avatar
Pagebound Royalty Badge

crybabybea

i'm Leah (or bea) :) she/her; 27yo librarian from the US 🩷 nonfiction lover currently exploring fiction! aiming to never stop learning. chronic over-analyzer. big fan of crying 🎇🌻🌞🌊🐋

97325 points

0% overlap
Badges46
Tiny but Mighty Nonfiction
Sourcebooks Summer of Swoon
Best of @SimonBooks Debut Women's Lit
Universe Quest: Octavia Butler's Afro-Futuristic World
The Cozy Crimes of Shady HollowPride 2025
Sapphic Across Genres
Achillean Across Genres
Feminism Without Exception
Critically Acclaimed Memoirs
Justice for All
Indigenous Peoples' Day 2026
My Taste
Mad Sisters of Esi
Ain't I a Woman: Black Women and Feminism
Chain-Gang All-Stars
Alone With You in the Ether
Assata: An Autobiography
Reading...
Plastic, Prism, Void: Part One
13%
Games: A Love Story
41%
Blackshirts and Reds: Rational Fascism and the Overthrow of Communism
44%
Death of the Author
29%

3.52 average  ·  601 reviews

Click a segment to filter

  • Nov 02, 2026
    IT
    ITStephen King
    crybabybea's Book Journey
    4.0
    Enjoyment: 3.5Quality: 4.0Characters: 4.0Plot: 4.0Audiobook: 5.0
    🎈
    🤡
    🕰️

    IT is a wildly ambitious, thematically expansive novel whose artistic weaknesses are so unbelievably frustrating, but ultimately don't erase the magnitude of its achievement. It's a novel whose ambition constantly exceeds its execution, but that ambition is so extraordinary that even its failures become part of an undeniably monumental reading experience.

    My edition of IT came in at a whopping 1174 pages, paired with an audiobook nearly 46 hours long. The novel is a monster in its own right, and my experience with it had me feeling every possible emotion. I was exhilarated, then plagued by boredom; I was crying, then laughing uncomfortably at things I felt like I probably shouldn't be laughing at. I was slow clapping in admiration of Stephen King's mind, then pounding my head against the wall in frustration because of it.

    Honestly, this strange mess of emotions made me want to slap on a 3 star rating and move on. But I have to admit that since finishing IT, I haven't stopped thinking about it. The more distance I gain, the more I recognize how much it accomplishes and how powerfully its different themes reinforce one another.

    While IT is sufficiently horrifying in its plot choices and confrontations with ghouls of all shapes and sizes, its true strength is the sheer scope of thematic meaning King attempts to explore. IT is a story about a supernatural monster terrorizing a quiet town in Maine, but it's also about the loss of childhood innocence, the banality of evil, the relationship between memory and identity, and ultimately, the power of friendship, connection, and solidarity.

    While many books touch on these themes, especially in the horror world, what amazes me about IT's iteration is how interconnected they all are. The characters' choice to return to one another, to reconnect and honor their friendship and the promises they made as children directly ties into the exploration of memory-making and how time, distance, and trauma can cause a rose-colored nostalgia that leaves out suffering and imperfection.

    This reckoning with nostalgia and the loss of innocence then ties in to a broader exploration of systems of oppression and how evil can take the form of neighbors who look away and communities that choose superficial connection over true solidarity. And in turn, the Losers' belief in and love for each other is a radical act of resistance in the face of those very same systems.

    Just like in reality, nothing in this book can be peeled apart. Everything is connected, every action has a consequence, every act of remembrance is a step toward the truth. Ultimately, what shines through is a surprisingly beautiful depiction of trauma and what it means to accept ourselves fully, reconnecting the parts of ourselves that kept us safe and taught us to survive.

    The dual timeline structure makes remembering, truly remembering, an active part of the narrative. More than just uncovering memories that recontextualize events in the past, the two timelines gradually converge in a way that mimics the feeling of uncovering and reconnecting parts of ourselves that have been suppressed or forgotten. By the end of the novel, this feels genuinely explosive, flipping back and forth between our characters' childhood and present selves like superimposed film.

