Originally reviewed 13 September 2017 on Goodreads
CW: Brief discussion of rape
Review summary: This book is an excellent study in three things: third-person perspective, writing youth and youthful POV, and successful installation of supernatural elements in a realistic, but fictional, world. Grady Hendrix has written one of the best young female friendships I've ever read.
"Gretchen put a hand on either side of Abby's face and pulled them together until their foreheads were touching.... 'I need you to tell me everything,' Gretchen said. 'Because you're the only person I can hear it from without going insane. I need to know it all.'"
So often with books whose premise is “something bad/unexpected happens to close friend of protag, leaving protag to deal with the aftereffects of and their own emotions about Bad Thing,” the Unfortunate Friend only serves as a vehicle for the Bad Thing to happen to or the protagonist to have feelings about. The author wants to get to the main action so as not to lose our attention, but what they have failed to do is give us any reason to care about the friendship itself. “My best friend is really great and important to me, so it’s pretty bad that she was possessed by a demon—just trust me.” Grady Hendrix has not done that here. Clearly a writer who trusts his own skill, he does not shy away from back story. He spends the first third of the book just developing our understanding of Abby’s and Gretchen’s friendship. It becomes clear very quickly that this isn’t just an amazing best-friend relationship; it’s a necessity for both of them, born out of the mutual, desperate need to be seen for who they truly are, and to be accepted for it. It’s a tool to navigate their very different but equally unideal home lives: Abby comes from economic hardship and wants to be known as anything other than the Scholarship Kid, while Gretchen endures physical and emotional abuse from her parents and an intense pressure to uphold the family image among Charleston’s elite. So when they reach age sixteen and Gretchen becomes possessed by a demonic entity, we feel very acutely Abby’s desperation to get her friend back. It’s not just about the loss of a good friend; for her, it’s survival in shark-infested waters.
THIS SECTION CONTAINS SPOILERS
Brother Lemon enveloped her wrist in an enormous hand and pressed it to the table, lightly but firmly. ‘…I’ve seen who’s inside of your friend, and I’m scared for you. This demon wants to isolate you. It wants to drive everyone else away. Then, when the time comes, it’ll make the demoniac win herself out and take you with it. You won’t have anyone left to help you when that hour is upon thee.’”
If you’re looking for a book that terrifies with impossible and unexplainable events, this isn’t it. The events that occur in My Best Friend’s Exorcism are very explainable, which is what makes the whole thing so insidious. || Gretchen’s possession coincides with an acid-fueled weekend, which leads both Abby and Gretchen to believe that her sudden and severe physical discomfort immediately following is merely a symptom of a bad trip. Then Gretchen stops sleeping, eating, washing or changing her clothes. She starts to talk about keeping “him” out, which leads Abby to believe that Gretchen was, in fact, raped that night in the woods. || And while the reader understands that this is not the case based on the premise of the book, they are still able to understand through Abby’s misunderstanding just how deeply violating a demonic possession would feel. Like rape and our societal understandings of rape, it is the non-consensual habitation of a body by another entity, the experience lingers with you long after it happens, and it is hard to tell other people what has happened to you for fear of being labeled as crazy or a liar. || Abby reminds us of these real-life consequences when she tries to bring her concern to Gretchen’s parents, who call her a liar and accuse her of giving Gretchen drugs and therefore causing her grave illness. They ban her from ever seeing Gretchen again and even go so far as to switch Gretchen out of classes they share together, which begins Abby’s slow social ostracization at school. In one masterful stroke, Hendrix makes us understand the depths to which Gretchen must be struggling, as well as feel Abby’s pain, desperation, and sense of betrayal at having her biggest lifeline wrenched from her grasp. ||
In fact, throughout the book we see very little supernatural phenomena, at least not the kind we would expect. There is very little eyes rolling back in the head, sudden levitation, or speaking in tongues. The most devastating events are tied to real-life evils: || ingestion of tapeworms as a method of weight loss, infidelity, juvenile arrest, wrongful imprisonment, sexual assault, inappropriate student-teacher relationships. || All of these factors were already present pre-existing; they just need the right kind of manipulation to cause an entire domino effect, and who better to do that but a higher demon of hell? The demon doesn’t need to instill fear through unnatural bodily contortions or otherworldly occurrences. He has all the tools he needs in the form of human evils, and in recognizing those tools he barely has to lift a finger to wreak unimaginable havoc.
END OF SPOILERS
“'The devil is loud and brash and full of drama. God, he’s like a sparrow.'”
I started this book wanting to read something bone-chillingly scary. This book is scary, but not in the ways I was expecting or hoping. I was disappointed when one-hundred and fifty pages had passed and I still hadn’t felt my skin crawl, but honestly, Hendrix has isolated the one way to really send demonic possession home for his readers: by linking it to the heavy real-life consequences and upheaval that such a possession would cause in our world. And I’m not talking about some kind of clumsy turning of the stereotype on its head for the sake of it—“The real demon was drugs/abuse/social ostracization all along!” I'm talking about actually taking those possibilities to their very real conclusions. Long ago people used to think that addiction and mental illness were simply demons possessing your body, but what if it was the other way around? What kind of damage, both immediate and lasting, is wrought by that misdiagnosis? My Best Friend’s Exorcism will tell you.
succulent_club commented...
I recently started using this matrix for star ratings:
Here's the post where the creator talks about it a little more.
It’s really simple, yet still captures nuance. I find it helps me to avoid rating inflation when giving my own ratings. If most things are at least 3 stars regardless of their quality, then ratings lose much of their meaning, imo.
l think it also (somewhat) standardizes my ratings, as much as something so subjective can be standardized.
The matrix is often a starting-point for me. I’ll sometimes tweak my ratings with partial-stars if I feel that the matrix result didn’t quite capture how I feel about the book. Similar to @MasquerainDreamer25, half stars are usually for when I'm leaning towards one side or the other but just can't bring myself to make it that.