avatar

Carthage

Been through the early 2010's Wattpad era. I'd love book reccs about *actual* strong female characters. Would looooooove to make friends! (I'm a soon-to-be published writer)

180 points

0% overlap
Level 2
My Taste
Vicious by V. E. Schwab (2014-05-06)
The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue
Pandora's Jar: Women in the Greek Myths
One Dark Window
Emily Wilde's Encyclopaedia of Faeries
Reading...
Gideon the Ninth
0%
Emily Wilde’s Map of the Otherlands
0%

Carthage commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

1d
  • Help me read poetry please

    Hi! I'm new to reading poetry and I need help. I've always had an aversion to it because I was made to believe (when I was impressionable) that it's difficult, pretentious, and without real benefit. This is obviously BS. I'm now looking to read one book of poetry a month.

    I'd like to start small and easy-ish as to not stunt and demotivate myself. So, if you have any recommendations, that would be so helpful!

    PS: I'm kinda skittish when it comes to big names (I know, it's all in my head but I really don't want to take any chances that could dim my spark by unearthing previous doubts and fears—I want to kill them with new poetry.)

    Thank you for your understanding and your help!

    25
    comments 29
    Reply
  • Carthage commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    1d
  • Kitten Names!!

    I just signed up to be a bottle foster for a local rescue org, which means I might be responsible for naming litters of kittens soon, a task which I do NOT take lightly lmao so what I want to know is, which book's cast of characters would you name a litter of kittens after?

    I just finished Six of Crows so the first crew that came to mind for me was Kaz, Inej, Nina, Matthius, Jesper, and Wylan, all of which would make truly excellent kitten names imo 🧐 What about you?? (do not say HP, it's overdone and also ..... just no lol)

    76
    comments 137
    Reply
  • Post from the Pagebound Club forum

    1d
  • Help me read poetry please

    Hi! I'm new to reading poetry and I need help. I've always had an aversion to it because I was made to believe (when I was impressionable) that it's difficult, pretentious, and without real benefit. This is obviously BS. I'm now looking to read one book of poetry a month.

    I'd like to start small and easy-ish as to not stunt and demotivate myself. So, if you have any recommendations, that would be so helpful!

    PS: I'm kinda skittish when it comes to big names (I know, it's all in my head but I really don't want to take any chances that could dim my spark by unearthing previous doubts and fears—I want to kill them with new poetry.)

    Thank you for your understanding and your help!

    25
    comments 29
    Reply
  • Carthage DNF'd a book

    2w
    Beg, Borrow, or Steal

    Beg, Borrow, or Steal

    Sarah Adams

    0
    0
    Reply

    Carthage left a rating...

    3w
  • Praise
    Carthage
    Jul 26, 2026
    Praise
    5.0
    Enjoyment: 5.0Quality: 5.0Characters: 5.0Plot: 5.0

    The only D/S dynamic that made sense. Everything flows perfectly. The transition makes sense. The feelings and doubts and hesitations and impulsivity make sense.

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • Carthage left a rating...

    7w
  • A Study in Drowning
    Carthage
    Jun 29, 2026
    A Study in Drowning
    5.0
    Enjoyment: 5.0Quality: 5.0Characters: 5.0Plot: 5.0
    📚
    👓
    🌊
    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • Carthage is interested in reading...

    8w
    Beg, Borrow, or Steal

    Beg, Borrow, or Steal

    Sarah Adams

    0
    0
    Reply

    Carthage commented on airareadsbooks's review of Collide

    8w
  • Collide
    airareadsbooks
    Jan 05, 2026
    Collide
    1.0
    Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:

    ˏˋ°•*⁀➷ 0.5/5

    sighs why do I even try?

    Hopefully, I won't hit the character count with how much I need to yap about all of this. I think this is my longest review till date and my fingers are about to fall off because of how much I typed.

    Also, where should I even start? I have so much I need to say, but I guess I'll talk about the characters first and then talk about the plot.

    First up, we have our "beloved" mmc.

    Aiden Crawford. He's your basic college "fuckboy" hockey captain.

    I would like to start this off by saying that I have some leftover ptsd from a male character with the name Aiden iykyk, so we definitely didn't have the best start and then it went downhill.

    Anyways, his pov opens up with him in bed with another woman because of course that's how you get the ladies to fall over their tits for you. In my very honest opinion, whoever first introduced the idea of a hoe for a male lead needs to come and justify why that was a good idea because why is it so mainstream right now? Every other book, especially hockey romance has a hoe for a male lead.