    While reading IT, I spent a lot of time evaluating it according to the qualities that I value the most in my reading experience. Psychological complexity, interiority, restraint, and trust in the reader are all things I consider non-negotiables for anything above a 4 star read, and they are all things I felt IT sometimes failed to deliver on.

    At times, its repetition felt absurd. The characters recovering their memory is a powerful way to restore continuity between their identities, but it also requires us to sit through page after page of characters exploring the same complication from a different angle. You spend hours inside the heads of the Losers (and everyone around them), and despite the enormous amount of time King spends developing them, they can, at times, feel surprisingly shallow.

    The story can feel contrived, and it easily slips into a simple "good vs. evil", liberalized idealization of morality. Its characters are, somehow, complex and also appear as caricatures in many of their worst moments. Even its antagonists are sympathetic and also horribly average. Sometimes I couldn't tell if I cared about the characters because they were well-developed, or because I was forced into a psychologically delusional attachment due to the unfathomable amount of time I spent in their heads.

    Somehow, IT feels heavy-handed, and deliciously subtle all at once. Like Stephen King couldn't trust his readers to understand that its characters were brought up under racist, homophobic, sexist conditions and taught to think a certain way without showing them constantly repeating slurs or thinking in ways that reproduce oppression. But also somehow that he could trust his readers enough to recognize that nothing in this novel means what it seems to mean on the surface, that everything, even the things that make us uncomfortable, has a deeper meaning and a deeper reason.

    The knowledge of that reasoning doesn't necessarily absolve it of its gratuity, but it does make it more compelling to examine. As much as I hated its repetition, it creates something that I don't think could have been achieved with a more restrained approach. Whether every part of its accumulation is necessary is debatable, but its total effect is undeniable.

    The more I sit with it, the more I feel like IT is an experience in a league of its own, and that it's trying to accomplish something narratively different than anything I've read before. The individual psychology of the characters would be underwhelming and disappointing in a different novel, but the collective relationship between the Losers is unforgettable. Its expansiveness, its repetition, its enormous cast of characters, its almost overwhelming catalogue of horrors all contribute to this incredibly immersive, cinematic experience that I've rarely felt before.

    The horror in this novel is everywhere. Its recollection of memory is exhaustive because the past isn't something the characters are able to summarize and move on from. The entire point of IT is to reckon with memory and the complicated nature of nostalgia that depends on selective remembrance and forgetting. As such, it's detailed sometimes to the point of excess.

    But damn it, I can't help it, I love my Losers. Their friendship is so, so deeply moving. Sitting with the magnitude of what they faced together is gut-wrenching, and realizing that they chose each other until the very end is tenderness in its most purest form.

    They are children failed by the system, failed by their families and failed by their communities, who find in one another the care, recognition, and protection that the world around them refuses to provide. Through each horrific experience, they choose each other. When those forgotten memories, through the return of It, come back in full force and threaten the precarious stability they've built for themselves, they choose each other again.

    Their solidarity is a balm against Derry's indifference, against the pain and heartache of facing the things that they would rather keep buried. When the town looks away, they act as witness, and when the town abandons people, they protect each other, and when the town forgets, they make the horrible, beautiful choice to remember, together.

    At this point, I feel like this is the type of book that you're either going to bite the bullet and read, or you're not. Trying to speedrun it in 7 days truly brought me to the edge of despair, but the rush of reading it all at once gave me no time to give in to its lulls. When the story started to feel repetitive almost to the point of feeling mind-numbing, I forced my way through as though I was navigating the tunnels of Derry myself, hoping for an answer to all of my whys at the end.

    I don't know if I can say I arrived at all the answers I wanted, but what I can say is that this book is an experience like no other, and I mean that positively and negatively. I have never felt so much tension in my own opinion of a book. Maybe I've seen The Deadlights myself, because all I'm really left with is just reluctant, hesitant, somewhat traumatized awe at Stephen King's vision.

