I finished the anime and I read somewhere that I should then continue the story by reading Light Novel #5 but I had a suspicion and I checked the reviews and I don’t remember the things mentioned here in #4 appearing in the anime… 🤔 is it not following the anime/manga so closely? Grateful for any advice!

I know a lot of people will say JKR, Colleen Hoover or other very big problematic authors for obvious reasons, but if there're any more niche ones or weird reasons why you can't or refuse to read them, tell me.

Mine would be Mia Ballard bc whether the allegations that she is assisted with A.I are true or false, I saw the counter of how many times the word 'sharp' was in Shy Girl and....I cannot handle that.

What are your bookish recommendations that aren't books? They could be podcasts, films, TV shows or video games about books; certain bookish gadgets/tech, book paraphernalia etc.

I'll go first

Podcast: there's a podcast called Reading Glasses, all about reading and it's very wholesome from what I've listened to

Bookish gadget: I love using a Bluetooth clicker for my e-reader, it means I can snuggle up with my cold hands under the covers and still turn the pages. Kobo released their own clicker last year I think, and lots of people are raving about it 😂

Book deal website: I use a website called Bookbub that can notify you on good ebook deals as often as you'd like. And if you favourite certain authors, it'll email you when a book of theirs is on offer!

At the risk of sounding negative, I really wanna talk about this.

I’ve notice in recent months there’s been huge influx in books being adapted to movies and TV shows (not mention the ever growing quest that is From Bookshelf to TV).

I’ll be honest. There was a time when I used to look forward to favourite books being adapted, mainly being turned into animated series. But it’s really worn me down as of late.

After the disaster that was “Wuthering Heights”, I’m weary of any story that gets adapted. I’ve seen Nolan’s Odyssey trailer, and I’m less than impressed.

I understand that we have interpretations. Afterall, what makes an adaptation or a retelling interesting is what new conversation it brings to the table.

Nolan’s Odyssey looks so glum and sci-fi-y. He’s playing off Viking motifs as if they’re Greek. There’s no colour other than blue or black, the costume, and I could keep going. The counter to these criticisms I’ve seen is that Homer didn’t care about costumes as they weren’t central to the story, so why should we? Which is just not true if you’ve either The Iliad and The Odyssey.

Costumes indicate status. There’s repeated mention of Telemachus’ purple robes, indicating his royal lineage, and despite that he’s treated so badly in his own home. Soooo much detail about Paris putting on his costume to go duel with Menelaus to show what a dandy he is. And Agamemnon’s costume.

I think all’s been said about “Wuthering Heights”, and though I haven’t read it myself, I’m 100% sure whatever Emerald Fennel was doing with her film wasn’t central AT ALL to the book’s themes.

There are some stories that just can’t be adapted (looking at Lolita). And we shouldn’t force it.

I’m not asking for word-for-word, the most faithful adaptation. I’m asking for meaning. I think we all just want the central themes of the stories to be explored in whatever way the director sees fit.

Despite my complaints, I’ll give Nolan’s Odyssey a chance. Maybe he does explore the central themes of how a journey can change us, trauma, loss, grief, homecoming, etc. I was excited for it before the trailer anyway.

I want to hear everybody else’s thoughts in regards to Film and TV adaptations. I liked The Vampire Diaries for the most part (it has major problems still), glad they strayed away from the books. But that show is just so different that I’m not sure it even counts as an adaptation.

I’m not a big film/show watcher for this reason (other than my terrible attention span lol), but if there’s any you liked I’d be interested to try.

Do you guys read super in depth reviews before reading a book or midway? Sometimes i don’t want my personal opinion to be altered too much by heavily detailed reviews so i’ll avoid it. But other times im either loving or hating a book so much i just have to see what other people are saying (spoiler free ofc) What are you guys thoughts? I always read quite a few basic reviews of books so i know im not wasting my money. But im more so asking about the lengthy more in depth ones.

Have you ever picked up a book solely because of its cover? Without actually knowing what it’s about?

