
Nakoa | 35 | đłď¸âđ | IndigiQueer Nerd (KÄnaka Maoli) | they/them | Demi/Ace đ Exploring stories across genres and perspectives đ BIPOC voices & Queer stories matter here IG @ nakoa.needs.books
11866 points



4.34 average  ¡ 95 reviews
Click a segment to filter

A Psalm for the Wild-Built (Monk & Robot, #1)
Becky Chambers

Hi, everyone. I really don't know where I should put this post or where it belongs but I don't really know where else to put it. So I'm sorry! If anybody wants it removed I can do that if you just ask! A couple weeks to months ago I posted something asking for a recommendation for books. It ended up blowing into this whole thing because some people felt that I was unfairly excluding the LGBTQ+ community by asking for books that excluded those characters and I wanted to say that I'm sorry that I posted that. It wasn't nice of me to do that and I was being extremely immature with how I responded to some of your comments. While my beliefs haven't changed, I shouldn't have done that and I know it hurt a lot of you. When I look back on it now I cringe with how I acted. I'm really sorry, everyone. I wanted to directly message the people who originally commented as to not bother the rest of PB, but since we don't have that, I didn't know where else to post. Another thing is that most of you guys were being very kind and understanding and, at the time, I didn't grasp onto that. I'm truly sorry, you guys!
Hi, everybody. Right after I posted this I had to go, so I just got back on and saw all the comments. I didn't think how it would disrespect the LGBTQ+ community if I posted it during Pride month because I had been thinking on it for weeks, and had time and the opportunity to post. A lot of people are also commenting about the fact that I said that it still doesn't align with my beliefs. I said that because I didn't want to be deceitful and make it sound like I had now accepted it. I understand that my apology might not do anything to fix the situation, but I wanted to do something to at least try to. ( I can delete the post by the end of the day or tomorrow morning so people can see my edit).
KanakaWordsmith commented...
I think thereâs a category error happening here that we need to name directly.
As queer people, our identities arenât moral positions or âbeliefsâ we hold about ourselves. Theyâre lived realities. Framing who we are as something that can be judged as âmorally rightâ or âmorally wrongâ collapses identity into ideology, and thatâs where distortion tends to start.
We can acknowledge that people will have personal feelings of approval or disapproval, but thatâs different from assigning moral wrongdoing to our existence. Moral frameworks are typically meant to evaluate actions that affect othersâharm, coercion, exploitationânot who someone is.
The comparison to selfishness doesnât really hold either. Selfishness is a behavior that can be observed and changed. Being gay or trans isnât a behavior or a stance we take; itâs not something we are âdoingâ in that sense.
And âitâs just my opinionâ doesnât soften the impact. Claims about the inherent wrongness of queer and trans identities have historically been used to justify exclusion and harm, even when expressed in a calm or abstract way.
So the distinction matters: this isnât a question of competing moral claims about whether we should exist. We do. The real issue is how long people insist on turning that fact into something to debate.