literatedyke commented on fierceandtender's update
fierceandtender is interested in reading...

Why Loiter?: Women And Risk On Mumbai Streets
Shilpa Phadke
literatedyke commented on Lurdo's update
Lurdo is interested in reading...

Why Loiter?: Women And Risk On Mumbai Streets
Shilpa Phadke
literatedyke commented on peryton's update
peryton made progress on...
Post from the Why Loiter?: Women And Risk On Mumbai Streets forum
While I'm past this point in the e-book now, I'm returning to it and wanted to share a quote:
"Mumbai's slum-dwellers, numbering almost seven million, form more than 50 per cent of the city's population. Yet, slum demolition drives are routinely undertaken under the rhetoric of beautification. Hawkers are moved around like pawns on a giant chessboard under the pretext of zoning and cleaning up the streets.
[...] Increasingly, 'citizens' are only those who can afford to buy a range of goods and services from water to electricity to real estate and toilet cleaners (which, of course, suggests the possession of a toilet), and from credit cards and club memberships to luxury cars and LCD television sets. The greater an individual's capacity to consume, the larger 'his' claim to the city. As consumer citizens we are told we have rights: the right to consume good products, the right to legal redress when consumer products are sub-standard. The rhetoric of consumer citizenship has all but drowned out the faint voices that claim citizenship based on inalienable rights to public space in the city. The impulse to exclude the poor is reflected in the spatial geography of the city: in the increasing security that we see, in the high walls of gated communities, in the glass barriers of malls and coffee shops, that repel even as they seductively beckon.
As anthropologist Arjun Appadurai (2000) puts it, 'The rich in these cities seek to gate as much of their lives as possible, travelling from guarded homes to darkened cars to air-conditioned offices, moving always in an envelope of privilege through the heat of public poverty and the dust of dispossession.'" - pgs 26-27
I'm not sure how much / if this has changed in Mumbai since being written in 2011, but if I had to guess, it's still true and has likely worsened. I'm definitely seeing parallels and connections with gentrification (materially and ideologically) here! The presence and guiding force of individualism, consumerism, carcerality especially via surveillance under the guise of safety, car-centric infrastructure, displacement, (and Islamophobia which is mentioned soon after this quote) etc is so pervasive in making public infrastructures more hostile, oppressive, and designed to fit the most privileged and powerful of our societies.
literatedyke unpaused...

Refusing Compulsory Sexuality: A Black Asexual Lens on Our Sex-Obsessed Culture
Sherronda J. Brown
literatedyke commented on aliyahmk's update
literatedyke made progress on...
literatedyke commented on peryton's update
peryton finished a book

Forest Euphoria: The Abounding Queerness of Nature
Patricia Ononiwu Kaishian
literatedyke commented on mrsrumbles's review of A Taste of Power: A Black Woman's Story
View spoiler
literatedyke commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I know there's been other posts here with conversations on the ethics and varying popularity of condoning and/or practicing 'pirating', but I wanted to open another avenue to consider the role (and potential difference?) of archiving.
For context, posts where I provided PDFs for some books got removed here recently; I'm coming from a place of respect and understanding for that decision as the creators of Pagebound could get into legal trouble for encouraging 'illegal activities' such as 'pirating'. I'm not necessarily trying to change that practice on this platform, but widen the conversation on 'book ownership' beyond this platform and destigmatize free access to knowledge.
Additionally, there's much nuance on this topic, but overall, I believe in and practice reading freely. I believe authors should be compensated for their work and that the financial position people may be in to support that or not comes down to systems of oppression that maximize exploitation, prioritize profits, manufacture scarcity, and hoard resources, not the personal responsibility of readers. Many people, including myself, cannot afford to buy books frequently whether they be new or used. Thankfully, I have easy access to a library and thus, Libby, which is my main way of reading books. However, not everyone has access to a library or can get a library card, so they have more limited access to books.
This is where resources like free little libraries and websites such as Internet Archive and Are.na come in. What is the line between 'stealing' books and archiving them? Is archiving for public access what determines something as being viewed as 'pirating' or theft? Does a paywall or other kind of barrier, like a archive with restricted access, imply a more worthy and moral form of theft or not theft at all? Does the archiving have to be done by an institutional 'owner' for it to have ethical legitimacy? Why?
To answer any of this clear-sightedly, the roles of capitalism, white supremacy, colonialism, imperialism, and patriarchy must be considered as the context which inequitably determines people's ability to access knowledge and the moral narratives around people who find ways around standardized, restrictive, and inaccessible carriers of information. I'd love to have a conversation with that in mind!
Post from the Pagebound Club forum
I know there's been other posts here with conversations on the ethics and varying popularity of condoning and/or practicing 'pirating', but I wanted to open another avenue to consider the role (and potential difference?) of archiving.
For context, posts where I provided PDFs for some books got removed here recently; I'm coming from a place of respect and understanding for that decision as the creators of Pagebound could get into legal trouble for encouraging 'illegal activities' such as 'pirating'. I'm not necessarily trying to change that practice on this platform, but widen the conversation on 'book ownership' beyond this platform and destigmatize free access to knowledge.
Additionally, there's much nuance on this topic, but overall, I believe in and practice reading freely. I believe authors should be compensated for their work and that the financial position people may be in to support that or not comes down to systems of oppression that maximize exploitation, prioritize profits, manufacture scarcity, and hoard resources, not the personal responsibility of readers. Many people, including myself, cannot afford to buy books frequently whether they be new or used. Thankfully, I have easy access to a library and thus, Libby, which is my main way of reading books. However, not everyone has access to a library or can get a library card, so they have more limited access to books.
This is where resources like free little libraries and websites such as Internet Archive and Are.na come in. What is the line between 'stealing' books and archiving them? Is archiving for public access what determines something as being viewed as 'pirating' or theft? Does a paywall or other kind of barrier, like a archive with restricted access, imply a more worthy and moral form of theft or not theft at all? Does the archiving have to be done by an institutional 'owner' for it to have ethical legitimacy? Why?
To answer any of this clear-sightedly, the roles of capitalism, white supremacy, colonialism, imperialism, and patriarchy must be considered as the context which inequitably determines people's ability to access knowledge and the moral narratives around people who find ways around standardized, restrictive, and inaccessible carriers of information. I'd love to have a conversation with that in mind!
literatedyke commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I'm very new to PB, so I'm not sure how community readalongs or quests are decided and run, so please forgive if this is out of place! But, August is Women in Translation Month and it would be cool if there was a side/limited time quest or readalong for it!
Even if there isn't and you're wanting to read more WiT, there are tons of good lists online by indie booksellers! Some of my recent favorites and ones I'm looking forward to reading:
literatedyke commented on literatedyke's update
literatedyke commented on a post
Post from the The Gilda Stories forum
literatedyke commented on a post