    I mean, no hate to you if you want to be a hoe, but like seriously? And why are all these women so interested in them. Are they not scared of contracting anything from him? The way they all take his word for it when he's like "I'm clean"? I would be repulsed if a guy like Aiden was in my vicinity. You would not catch me being attracted to someone like that.

    If you are trying to convince me to like a male lead, 9 times out of 10 having a woman in bed with him when his chapter opens up is not going to impress me. I say 9 times out of 10 only because it didn't bother me the first couple of times since I thought it was a one-off. However, I'm tired of that dynamic and characterization where the male lead fucks everything and anything until he meets his female lead and suddenly becomes obsessed with the blandest female. I am absolutely abhorrently disgusted with men like that.

    Also, it kind of gives off the wrong image. Like, I mean of course we're supposed to be separating fiction from reality, but there are people out there that might still get influenced by this. Imagine trying to fix a fuckboy in real life because you saw the female lead do it in your favorite book? I really hope people don't actually try that, but you can never be so sure. Although, I also have to say that in Aiden's case, his fuckboy image seems super forced. Given the rest of his personality, it didn't really mesh well with it. It was like he was marketed as one just for the sake of it. I don't really know how to explain it, but it was like him being a manwhore had to be shown and said way more than it needed to. The fact that he was a complete simp later kind of added to that.

    You would have thought once would have been enough to establish that he's a manwhore, but then you also have that scene where there was a naked girl with whipped cream in his bed even after he met the female lead...and it was like the fuck was I a witness to? I'm not saying he needs to be obsessed with the female lead from the start, but like we also didn't have to see all that. It's not something quirky or funny. It's just gross and icky. How am I even supposed to have positive thoughts about him? Not that I would because no thanks, I'm good.

    Anyways, his manwhore thing aside, like I said above, he's just like every other college hockey player. To prove my point, let's run down the list shall we?

    Lives in a hockey house ✔︎

    Fuckboy ✔︎

    Dreams of being in the NHL (duh) ✔︎

    Basically insults the female lead in their first meeting ✔︎

    Loves to party ✔︎

    Has a group of 4-5 friends who will also eventually get their own story ✔︎

    oh and bonus for these next few because these happen at least once in hockey romance series:

    Opening scene with a random woman ✔︎

    Captain of the team ✔︎

    Signed to an NHL team by the start of the book ✔︎

    Weirdest Golden Retriever Energy ✔︎

    Acts like a fuckboy but is kind of deep with the female lead from the start ✔︎

    Some trauma related to his parents ✔︎

    Essentially, Aiden Crawford is a mix of Garret Graham from The Deal and Nathan whatever his last name is (I would like to say it's Hawkins, but don't quote me) from Icebreaker. I didn't like either of those male leads, so it might not be a surprise that I didn't like Aiden either (don't look at my review for The Deal cause my opinions have changed and I just haven't gotten around to fixing that review).

    The point that I lost it with him was the line below.

    "It’s going to be because you know the only guy that can satisfy you is me."


    Bold for someone who gave a mediocre performance at best. I'm being super nice because whatever the fuck happened was cringey, low-key unnecessary and slightly unpleasant on my eyes. Brother, eughhh.

    I have so much more I want to say about this guy, but I'm about to lose my mind the more I think about him and I need a change in scenery so let's talk about the female lead next.

    Summer Preston. My God, do I have beef with this bitch.

    She's so passive aggressive and it's not in the best way. I could totally relate to a black cat female lead who acts "spike-y", but she took it to the extreme. Like at one point, you gotta find it annoying when you see yourself do it over and over again. Basically, everyone was bending over backwards trying to accommodate for girlypop and she just did not care.

    Homegirl hates all hockey players because her father was one and she doesn't like him. Actually, that's low-key wrong, let me correct myself, it's because she thought that he prioritized hockey over her. In her defense, yes, he did and I could see how she felt like he abandoned her, but like why hate on the sport and the people who play that sport. I mean just because your father wasn't a good person because hockey took over his life, doesn't mean they're all like that.

    And the thing is, for someone who has that deep dislike for hockey player, she barely showed it around Aiden even at the start (aside from the first scene where they see each other). Which is confusing because what was the purpose of the whole trauma thing in the first place if you were going to fold super quickly? It was very underdeveloped at the start and then it kind of fizzled out throughout the middle only to make an appearance towards the third-act area.