    8
  • Oct 22, 2026
    Pacifique
    PacifiqueSarah L. Taggart
    crybabybea's Book Journey
    5.0
    Enjoyment: 5.0Quality: 5.0Characters: 5.0Plot: 5.0Audiobook: 5.0
    🧠
    🪞
    🕳️

    What is love, if not a delusion preserved to make life even slightly less unbearable? What is life if not a set of delusions, amorphous feelings and abstract meanings?

    If life is merely a set of delusions, whose delusions get demonized, and whose normalized? Who gets to decide?

    Pacifique is a mindfuck in all of the ways that you least expect. It is a love story within a love story within a love story, and it's also not a love story at all. It relishes in ambiguity, answers questions with more questions, keeps you trapped in your head like a hamster running on a wheel.

    I'm used to love stories using the relationships between people as a framework to explore larger themes like sociocultural norms and existentiality. I have never seen a love story that uses not one, but two significant romantic relationships (and multiple other levels of connection from institutional to familial to platonic) as a way to navigate madness and systems of oppression in this way.

    Through Tia's recollection of Pacifique, Taggart explores the meaning of memory and what it means to be given the right to uncertainty. The love story between Pacifique and Tia is poignant, emotionally intense, and is constantly punctured by the fact that it might not even be real at all.

    In contrast, Tia experiences a real, but shallow love with Andrew, a connection that they both need but that neither is sure will last. As we follow Tia through her journey in and out of the mental hospital, the differences between reality and delusion become more and more blurred.

    Tia is a revolutionary character in that she acts as an unreliable narrator who refuses to be unreliable. Instead of trying to solve a mystery about whether or not Pacifique is real, or whether or not Tia can be trusted, centering her narrative encourages the reader to question why black and white answers matter in the first place.

    Does it change the emotional meaning, to confirm Pacifique's existence? Would knowing she was real erase the harm done by institutional gaslighting and repeated loss of autonomy?

    While being invited to inhabit her mind, it feels like the author is placing a sort of trust in our hands. Unreliability is usually a question about the relationship between the narrator and reality, but when the narrator is mentally ill, that question can get complicated, and even dangerous.

    Taggart challenges us to examine the assumptions we bring to a story with a supposedly unreliable narrator, to contend with the possibility that our desire to establish the truth becomes a desire to overrule her. The experience of reading Pacifique becomes meta in that the reader's complicity is constantly called in to question. We are repeatedly forced to look at the institutions and social conventions that determine people's autonomy and credibility, and in turn forced to contend with our place within those systems.

    By creating this feeling of complicity and existentiality, the book functions as an astute systemic critique that tackles epistemic injustice and the right to one's own interpretive authority. Each interaction between Tia and those around her, from doctors to fellow patients to her mother to Pacifique herself, reminds us of the ways power creeps in to intimacy, to the level of the body.

    Power is always, always in the room. It appears in conversations where Tia can't convince anyone to listen. In memories she is forbidden to defend. In the way she learns to conceal parts of herself. In the relationships that suffer because she no longer knows what she can safely share. And, perhaps most importantly, power is present in us, as we are placed into a position to reproduce the pattern ourselves.

    Each added layer parallels and multiplies and compounds, refusing to keep us on the outside. While Tia grapples with the experience of being questioned and how it teaches her to question herself, the reader enters a parallel plane, wondering whether to trust her, but with the uncomfortable knowledge that the reader is not the person who has to live with the consequences of that scrutiny.

    Tia's refusal to accept the role assigned to her, even when she struggles with internalizing that oppression, is not necessarily a refusal to acknowledge uncertainty. Rather, it is a refusal to allow anyone, including the reader, to take control over her experience, autonomy, and authority.

    Beyond its existentiality and systemic critique, Pacifique is still a love story at its core, and there is a familiar emotional structure here. Tia and Pacifique share an intense connection that functions as both a sense of security and a sense of instability, a connection that is filled with so much love and grief in kind. Like many sapphic love stories, there is a feeling of inevitable, irreversible loss that beats underneath.

    But by including conversations about madness and delusion, Taggart introduces an entirely new level of uncertainty. Not only do we question whether or not Tia and Pacifique can be together, if their love will mean something after it ends, we question whether their love exists within reality at all, and whether that distinction matters in the first place.

