legacyforgotten commented on a post
Post from the The Rose Field (The Book of Dust #3) forum
legacyforgotten wrote a review...
Nostalgia glasses on:
Went in knowing this would bum me out bc I already rly disliked SCW 🫤 It rly hurts me to say bc HDM is my favorite series since growing up and even while cringing my way thru this book, I still rly love Pullman's style... but the book of dust trilogy just isn't good 😭
The thing is I think it had a lot of potential for some good socio-political commentary, which is clearly what he was trying to do, but it pulls in just too many directions to be satisfying. I'm really confused why he felt the need to retcon closing the windows??
Idk, look at other reviews for further critique 🥲 I'm going to follow Pullman's advice and use my imagination.... and imagine the sequels don't exist.
legacyforgotten finished a book

The Rose Field (The Book of Dust #3)
Philip Pullman
legacyforgotten commented on a post
Pullman, why are we going into the ethics of a senior professor (11 years older to FMC) possibly being in love with the child he helped care for. No one wants this disgusting dynamic and I hope the book doesn't tread that line any further. ugh.
legacyforgotten started reading...

The Rose Field (The Book of Dust #3)
Philip Pullman
legacyforgotten made progress on...
legacyforgotten commented on legacyforgotten's update
legacyforgotten TBR'd a book

The Rose Field (The Book of Dust #3)
Philip Pullman
legacyforgotten TBR'd a book

The Rose Field (The Book of Dust #3)
Philip Pullman
legacyforgotten wrote a review...
The audiobook was really immersive. Have read The Only Good Indians by the same author and I liked this one more 🙂 Worth the wait on libby lol
legacyforgotten finished a book

The Buffalo Hunter Hunter
Stephen Graham Jones
legacyforgotten commented on legacyforgotten's update