    Oh, and she's half-Indian and I have problems with the portrayal of Indian (South Asian woman in general) in mainstream media. It's either that they're shown as a complete good girl where they are super innocent, they act like a banshee, or they're stuck-up. And then the thing is that her being Indian wasn't really shown. I'm not expecting stereotypes, but there wasn't much to go off of. We had a couple instances of Butter Chicken, her mom calls her "Meri Jaan" once, her sister's name is Indian and so is her mom's, and then she calls her grandparents "Nanni and Nanna", but aside from that, she was basically a white person. Well, duh because she's half white, but I didn't see any real reason for her being Indian.

    Also, she says her sisters were born when she was in high school, so how are they 15 already? The math is not adding up. Even if she was 14 when they were born, she would have to be 29 years old for them to be 15, so like was that a typo or was that a miscalculation because she was 20?

    And, then I decided let's also make a list for the female lead while I'm at it since there are some basic qualities that females in hockey romances have:

    She doesn't go out ✔︎

    She only has like 2-3 friends ✔︎

    Typical oldest sibling portrayal ✔︎

    Bonus if they have any of the below, and she had all of them:

    Hates hockey players ✔︎

    Daddy issues ✔︎

    Younger siblings who had life better ✔︎

    “Just so you know, you’re ruining my hair-wash schedule.”


    Girl, what? I don't think he really gives a fuck. Like what are you on?

    “I have five, ten, and twenty-year plans.”


    In this economy? It would be great if we could make it past this year lmao.

    “Summer. Like the season.”


    This gave me flashbacks to Shannon, like the river.

    We stopped at an Indian place by Dalton that Aiden swore had the best butter chicken.


    What is white people's obsession with butter chicken? Like, OMG. Please diversify your tastes, there is so much more to Indian food than Butter Chicken. I can guarantee that once you try other food, you'll forget all about Butter Chicken. No offense if you like Butter Chicken though.

    0
    comments 1
    Reply
  • Carthage commented on gmoneyyyyyy's review of Collide

    8w
  • Collide
    gmoneyyyyyy
    Apr 15, 2026
    Collide
    1.0
    Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:

    i’m sorry but i truly do not think i can say one positive thing about this disjointed mismatch of plotless chapters that somehow can be labeled a “book”

    0
    comments 1
    Reply
  • Carthage commented on ririreads's review of Collide

    8w
  • Collide
    ririreads
    Jan 08, 2026
    Collide
    1.0
    Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:

    DNF at 46%
    Hated the characters and couldn't understand how Aiden was so obsessed with Summer after meeting her once.

    2
    comments 1
    Reply
  • Carthage wrote a review...

    8w
  • Collide
    Carthage
    Jun 23, 2026
    Collide
    DNF
    0.5
    Enjoyment: 0.5Quality: 0.5Characters: 0.5Plot: 0.5

    I'm sorry, but it's a no for me.

    1. "Her eyes are darkening" "i didn't realize i was holding my breath"
    2. flimsy plot held together by my dwindling will to finish reading the book just because i started it
    3. Too obvious an exposition which isn't baked within the story well enough that it takes you out of the zone
    4. Characters....aren't developed at all
    5. I honestly and genuinely don't understand how the budding of the relationship even took place. How did he even come to like her?
    6. If he's starting to fall for her, we should be able to at least see it but 🤷‍♀️
    7. Grammar mistakes "your" instead of "you're" 🫠
    8. The dialogue they each have inside their head (narration) isn't realistic and if it is then he's ew.

    So no, i am not finishing it.

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • Carthage TBR'd a book

    8w
    The Poppy War

    The Poppy War

    R.F. Kuang

    0
    0
    Reply

    Carthage TBR'd a book

    8w
    The Lion Women of Tehran

    The Lion Women of Tehran

    Marjan Kamali

    0
    0
    Reply

    Carthage wrote a review...

    22w
  • The Night Guest
    Carthage
    Mar 15, 2026
    The Night Guest
    1.0
    Enjoyment: 0.5Quality: 1.0Characters: 0.5Plot: 0.5

    I'm sorry to say that it was so unsatisfying. I couldn't relate to the main character at all. Every choice she made, pissed me off. I do not like the ending. It makes no sense. I didn't understand the point of anything that was happening to her. I didn't understand why or how it was happening to her. Then again, if she had made different choices, maybe light would have been shed on the source. [ONLY THE NEXT PHRASE IS A SPOILER] I know it's psychosis. It's not supposed to make sense; It's just not satisfying in a book to have no answers or no satisfying ending (happy or otherwise).

    I didn't understand the point of the story or even the plot (?). Thankfully, it was short in length so I didn't waste too much time.

    0
    comments 0
    Reply