    There's an interesting parallel set between the book's treatment of madness and queerness, both acting as avenues through which Tia learns to accept what she experiences internally as opposed to the meaning that gets recognized as legitimate. In some ways, the love story is a metaphor for Tia's acceptance of herself, her queerness and her madness, but at the same time, it never feels reduced to symbolism. Much like Tia's relationship to Pacifique, each meaning exists in tandem, intersecting and connecting and diverging but never fully collapsing into each other.

    Truthfully, I'm mind-blown at how many layers this book has. It is a reckoning with reality itself, how we make sense of memory and meaning and the institutions that function so quietly and yet so loudly in the background. It is a love story that challenges how the concept of a love story can even be defined, a tale of madness and queerness and autonomy and ultimately, love. When you close the book, there is a feeling of not knowing exactly what happened, but being certain that it mattered more than you can ever articulate.

    17
  • Mar 15, 2026
    One Day, Everyone Will Have Always Been Against This
    One Day, Everyone Will Have Always Been Against ThisOmar El Akkad
    crybabybea's Book Journey
    3.0
    Enjoyment: 3.0Quality: 3.5Characters: Plot:
    🇵🇸
    ✊
    🇺🇸

    One Day, Everyone Will Have Always Been Against This is a book of contradictions. Accordingly, I had such opposing, conflicting feelings that have lingered days after finishing.

    At its core, this book is a catharsis. Especially, a catharsis for those just beginning to radicalize and divest from the American political system, its myths and manipulations. Anyone who currently is or recently was wrestling with the rage and grief at realizing the system is irredeemable, that the American lie of "democracy" has always been an illusion.

    There is a lot of value in mirroring this in a collection that has been so widely read and processed, and I have no doubt that this book will begin or deepen the radicalization process for many people.

    El Akkad powerfully shuffles between philosophical political pondering and personal recollection. By vulnerably addressing his own failure to see behind the curtain, even when his profession as a journalist placed him in the middle of the imperial violence, El Akkad shows that the personal is political. In doing so, he also shows that the reality of disillusionment is messy and shameful.

    Coming to terms with the collapse of a dream you believed in for your own survival and comfort is not easy, it does not happen overnight, and the cognitive dissonance often leads people down a worse path.

    The shame of remembering and reckoning with your own complicity is a monster in and of itself, an ongoing project that never seems to have an end. El Akkad shows that it must be faced, even when it is painful and confusing and even when it makes you feel lost and hopeless.

    El Akkad's writing is deeply moving. There are lines that hit you like a punch to the gut, that beg to be highlighted and quoted. There were times I found it a bit contrived, like El Akkad was searching for the most quotable sentences rather than the most transparent language.

    His poeticism makes for a beautifully emotive experience, but at times felt like a performance. Many of its flowery moments feel like the language starts to center itself and the subject starts to recede; readers are prone to think "this is a beautiful sentence" rather than thinking about the people trapped under the rubble.

    The best moments are when the language feels like it's just barely containing the thing it's describing, when you can feel the weight threatening to break the sentence. The mic-drop one-liners and quotable zingers are easier to forget. They become content, a black square to post and move on from.

    This poetic language serves the book's overall purpose of emotional catharsis, but at times feels like it gets in the way of actual reflection and change.

    While the cutting emotion is the strength of One Day, Everyone Will Have Always Been Against This, it also limits its framework. At times, there is a sense that El Akkad is so stuck in the emotion that he cannot see a way out. In his own words, this reckoning with emotion is "the most pathetic, necessary function of this work: witness". Like this quote suggests, the contradiction is that witness is simultaneously necessary and not enough.

    The overarching critique of this book revolves around the oblivious way liberals buy into the American mythos, explaining away their complicity in genocide by using progressive language and useless yard sign activism, which feels powerful and empathetic but only serves the status quo.

    If the critique within this book is that feeling bad is not enough to mobilize change, then it risks becoming exactly what it critiques: a way to feel righteous without being effective.

    There is undeniable power in mirroring the emotions of the disillusioned, in providing catharsis for those who have nowhere for their feelings to go, but the reader is often left in the space this book creates. Angry, grieving, seeing too clearly, but stuck. Perhaps the discomfort of that stuckness is meant to push readers toward change (I hope it does), but it's an indirect strategy that risks reproducing the same problem it names.

