now and though a lot of the themes touched on in these poems are things we've talked about to some point together, it is a new experience to see it in this form. There is so much resilience in these words, with compassion but also self identity, and I connected strongly with the way she brings the world of medicine and poetry together. The candid ugliness of grief in itself feels healing to read, to sit with and acknowledge. This is a collection that makes me sad, angry, relieved, anything—mostly, though, it's a reminder of the human nature of suffering that we share, and if it is shared, perhaps the weight can become a bit lighter.
A Wizard’s Guide to Defensive Baking
T. Kingfisher
There’s just something very devastating about Mona continuously turning to adults and authority figures genuinely believing they’ll help her and they’re either incompetent or outright want to harm her