robotrabbit commented on robotrabbit's update
robotrabbit commented on a post


Hi all my lovely supporters of women's wrongs! It seems we've tempted fate with this quest; we are now in the position of evaluating a real life woman's alleged wrongs.
There's been some chatter in this quest forum already about Mia Ballard, author of Sugar (in this quest) and Shy Girl. Here's a quick and very simplified primer for those unaware:
Ballard is a Black poet and indie author. She debuted with Sugar in 2024 to great success, and followed up in 2025 with Shy Girl which earned her a book deal with publisher Hachette. [Editing to add for clarity: Shy Girl was also indie published and very successful; after Shy Girl's success, Hachette made a deal with Ballard to traditionally publish.] A few months ago, the online book space became suspicious of Ballard's writing in Shy Girl specifically and called out many "tells" of AI writing. Booktuber Frankie's shelf outlined their suspicions in a 2hr 40min YouTube video, calling Shy Girl "AI slop". In March 2026, Hachette dropped Ballard and pulled Shy Girl from publication (link to the NYT article here ).
This has stirred much discourse. On one side, people see this as a win for human created art and a vote for keeping AI out of the book space (which we love). On the other side, people warn of ruining authors' careers over AI allegations when AI detection is so flawed. Ballard maintains that she did not write Shy Girl using AI, however she did hire an editor who used AI without her knowledge. There is also the added element of Ballard being a Black debut indie author, and also the first to have a book deal canceled over AI. Some argue the injustice of Ballard taking the fall for this when Hachette is just as responsible for the editing of the work they ultimately published.
Amidst all this discourse, I want to ask you all: how do we feel about Sugar's inclusion in this quest? As someone passionate about keeping AI out of the arts (and the book space in particular), I feel conflicted about having Ballard represented in this list. On the one hand, having a "better safe than sorry" stance against AI in books is reasonable, and I would not want to advocate for the consumption of AI generated novels. On the other hand, Sugar was not accused of being AI generated (there is some suspicion about the cover art, but it's pure speculation--Ballard is adamant she modified it herself off a free image she found online). It is also a sort of poetic irony that this discussion is happening in a quest titled Supporting Women's Wrongs. There's something to be said about the discussion value of including morally grey women.
I'm very curious to hear what you all think, and what you believe should be done about Sugar. Do we keep it in, or do we remove it?
robotrabbit created a list
the first selfie was a hand on the cave wall
prehistorical humans & their companions, all the history between them and you now reaching back
0






robotrabbit is interested in reading...

Radical Animism: Reading for the End of the World
Jemma Deer
robotrabbit is interested in reading...

Art History and Class Struggle
Nicos Hadjinicolaou
robotrabbit is interested in reading...

Bloodied Bodies, Bloody Landscapes: Settler Colonialism in Horror (Indigenous Voices in World Arts and Cultural Expressions)
Laura Hall
robotrabbit commented on peryton's update
peryton TBR'd a book

The Flowering Wand: Rewilding the Sacred Masculine
Sophie Strand
robotrabbit is interested in reading...

Bento's Sketchbook
John Berger
robotrabbit is interested in reading...

Becoming Human: Matter and Meaning in an Antiblack World (Sexual Cultures, 53)
Zakiyyah Iman Jackson
robotrabbit commented on robotrabbit's update
robotrabbit started reading...

L.A. Rebellion: Creating a New Black Cinema
Allyson Field
robotrabbit started reading...

L.A. Rebellion: Creating a New Black Cinema
Allyson Field
robotrabbit finished a book

Madness, Rack, and Honey: Collected Lectures
Mary Ruefle
robotrabbit commented on robotrabbit's update
robotrabbit made progress on...
robotrabbit made progress on...
robotrabbit commented on robotrabbit's update
robotrabbit made progress on...
robotrabbit commented on electrikate's review of Wicked Dreams: Fairytales With A Twist
DNF @ 35%

Let’s be honest. I was reading this because I saw the TW for somnophilia and thought, eh, sleeping beauty retelling? Up my kink-alley. This wasn’t sleeping beauty at all. This was girl gets “kidnapped” for her dads shitty behavior years earlier. One of her 4 abductors is a doctor and uses a combo of propofol and ketamine, along with scopolamine patches. Now, I’m not a medical professional… (i am) There were a lot of questionable medical decisions.
The first 35% has been majority sex scenes. One after the other. With somnophilia related content, I am looking for it to read a certain way. What’s the point otherwise? I want sneaking and confusion and obsessive watching and creeping and… tiptoeing around. I want internal dialogue about what’s going on. Something. They load her up with meds to knock her out and go to pound town. There’s not the finesse I’m personally looking for- like this was decent enough for the 89pgs I read, but I can’t see myself dedicating my brainpower for 260pgs.
robotrabbit made progress on...
robotrabbit is interested in reading...

The Creative Act: A Way of Being
Rick Rubin
robotrabbit TBR'd a book

Meander, Spiral, Explode: Design and Pattern in Narrative
Jane Alison