    Because of this book's focus on emotion and personal, individual experience, El Akkad often returns to pathologizing broader topics into individual feeling. Repeatedly, El Akkad conflates the idea of resistance with revenge.

    I'm not naive enough to imply that vengeance is not even slightly part of the equation, of course the reality is complex and it would be foolish to expect emotion to not play a role at all. However, reinforcing the idea that resistance is a form of revenge only serves the imperial core, only reinforces the narrative of resistance being barbaric and devoid of rationality.

    This conflation traps liberation in the empire's logic. Resistance becomes a reaction, defined by the thing it's responding to, rather than action. It makes resistance fully about psychology rather than politics. Even worse because he never names resistance for what it is, only relying on the assumption painted by the word "revenge".

    He compares armed resistance and genocidal imperialist violence as "two evils". There is a chapter devoted to tearing apart the word "terror", which again equates resistance as something borne of fear; the empire's terror (violence) creates terror (fear) in its victims. The empire pathologizes that "terror" (fear) as "terrorism", despite the empire being the true "terrorist".

    I understand the purpose of wanting to interrogate language in this way, but it feels flat when El Akkad falls into the same rhetorical traps that ultimately serve the empire's mythos. Here is a direct quote about the actions of Hamas (whom he refers to as a "terror group") during the Al-Aqsa Flood (October 7th): It was a bloodbath, orchestrated by exactly the kind of entity that thrives in the absence of anything resembling a future.

    This quote, and El Akkad's subsequent pathologizing of resistance throughout the whole book, specifically Palestinian resistance, shows a fundamental misunderstanding of the Palestinian cause.

    Anyone who has read anything about Palestine's liberation knows that their lives, despite being under the most gruesome occupation and genocide for 75+ years, are carried on by an astounding thrum of indestructible hope. This hope for a better future is a fundamental tenet of radical thought, something that has carried movements across the globe for centuries, and Palestine is no exception.

    Oppressed people are not fighting for revenge, they are fighting for liberation. Palestinians are fighting for land that is rightfully theirs, for an end to occupation, for the right to live. The very act of their resistance is evidence of their hope for the future. To chalk that up as simple fear and a desire for vengeance collapses all depth of importance.

    This language only serves to dehumanize Palestinians as helpless victims who have no hope for the future, and it reinforces the same individualism that El Akkad seeks to critique. Oppressed people are fighting because they insist on their future. To miss that is to miss everything.

    This subtle return to individualism is present throughout all of El Akkad's writing. Victims of imperial violence are scared and vengeful, politicians are cowardly, citizens of the empire are selfish and unempathetic. This enforces the idea that the system can be saved, that the US has just taken a turn away from democracy, that we just need the "right" politician to stand up and do the right thing.

    Politicians are not failing to act, they are profiting from a system that is functioning exactly as designed. Israel is not an ally that the US is too afraid to oppose, it is a military asset, a projection of power, and a tool for imperial control. Calling political inaction cowardice implies that braver people could fix it, which lets the system off the hook. There are even moments where El Akkad throws in US-backed anti-Chinese propaganda for seemingly no reason.

    Normally, I would not zero in on such minor faults of language, and I would not discredit a book based on a handful of unsavory additions. But, in a book about rhetoric and propaganda and the illusion of neutrality, about how language becomes a way for the state to manufacture consent for its violence, doesn't it make it even more important to be clear about the language used? Doesn't the book lose part of its meaning when it subtly reinforces the same problem it critiques, even if unintentionally? Doesn't it become even more blatant when the author spouts state-funded talking points?

    Again, One Day, Everyone Will Have Always Been Against This is fundamentally a book of contradiction, a half step between radical analysis and liberal catharsis. It is one man's reckoning with his own radicalization and complicity in the imperial core.

    An imperfect, messy, personal experience that can never be expected to be flawless. It is not a perfect book. Its core message is striking, timely, and so, so important. And yet, it does not feel like enough, and its limitations become more and more glaring for those who are further along on the journey of radicalization.

