avatar
Pagebound Royalty Badge

succulent_club

30s | she/her/ella | linguistics enthusiast, friend to street dogs & spikey plants. i love footnotes, annotations, and marginalia. spontaneously having a very jane austen fall.

3510 points

0% overlap
Badges14
Level 6Indigenous Peoples' Day 2026
Fall 2026 Readalong
Gothic Literature
Classic Literature from the United States
British & Irish Classic Literature
My Taste
The Annotated Pride and Prejudice
My Best Friend's Exorcism
The Likeness
Factfulness: Ten Reasons We're Wrong About the World – and Why Things Are Better Than You Think
Americanah
Reading...
Black Sun
49%
The Bloody Chamber and Other Stories
18%
Change the Wallpaper: Transforming Cultural Patterns to Build More Just Communities
34%

4.00 average  ·  177 reviews

Click a segment to filter

  • Aug 08, 2026
    My Best Friend's Exorcism
    My Best Friend's ExorcismGrady Hendrix
    succulent_club's Book Journey
    5.0
    Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:
    0


  • Reaction from 53% | Lizzy’s reaction to Darcy’s letter

    On this reread I’m experiencing such schadenfreude at Lizzy’s mortification

    Leslie Knope smiling triumphantly in front of a powerpoint slide which says “You Blew It. Super Hard. Complete Buffoonery.”

    68
    8

  • avatar
    Pagebound Royalty Badge

    succulent_club commented...

    I recently started using this matrix for star ratings: A three by three table (excluding row and column headings). The columns are labelled: Nothing really wrong with it A few things wrong with it So many things wrong with it The rows are labelled: Lots of awesome things A few awesome things Nothing really awesome The cells inside the table are labelled as follows: Lots of awesome things/nothing really wrong with it: 5 stars Lots of awesome things/a few things wrong with it: 4 stars (spicy) Lots of awesome things/so many things wrong with it: 3 stars (spicy) A few awesome things/nothing really wrong with it: 4 stars (bland) A few awesome things/a few things wrong with it: 3 stars (mild) A few awesome things/so many things wrong with it: 2 stars (spicy) Nothing really awesome/nothing really wrong with it: 3 stars (bland) Nothing really awesome/a few things wrong with it: 2 stars (bland) Nothing really awesome/so many things wrong with it: 1 star. Credit to tumblr user aromanticduck. Here's the post where the creator talks about it a little more.

    It’s really simple, yet still captures nuance. I find it helps me to avoid rating inflation when giving my own ratings. If most things are at least 3 stars regardless of their quality, then ratings lose much of their meaning, imo.

    l think it also (somewhat) standardizes my ratings, as much as something so subjective can be standardized.

    The matrix is often a starting-point for me. I’ll sometimes tweak my ratings with partial-stars if I feel that the matrix result didn’t quite capture how I feel about the book. Similar to @MasquerainDreamer25, half stars are usually for when I'm leaning towards one side or the other but just can't bring myself to make it that.

  • star ratings systems?

    i'm sure something to this effect has been posted here before but i thought i'd ask anyway! how does your star rating system work? i haven't left star ratings in a while because i can never stay consistent with them, but i think if i could just figure out a concrete system, i might have more success with them.

    15
    28