avatar

Rosemaryfell

Daphne πŸ¦‹ This is just another reader who studies history, supports Palestine, loves ghibli movies and grew up watching Atla. Now i just live through stories πŸ‡΅πŸ‡Έ

8942 points

0% overlap
Badges19
Justice for All
Fever Dreams & Strange Realities
Queer Horror
My Taste
Our Share of Night
Immaculate Conception
The Bell
Velvet Was the Night
House of Hollow
Reading...
The Trespasser
0%
Sorrowland
0%
The Remains of the Day
0%
Girl Dinner
0%
A Fire Endless
5%
Vicious
0%
The Buffalo Hunter Hunter
16%
An Academy for Liars
0%
Ninth House
0%
Sorcery of Thorns
0%

October 2026

Small Boat

3.31 average Β Β·Β  300 reviews

Click a segment to filter



  • About club posts for recommendations from pre existing listsπŸ’Œ

    (I am fully aware this is bound to be a controversial opinion, I don't mean to target any comment or user in any way, I deeply wish to hear the general feeling about this)

    As someone who has been occasionally using the PB app for around half a year now, it's more than common to see new people coming and asking for recommendations on a specific niche Great, amazing, let's get the education starting!

    The community is growing and people are loving it here But every other recommendation post that I see is often met with some polite rejection and links to a number of lists>> Now lists are great and there are many for every taste but they don't always work for a personalized recommendation. First of all there is already a huge chunk of them for one person to see them all of they don't have the time to spend too much time on the app. The most popular ones are also pretty overcrowded with more than 50 books in there which can be overwhelming or just not helpful if someone wants something specific

    And as the experience grows you get familiar with the app and the users, you will find people who you connect with their tastes and trust their judgment or see their posts πŸ’— For now (at least to my update of the app I don't know if there is a feature available overall) personal messages are not an option, posts like these are often how users get better involved with the fandoms and others. I just feel like the experience gets a little shaky when all the comments are gesturing to a list without recommending even a book from there. The intention might be good and to be completely honest I have found many of my favorite lists through chat. Thanks for reading all that if you did btw

    42
    60