    So, read this book. Feel the feelings. Grieve, rage, nod your head knowingly when El Akkad says the right things, but don't stop there. Turn the rage into action, educate yourself on the reality of Palestinian resistance from Palestinians themselves, revolutionize your thinking and build a community of radical thought and radical care.

    So one day, when everyone claims to have always been against this, when the rage and grief comes back full circle, rather than it being because the system cannot be stopped, perhaps it will be because enough people rose to action, because enough people chose to divest from the systems that profit from genocide and imperialism. That revolution does not start or end with this book. It starts and ends with you.

    35


  • Thoughts from 20% (beginning of chapter 1 [50th anniversary edition]) ~ radical imagination

    But almost always, during the initial stage of the struggle, the oppressed, instead of striving for liberation, tend themselves to be-come oppressors, or “sub-oppressors.” The very structure of their thought has been conditioned by the contradictions of the ­concrete, existential situation by which they were shaped. Their ideal is to be men; but for them, to be men is to be oppressors. This is their model of humanity.

    this is exactly why my personal political journey always circles back around to the idea of radical imagination and radical hope!! it's not only imagining that the world can be a better place in some nebulous way, but imagining ourselves, our humanity, outside of the constructed identities and systems we exist within. if we continue to only imagine ourselves within the systems already built and shaped by dehumanization, then we will never reach liberation, because the dehumanized structure will always remain in place

    we have to recognize our position as oppressed people, and use that recognition to inform our action. identifying and noticing is only the first step, but if we never step outside of defining ourselves by the systems already in place, then we will never be able to imagine a world outside of them. it's not enough to define our existence by our relation to the oppressor, it's the idea that the oppressed cannot fight for true liberation while the oppressor remains their model of humanity

    this is the limit of so much of liberal politics. the goal of liberation is not simply to become "equal" to the oppressor, or to flip the hierarchy so the oppressed become the new oppressor. the goal of liberation is to completely dismantle the existing systems entirely. this idea of becoming "sub-oppressors" reproducing the oppressor/oppressed is so useful to think about and can apply to so many current issues within our current sociopolitical climate

    most obviously, i think about the issue of assimilation and reform and how the oppressed are drawn to the oppressor's way of life because that way of life has become the way we define safety and success. it's very much a liberal political aspiration that becomes obsessed with respectability and proximity to power - this idea that we can somehow "do the hierarchy better" in order to enact change from within the systems that already exist

    it also applies to intersectionality and the way "sub-oppressors" appear within marginalized groups themselves. as the biggest example, i think about Black feminists and how they speak about being separated from Black movements because of patriarchal oppression, while also being separated from feminist movements because of racism. this alone proves why identity cannot be enough to settle political analysis. it is only the beginning that locates someone within structures of power, it doesn't guarantee liberatory consciousness

    AND another obvious connection is the issue of carceral thinking. the way that even leftist groups, radical groups can reproduce harm and the continuation of oppression by not first deconstructing from the logic of carcerality and policing. this is why so many organizations and conversations and relationships can devolve into lateral violence and peer policing ie cancel or callout culture

    all of these issues stem from the same place Freire is pointing out, what happens when we fail to deconstruct from oppressive systems before becoming politically active. even still, it's a constant process, it requires constant noticing and reflection and awareness. reminds me a lot of the phrase: freedom is a constant struggle, as well as Assata's teachings: "The less you think about your oppression, the more your tolerance for it grows. After a while, people just think oppression is the normal state of things. But to become free, you have to be acutely aware of being a slave."