For me it was The Poisoner by I.V Ophelia. The cover was so mystical and pretty! I just had to get it lol even if the story was terrible, it’d look cute on my shelf. But it was actually such a good book! The vibes were perfect after wanting something vampy and gothic to read after watching Dracula in theaters! Can’t wait for book 2 now!!

I really want to like this but I’m still having such a hard time getting into it. Maybe it’s because I’m using the audiobook, which isn’t bad, but I feel like my brain has switched recently and audiobooks aren’t really working for me anymore.

So I am currently reading Murder Your Employer The MacMasters Guide to Homocide, and I have to say that I have been liking the feel and the vibes of it so far and I know that I will probably want to read something similar to it and since I've never read much Dark Academia I was hoping I could get some recommendations so I could get into them eventually.

I wouldn't be able to properly explain the kind of book that I would be looking for properly since again I've never really delved into Dark Academia but maybe something like Wednesday? as much as I didn't like the show because of the characters and their characterization I absolutely loved the setting and the vibes and the fantastical and gothic style of it

Its been on my mind what king of reader I am, so started thinking of how to describe it and compare it to others.

So I started thinking of reading personalities as a 3-part combo:

Reader Style + Reader Motivation + Reader Behavior

Pick one from each category and combine them to describe your reading personality.

1️⃣ Reader Style: How you process books

Analytical Reader: You break books down into parts—characters, themes, prose, pacing—and enjoy understanding why something worked or didn’t.

Emotional Reader: Your main connection to books is how they make you feel. If a book hits emotionally, you’ll forgive a lot of flaws.

Immersive Reader: You read to disappear into another world. Atmosphere and worldbuilding matter more than analysis.

Fast Flow Reader: You read primarily for story momentum. Plot and pacing matter more than prose or themes.

Reflective Reader: You love books that make you think about life, philosophy, or meaning.

2️⃣ Reader Motivation: How you choose books

Vibe Reader: You pick books based on tone, atmosphere, or aesthetic.

Mood Reader: You read whatever fits your current mood.

Genre Reader: You stick closely to specific genres you love.

Trope Reader: You actively look for specific tropes or relationship dynamics.

Author Reader: You follow specific authors and read everything they write.

Recommendation Reader: Your TBR mostly comes from friends, reviewers, or the community.

3️⃣ Reader Behavior: How you interact with reading

Curator Reader: You organize reading like a collection or archive (lists, spreadsheets, vibe maps, reading challenges).

Explorer Reader: You actively seek out new genres, formats, and unusual books.

Comforter Reader: You often return to favorite genres or reread beloved books.

Completist Reader: You love finishing series, author backlists, or themed reading goals.

I think I am a Analytical Vibe Curator reader because I tend to pick books based on aesthetic and atmosphere, then over-analyze them afterward and categorize them into elaborate systems.

Welcome back to Wednesday Would You Rather!

Drop your answers in the comments and defend 'em like the main character in a courtroom drama 😌

1. 🏰 Read only classic literature for a year OR 📱 Read only books published this year?

2. 🌧️ Read a beautifully written book where nothing happens OR 💥 Read a messy book with an unforgettable plot?

3. 📚 Have unlimited shelf space OR 💳 Have unlimited book-buying money?

4. 🕯️ Read by a cozy fireplace during a snowstorm OR 🌊 Read on a quiet beach at sunset?

5. ✍️ Meet your favorite author OR 📖 Read their next unreleased book early?

6. 🔎 Figure out the plot twist halfway through OR 😮 Be completely shocked at the end?

7. 🧳 Take one beloved book on every trip OR 📚 Always buy a new book wherever you travel?

8. ⏰ Only read in short 10-minute bursts OR 📖 Only read in long 3-hour sessions?

9. 🗺️ Explore a massive fantasy world with maps and lore OR 🏙️ Read a deeply realistic story set in the real world?

10. 🏆 Finish every book you start OR 🚪 DNF any book the moment it loses you?