mattcasie commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
This is such a random thought I just had, but I’m curious… for the parents who read books to their children, do you count those books towards your goal? Honestly, if I was a parent, I would. It’s a book regardless of the target audience.
Post from the Pagebound Club forum
This is such a random thought I just had, but I’m curious… for the parents who read books to their children, do you count those books towards your goal? Honestly, if I was a parent, I would. It’s a book regardless of the target audience.
mattcasie commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
With the weekend on the horizon what you planning on reading this weekend? Are you finishing a book? Starting one? Do you need a recommendation for a book?
I'm currently reading two. Divine Rivals by Rebecca Ross, I'm struggling to get into it. Do Admit: The Mitford Sisters and Me by Mimi Pond, it's a brilliant 450 page graphic novel biography.
mattcasie commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I was on tiktok and saw someone stitching a video response of a woman criticising a mm book. But thats not what i want to talk about ( this is the useless contex i add for no reason sometimes😂) what i want to talk about is a comment in the video. The comment was
" i don’t understand why people can’t just say “it wasn’t for me” and move on. I am not here to yuck someone’s yum or criticize someone’s work. We can’t all like the same things, I get that, but I’m no hater." And the creator responded with "Yes!!!! Stop being haters, please🔥"
hate ( or more so criticism) is just as important as the love. its a book not a fanfic. people will criticise it. it will be criticised and analysed. there will be haters talking about how stupid the book is (im not talking about the book in the video here btw. im talking in general) and how the characters are also stupid. we cant all love the same wrork. wich is ultimately why people hate books. And criticize them.
Ofc we're not talking about ridiculous criticism that are not even about the book (like not being able to see yourself in the characters) or cruel criticism.
But what stood out to me is " I am not here to........or criticize someone’s work" because no. I AM here to criticise someones work. Especially when its a PUBLISHED book. I would agree if this was about fanfics but published book? No. Absolutely not. People are allowed to hate books.
Thats part of art. Art will be criticised or loved. And not every criticism will be deep and analytical. Sometimes even "it was boring" is still valid. Because at the end it WAS boring. I read it and it bored me why wouldn't that be valid? You might read it and find it fun amd nkt boring and yours would be valid too. Its subjective. Like, if you dont want your book to be criticised then write a fanfic, an original fanfic. Dont publish it🤷♀️.
I hope i explained this well. What do yall think?
Post from the Broken Country forum
Post from the Broken Country forum
mattcasie started reading...

Broken Country
Clare Leslie Hall
mattcasie commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
Hello everyone!
Recently I’ve been reading a lot of essays, so I have a couple questions!
Thanks guys!
mattcasie commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
mattcasie left a rating...
mattcasie finished a book

No Known Address (Lorimer SideStreets)
Steven Barwin
mattcasie completed their yearly reading goal of 5 books!



mattcasie entered a giveaway...