    26
    2
  • Thoughts from 30% (end ch 2)

    oh i fear this book is going to completely change how i view every situation but especially online. Ross gives me such a clear framework for how call-out culture functions and how call outs work and fail in relationships, and now that i have language and a pattern to examine i don't think i'll be able to stop myself from seeing it everywhere

    what's really sticking out to me is the way Ross pulls apart the difference between calling out as a legitimate action and call-out culture as a social environment. harm exists on a scale, and call outs are useful in certain situations, but they are often a last resort - especially when power is unreachable or trust has already been exhausted

    mostly, this is giving me language to understand why so much online discourse feels impossible to resolve. it's the way a real structural grievance gets attached to the wrong target. someone's anger about real systems that deserve that anger gets misplaced into the nearest available person, artist, or platform. people become containers and symbols for systemic injustice. Ross naming this as abstraction is so precise

    and online, the way call-out culture has progressed means that every instance of harm, every mistake, and every interaction is treated at the level of a five-alarm fire, the most extreme act of violence on the scale, and thus met with calling out (aka the most extreme, last resort action)

    it creates an environment where nothing means anything anymore because everything is treated with the same degree of severity. then the real violence and harm gets lost, drowned out by people talking past each other about clumsy comments or minor offenses

    it's not about not being angry or not naming harm, but to be more disciplined with the tools we use. who has power, who can actually change conditions? is this a first resort or a last resort? is the goal accountability, public warning, repair, or is it punishment or emotional release? those questions feel especially relevant online, where outrage can look like action even when it doesn't build much beyond fear, defensiveness, or tribalism

    in a way, under call-out culture, calling out can also become a performance. when it comes from unprocessed emotion, it can become a moral defense, a way to prove to ourselves and others that we are on the "right side" of a situation. as Ross says, "the point of protests becomes not to take a stand but to be seen taking a stand". call-outs are not inherently wrong, but when call-out culture becomes the default environment, the effects are disproportionate and muddied

    so many good quotes from this chapter, but i love especially how Ross points out the surveillance and lateral violence that call-out or cancel culture enables and encourages. it's one thing to call-out those with power (politicians, public figures, high-level executives), but wielding call-outs like a weapon eventually means the violence will come back to those closest to us, preventing transformation and progress

    "When we engage in this behavior, we hamper efforts at healing and accountability, embracing instead the disposability politics of the prison industrial complex: punishing, silencing, segregating, and exiling. If these tactics don’t reduce crime with all the power of the state behind them, why should we expect them to be effective tools for the human rights movement?"

    65
    24
  • thinking about radical love & community care

    something that has been really sticking with me lately when reading works rooted in Black feminism or transformative justice is the concept of radical love, which feeds radical hope, which feeds radical transformation

    one of my favorite bell hooks essays of all time is "Homeplace: A Site of Resistance", in which she talks about how Black women would face the oppression of the outside world, which sought to drain them of all of their energy and will to survive, and how Black women would resist this oppressive attempt at erasure by transforming their homes & communities into places of radical love and nurturance

    "This task of making homeplace was not simply a matter of black women providing service; it was about the construction of a safe place where black people could affirm one another and by so doing heal many of the wounds inflicted by racist domination. We could not learn to love or respect ourselves in the culture of white supremacy, on the outside; it was there on the inside, in that “homeplace,” most often created and kept by black women, that we had the opportunity to grow and develop, to nurture our spirits. This task of making a homeplace, of making home a community of resistance, has been shared by black women globally, especially black women in white supremacist societies."

    i started thinking about how now, in 2026, the ability to make a homeplace has almost no boundary. you can find community in so many ways, especially with the internet. while there are many ways that oppressive systems try to influence us to prevent coalition, i think we still find pockets of "homeplaces" in small but powerful ways

    especially now, when things seem to be so dark, i often feel powerless in the face of oppression, but it's the love and care of my friends, my loved ones, my community that reminds me of the malleable nature of humanity. if individual humans are perpetuating oppression via systems of control, but humans are also capable of holding each other and changing each other in small ways, then it might hold true that those systems can be changed in the same way. with collective action, radical care, and hope for radical transformation

    so i wanted to send a little question to you all. feel free to answer them all, or just one, or share your related thoughts without answering any of them :)

    in what ways have you found your own "homeplace"? have there been any recent moments of community care, of radical love, that have reminded you of the hope of living? have you read anything recently that's reminded you of the importance of community, of having a home to come back to?

    57
    11

  • avatar
    Pagebound Royalty Badge

    crybabybea commented...

    my dream has come true and now i am a proud romance enjoyer happy hamster with sparkly flamingo badge sun