3.78 average ย ยทย 105 reviews
Click a segment to filter
This was one of the first books I read this year, and now it is July and I don't think I've read another fiction book yet that has moved me so much. So I'll do this in stages.
Firstly, I listened to Jack Lowden narrate this in audiobook form, and I highly recommend the format. Lowden is a beautiful, gentle narrator, which is exactly what this beautiful gentle book needs. It feels like you're being quietly invited to share in something magical, rather than having a story told to you. He's warm, and humorous and pensive by turns and I could have immediately restarted it on completion just to hear him narrate again.
The book itself, in my opinion, is pure magic. The author is primarily a poet and it very much shows. So many of the word choices are just off kilter in either what they are or how they're put together to infuse this whole book with a beautifully eccentric and melodic quality that suits its narrative down to the ground. The fact too that Scots is used throughout grounds it to location perfectly.
I found this book a hopeful one, not quite a happy one. The Father and Ouse are battling with their grief at the loss of The Mother, and grappling with the fact that while they may love each other, they cannot understand each other - The Father, irascible, taciturn and violent, and Ouse, a soft imaginative artist, who sells his art across the water. They have little common ground except Muckle Flugga itself, which they both love to desperation. Their relationship, and the way it is thrown entirely out of balance by the arrival of Firth and his complicated, awestruck, patronising, encompassing love for Ouse, is heartbreaking and stunningly wrought. Ouse himself is such a tricky character - it's easy to think of him, as perhaps The Father and Firth both do, as a passive, uncomplicated and innocent figure, but the way his depth is slowly revealed and given over is masterfully done.
For all that this takes place on a remote lighthouse, there is so much life and movement in this book, and it's hard to get into the details of it without revealing spoilers. It's odd and charming and has permanently carved itself a space in my heart. I finished it and somehow felt more alive and present in the world than I had when it began.
I love this book.
For me, this is not my favourite Michelle Paver. All the qualities that make her books so atmospheric are here in spades, her descriptions of the natural world, and the creatures that inhabit it, are stunning, and it gets so fantastically creepy as the supernatural elements move in. I just couldn't help but feel like this path has been trodden before, and many of the characters felt quite stock to me, even without having to get past the 1970s attitudes of the leads. It was like Michelle Paver writing Michael Crichton, or vice versa. I had a fairly good time, but it's not one I'll particularly revisit.

Which side of the spectrum do you belong to--the 'anybody who reads a lot of spice/smut should atp call it ๐ฝ addiction' or 'We should let people read whatever they want because barely anybody picks up a book these days.'?
Also context, I saw two of these opinions on the same YouTube video, which is why I'm posing these specific questions. As for me, I do not care what people are reading as long as they are reading (I say this because around me, I've noticed such a lack of reading that I just wish somebody picks up a book) because books genuinely provide a lot of political and general knowledge along with empathy. Moreover, whatever you read should not be on a pedestal to judge and scrutinise, like who is one single person to determine how wrong or right another single person is? Unless the book is specifically normalizing SA, I do not care.


nicheinterest commented...
I see you're in the UK - me too. I would look to see if your library is networked to other libraries, which may vastly expand possibilities for you for both physical and ebooks (though there is sometimes a transfer fee for physical books). Mine for instance, is networked to two neighbouring counties and I can access the whole ebook network via Libby just as I can with my own. The librarian will be able to help you on this, so i'd just ask.
There is also the option to subscribe as a non-resident to overseas libraries. The Queens Public Library offers a non-resident card for fifty dollars a year, and has a fantastic ebook library available. Again you can hook it into Libby and have all the library stock available in one place. If you search PB club or google, you may find others offering non-resident cards - these lists can change quite a lot.
If you like audiobooks, places like libro.fm do a subscription model that gives you one credit per month for an audiobook, or if you have an Amazon Music subscription, you can choose one Audiobook per month there also.
Both Kindle and Kobo offer subscription services, so for a monthly fee you get access to a huge swathe of books - I find the Kobo selection suits me better, but it very much depends on what you are looking to read.
If you want to read anything in the public domain, try Standard Ebooks website, which has a lot of books that are really well formatted and all entirely free. Project Gutenberg has a bigger selection, but is a little less beautiful in presentation. Archive.org can be browsed on a desktop or via the Open Library app, which is another option for out of print books.
For free and cheap physical ways to get books - charity shops and second hand bookshops/market stalls are your best friend here. Oxfam books has an online presence. World of Books is an online second hand bookshop which is super reasonably priced most of the time, and Abe Books is basically Amazon marketplace for books, but has a lot of options. I've sound some great deals on rarer books there.
Lastly, I echo the advice to do some research around what you read and try only to spend money on the things you're more confident you'll know you will enjoy. it may take time to build up that knowledge, especially as your tastes change. I know mine fluctuate a lot, so sometimes books I would have loved three years ago, I just couldn't get into now and vice versa.
Hope some of that is helpful!

post has been deleted.


nicheinterest commented...
I mostly use the Discover tab as a mechanism for entirely failing to clear out my TBR.
Every day, I scroll through the Discover tab to find out what's on the featured emoji list, most discussed, most finished and most TBR'd yesterday ... so it got me thinking, how do you use the discover section? Have you been influenced in your reading choices by what's in there? Have you found new books this way? Or are you like me and count how many books are already in your library on those pages to see if you can beat your personal best?
nicheinterest commented...
Honestly neither. People should be allowed to read whatever they want, period. Adults are allowed to read porn just because they enjoy porn. There is entirely too much policing of the "right" things to be reading and tbh it is for the most part, nobody else's business to judge.