EDIT: Thank you for all the great suggestions in the comments (if you have more please share)! I will be trying lots of new things moving forward, though I do still believe a post limit based on reading progression and/or having a total post cap per book with no time restriction would allow for more balance between fast and slower readers 😊

Now before anyone comes for me, I 100% agree with there being a limit to posts, and the 5 post limit isn’t really the issue; people should be thinking about what they want to share in a forum and a limit is good for that. However, as someone who often reads an entire book within 24 hours, being limited to only 5 forum posts for the whole books is a bummer, especially since someone reading the same book over a longer period will be provided a chance to post 10+ times. I held off marking one of my books as read so that I could post the few comments I wanted to after midnight, and when that didn’t work later that next day (which also didn’t work), but I feel like I’m being punished for being a fast reader (and I’m a little confused at when/how the 24 hour limit resets). It wouldn’t even let me post something new after deleting an older post, since if I figured if I had to choose between the two, the most recent post was more “worth it”.

I still think there should be a limit, but maybe it needs to be based on book percentage rather than time? Perhaps you get a certain number of posts for every 10 - 20% of a book?? I dunno, I just feel that there is a slight imbalance for those who read faster. Anyone else run into this issue or am I the crazy one? 🤪

I'm liking it, even though I'm a bit tired of the friends to lovers trope in the sense that it makes it seem as if girls and boys can't be friends. I'm not a big fan of romance so this might be my first and last book of hers

I'm personally a big proponent for publication order on this series. The other obvious option is chronological, but I really think one should start with this book (Redwall), before going back and tackling the history.

I do think there's several books in the same "era" so to speak that could be done together. So could do all the ones with Matthias, then go back and do all the Martin ones, then do Salmandastron-based ones, etc.

Anyone else have thoughts on reading order options?

hi everyone! i was surprised to see that rarest badge earned was a stat in wrapped- and i love it! mine was the sparkly badge for the Winter 2026 Readalong which i was surprised to see only 63 others on PB have earned 🥹🥹 i'm curious about what other's rarest badges were, since not everyone has shared their wrapped. were you surprised about the number of people with the badge too?